Thanks for the replies everybody! I believe the scratching was done when I dropped my keys into my pocket and pulling the keys out, my pockets are deep so the keys never touch my knives, unless its on the down or up. I am going to buy another Navaja brand new and probably only wear it on special occasions, which I don't like to do, I believe knives are meant to be used and don't have 'safe queens'. But to me, this knife is something special, I really want one and want it to stay beautiful. I might buy two, one to keep safe and one to use, not sure yet. I do like the idea of hand rubbing the bolsters, I was even thinking about trying to stonewash the bolsters and blade, but I'm not sure how this particular knife would look. Ideally, I would want to remove the bolsters and have some all carbon fiber scales made for one Navaja and all G10 scales for a second, but I don't know if that's possible, I'll have to ask around.