- Joined
- Nov 19, 2011
- Messages
- 222
What are the pros and cons of bone vs. wood handles on khukris? BTW - that's not a loaded question. I imagine there are trade-offs either way.
-
The BladeForums.com 2024 Traditional Knife is ready to order! See this thread for details: https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/bladeforums-2024-traditional-knife.2003187/
Price is$300$250 ea (shipped within CONUS). If you live outside the US, I will contact you after your order for extra shipping charges.
Order here: https://www.bladeforums.com/help/2024-traditional/ - Order as many as you like, we have plenty.
Bone vs Wood handles
- Thread starter roninsgrips
- Start date
- Joined
- Mar 27, 2010
- Messages
- 4,988
Welcome Ronin!
I haven't scored any bone handles but i fancy antler more than horn.
If you are going to the use that khukuri with bone handles for heavy work i would suggest it's not a good idea.
It would be tricky to put a rat tang, let alone riveted but i will opt for model with light application - skinning or kitchen use.
Wood to me is still the best in terms of ergo. I can DIM (DO IT MYSELF) but not on bone.
Speaking of that some horns have amazing texture, especially when it's carved. This is a classic example of a high quality khuk handle:
I haven't scored any bone handles but i fancy antler more than horn.
If you are going to the use that khukuri with bone handles for heavy work i would suggest it's not a good idea.
It would be tricky to put a rat tang, let alone riveted but i will opt for model with light application - skinning or kitchen use.
Wood to me is still the best in terms of ergo. I can DIM (DO IT MYSELF) but not on bone.
Speaking of that some horns have amazing texture, especially when it's carved. This is a classic example of a high quality khuk handle:
Last edited:
- Joined
- May 8, 2005
- Messages
- 289
Bone, IMO, isn't as resistant to impact from heavy use as the grain structures inherent in wood, but it definitely looks good!
Stabilization can help a lot, comparatively, but for a working khukri, dense grained wood is the way to go!
BTW, if that's you, George, if you were to get a dealer membership here, I'd get to pimp the hell out of you in Gadgets and Gear without me getting booted for trolling!
Stabilization can help a lot, comparatively, but for a working khukri, dense grained wood is the way to go!
BTW, if that's you, George, if you were to get a dealer membership here, I'd get to pimp the hell out of you in Gadgets and Gear without me getting booted for trolling!
There are many threads about Horn Vs. wood on this forum....the search function is your friend.
( at the top of the forum on the right, you will see a tab that says "search this forum". Just enter your terms and Voila.)
Many say that Wood is better for hard use khukuri.
I find that properly cared for horn is just as durable.
It served the ornery buffalo it came from quite well.
Wood is probably better suited on khukuri that are used in cold climates.
( at the top of the forum on the right, you will see a tab that says "search this forum". Just enter your terms and Voila.)
Many say that Wood is better for hard use khukuri.
I find that properly cared for horn is just as durable.
It served the ornery buffalo it came from quite well.
Wood is probably better suited on khukuri that are used in cold climates.
- Joined
- Nov 19, 2011
- Messages
- 222
Hey Keith!! Yeah, it's me but I'm not selling anything. Guys have always said how amazing the HI khukris are and when I finally started digging I was amazed. I'm hoping to pick up a few. It really looks like they have a soul vs. being mass produced.
It sounds like bone is mainly for looks and wood is for use. I'm really more of a functional-user kind of guy so I will probably steer towards wood.
It sounds like bone is mainly for looks and wood is for use. I'm really more of a functional-user kind of guy so I will probably steer towards wood.
- Joined
- Nov 19, 2011
- Messages
- 222
Thank you all. I'll do some searching. It didn't dawn on me to do that. Doh!
Don't let the looks fool you.
Horn and bone is very tough. I havent broken a horn handle yet and the majority of my collection is Horn.
- Joined
- May 8, 2005
- Messages
- 289
Well, since you're here, you have direct contact with Yangdu in case anything should happen. Of course, if you did manage to break an H.I. khukri, I would be impressed. Or suspicious of steroids!
You could make a mold of the handle, though. Work your magic if the handle ever got dinged. Guaranteed you'd never have another problem!
You could make a mold of the handle, though. Work your magic if the handle ever got dinged. Guaranteed you'd never have another problem!
- Joined
- Nov 19, 2011
- Messages
- 222
I was thinking on the maintenance side - I know how to care for wood, repair it, etc. but I know virtually nothing about bone if it chips how to condition it, etc. I'll use search too.
As Holmesmade mentioned, I doubt the kamis would use a material that wasn't fairly well suited for the task.
I have to confess, I have a super-CAK arriving either today or Friday from Yangdu. I've been lurking for almost two weeks now trying to learn.
Hi Roninsgrips,
I was in the same situation not long ago, trying to figure out what I wanted. Originally, I thought I wanted horn for my grips. But I got the same Super CAK by Bhakta Kami with satisal handle and I LOVE it. I then got a Sirupati with horn handle, which is absolutely beautifu. But I think I prefer the wood from the standpoint of stability in the hand. By the way, you won't be able to put the Super CAK down, it's so impressive
I was in the same situation not long ago, trying to figure out what I wanted. Originally, I thought I wanted horn for my grips. But I got the same Super CAK by Bhakta Kami with satisal handle and I LOVE it. I then got a Sirupati with horn handle, which is absolutely beautifu. But I think I prefer the wood from the standpoint of stability in the hand. By the way, you won't be able to put the Super CAK down, it's so impressive
- Joined
- Nov 19, 2011
- Messages
- 222
I'm really excited about it. Not sure how I will explain it to my wife, but am selling off some old stuff to cover the bills.
Welcome roninsgrips!
Hooflex is probaly best for conditioning horn, some also keep it hydrated with mineral oil. Otherwise the care is much the same as wood. It works much the same as wood, although it does stink when you try to grind or sand it with power tools.
Hooflex is probaly best for conditioning horn, some also keep it hydrated with mineral oil. Otherwise the care is much the same as wood. It works much the same as wood, although it does stink when you try to grind or sand it with power tools.
- Joined
- Nov 19, 2011
- Messages
- 222
Hooflex is a good tip - thank you. I grew up with horses but never put the hoof care and bone handle care together!
Folks, I really appreciate you taking the time to explain this.
Folks, I really appreciate you taking the time to explain this.
- Joined
- May 8, 2005
- Messages
- 289
Poke around the other sub-forums, too! The amount of info contained on this site is phenomenal!
Shop talk in the general knife maker's discussion forum could be a great resource for grinders, sanders and other tool supplies. A lot of the ideas I've had were based on stuff I learned here!
Shop talk in the general knife maker's discussion forum could be a great resource for grinders, sanders and other tool supplies. A lot of the ideas I've had were based on stuff I learned here!
- Joined
- Nov 19, 2011
- Messages
- 222
Will do. Thinking about potential projects for next summer already.