Book Review: Pananandata

Smoke

Gold Member
Joined
Oct 14, 1998
Messages
2,592
History and Techniques of the Daga, Yantok, Balisong, and Other Traditional Weapons of the Philippines by Amante Marinas Sr. Available through Amazon and Paladin Press. 150 pgs 9 Chps, B&W photos.

The BD
Intro
Chp 1 Origin of Pananandata/Basic Concepts (weapon types, target chart)
Chp 2 Balisong (background, 3 openings, a pic of a giant balisong)
Chp 3 Rigid Weapons (short staff, 31" stick, bolo, single stick, knife, cane, ring, tonfa)
Chp 4 Half Flexible/Half Rigid Weapons (nunchaku, short horsewhip)
Chp 5 Flexible Weapons (rope, chain)
Chp 6 Throwing Weapons (throwing knives)
Chp 7 Blowguns (loading techniques)
Chp 8 Empty Hands ( defences against punches, kicks)
Chp 9 Sparring

The latest in the Pananandata series, Marinas adds his personal history to the book, which
luckily has bigger pictures than the older series. If you're experienced, you can skip
Chapters 1, 2, and parts of 3, which has an average of 4 techniques shown per weapon.
Overall, the blade and impact weapon techniques aren't as complex or centered on closing up
to corto range as the Arnis Lanada
book and if you understand palasut and hubud, you'll understand the more exotic weapons
shown.

The cane (tungkod) section is where it starts to get interesting, Marinas shows defenses against grabs, sticks, and knives. The tonfa (hawakan) section showed medio range defences against both sticks and knives, while the rattan hoop (dikin) section alternated it's approach between 1 and 2 handed moves. Tabak-toyok (nunchaku) alternates between long range swinging and short stick application, while the whip (latigo) was all about long range.

The rope or lubid section shows defenses against punches, kicks, knives, and a rear bear hug. This was also the most detailed in terms of technique and strategy The moves are of a different flavor than the Rope Fighting book, not as much on closing and choking or throwing. Marinas also covers the basics of knife throwing and using it as a possible strategy against multiple opponents. The Blowgun section was pretty straightforward and short, focusing on mostly history and technique instead of actual application. Empty hands had 3 sections on defending against punches, kicks, and sticks. The Sparring section mostly has advice but shows some free sparring sequences as well, lots of jumping attacks you don't see often in FMA. Interestingly, Marinas feels that G. Silver and J. Swetnam's advice on weapons and sparring is the way to go.

A good reference for all levels but intermediate and advanced folks will get the most out of it.

_____________________________
The preceding review does not reflect the views of the owners of this site. As always, books and/or videos are not a substitute for
actual hands on instruction by a certified instructor.
 
excuse me, i dont ususally do this, but i would be very careful believing mr marinas in his writings. we already had this thing with daniel insantos book having incorrect informations about the philippine martial arts, and i will not keep my mouth shut when it comes to the many created things, that mr. marinas puts in the magazines.

things, like the "hawakan" (which is a tagalog word, not made up) is just someone trying to say "yes the philippine culture/martial art has that too". i dont feel like we needed to claim all the chinese and japanese weapons. yes, we do have some of the same things, but if you make up something, do not try to act like it came before you. what this does is make the rest of us who do not have those technqiues you created, look like we have inferior art.

your style does not need an ancient history to have a credibility. latiko at balisong? what a imagination!

and you cannot hide behind dialects. yes, we have many dialects, but the country of the philippines is not so big that one area will have a martial art, and the rest of us never even heard of it. especially when you went around (or your master) went around fighting in "death matches".

we are already suffering in this martial art because of phony master's, phony certificates, and phony stories. we do not need phony history to make it worse.
 
"latiko at balisong? what a imagination!"

Are you saying that whips and butterfly knives are NOT part of Filipino martial arts?
 
Smoke.

Thanks for the excellent as always review.

I enjoyed the book and found it informative and interesting

Bill
 
of course a whip and the balisong is used by philippine martial arts. but if you read some of his article, he talks about the combination like it has a history in the art, and was passed down to him.

now, if there is a combination, it is in his style, so just say that. i am not going to just shut up because "well it COULD have been in the philippine martial art a long time ago". i am not just going to believe anything people say, thats all. especially when it comes to his stories.
 
Who cares if Marinas claims that "latiko at balisong" are not some sort of recorded history in Philippine Arts.

I can pick up a shoe in my left hand and a pen in my right.

I can call it "sapatos at boll pen" and it will still be FMA because it's not so much the weapons, but the hand movement that will distinguish it's authenticity.

Even though I'm not a big on Marinas, at least he's out there writing and publishing books to promote the art instead of coming on the internet to criticize.
 
promoting the art is good. i promote the art by teaching it. i teach it in the most honest way i can.

i am assuming you are filipino, that is good. but i assume you did not study in the philippines because you dont get offended by incorrect information being given about our patriotic arts. i do, and thats one of the reason i am here, to go against incorrect information, i dont believe that just any publicity is good publicity. so i dont go on the internet to criticize, if you read enough of my postings you would see that.

but then, some people get there feelings hurt when they found out what they are told about the philippine martial arts, is not true, like the fact that filipino muslims do NOT practice, KALI, which is an american "FMA".
 
Mabuhay!

Manong Kuntawman,

Yes. I was not trained in the Philippines, so of course my
perspective to the art has different degrees of sensitivity.

As far as the term "Kali" is concerned, I know that Punong Guro Edgar Sulite would refer to the arts as Kali, even Tatang had no problem with his art being called, "Kali" Ilustrisimo.

So i never understand why people have a problem with it being called "Kali"

Why do people disagree with the word KALI?
 
Doesn't "hawakan" just mean to hold in Tagalog? Manong is a male term used to address older men in a respectful way.
 
versjkd, yes you are right.

manong is a tagalog word for "sir" or "gentleman", but its used like a title. you can be just an old man in one place, but a manong in another, because the people know you and respect you. you can also say "tatang" (visayas) or inang for a woman (this is what my students call my mom).

oh i forgot, you dont have to call me manong 9thanks for the respect) because i am too young (33).
 
Back
Top