bought a unknown custom knife with no marking

Joined
Dec 12, 2015
Messages
2
Hello everyone, im pretty new to knives and have a few questions about this knife i bought while on vacation in Texas. I know its Damascus steel and has a bone handle but what type of knife is it exactly? I was planning on using it as an all around survival knife to keep in my pack when im hiking/camping/fishing. the blade thickness is 3mm and 9 inches full length, blade length is 5in. Also, i know bone handles tend to have a "smell", but this handle smells like the knife spent the better part of its life in a pig pen covered in excrement. I know the knife isnt new, it has some wear on it and i have read that the smell wears off over time but i just dont think this is the smell everyone talks about. Is there anyway to safely clean this handle without ruining the bone? ive tried all kinds of soaps and ive even used some hoppes 9. im at a loss with this stinky beautiful knife. help please


image4%202.jpg
[/URL][/IMG]








 
With no makers mark and a strange design, I would guess you got yourself a Pakistani damascus special.

Not sure how to rid the smell from the bone with the handles attached to the knife, someone else may have some ideas on that or it will probably go away eventually.

Hang around here for a while, you will learn all you need to know about knives. You can also buy quality handmade user knives here for very good prices!

-Clint
 
Like Augus and Bill said above, potentially a paki knife and the scales are definitely horn of some type.
Just because it may be paki however doesn't mean it will be bad though. Best bet will be to use it a bit and you will find out if you want to take it out into the field with you or not. Welcome to the world of knives ;) As for getting rid of the smell I have no idea. The safest albeit longest way I could think of would probably be sun bleaching, but that would only work if the bacteria causing the smell is located on the exposed surface.
 
Hello everyone, im pretty new to knives and have a few questions about this knife i bought while on vacation in Texas. I know its Damascus steel and has a bone handle but what type of knife is it exactly? I was planning on using it as an all around survival knife to keep in my pack when im hiking/camping/fishing. the blade thickness is 3mm and 9 inches full length, blade length is 5in. Also, i know bone handles tend to have a "smell", but this handle smells like the knife spent the better part of its life in a pig pen covered in excrement. I know the knife isnt new, it has some wear on it and i have read that the smell wears off over time but i just dont think this is the smell everyone talks about. Is there anyway to safely clean this handle without ruining the bone? ive tried all kinds of soaps and ive even used some hoppes 9. im at a loss with this stinky beautiful knife. help please

Try essential oils ?
 
Have you tried vinegar? Might cut the smell, it's probably from fresh horn being worked. It may not be all that old.
 
Whatever is causing the smell is inside the pores of the grips. Since cleaners and solvents have not done the trick, as CSGKnives says, you are left with sun bleaching doing the job. Consider that sheep's horn can have some pretty bad animal odor to it (goat can be even worse) and that it may simply need time to evaporate the smell out. I say leave it outside for a few weeks (not in the rain or snow, of course) and let the open air have its way with it.

I agree that this is probably a Pakistan-made knife, but I've seen some impressive bushcrafting done with knives like that. Be careful with batonning and chopping, work up to heavier tasks over time, and eventually give the knife a workout. You will no doubt have more impressive knives (better provenance, more reliable track record, etc.) in the future if you continue with this hobby, but this one will teach you a lot. Give us a review as you get to know it.

Zieg
 
i want to thank you all for the helpful tips. the knife may or may not be of quality, i really wouldnt know, but i think its absolutely beautiful. How would you guys suggest i test how good the quality is? I will try the sun bleaching, although finding a spot to do it will be difficult because i live in a condo in a city lol. id like to run this knife through some hurdles before i decided to keep it with my pack.
 
i want to thank you all for the helpful tips. the knife may or may not be of quality, i really wouldnt know, but i think its absolutely beautiful. How would you guys suggest i test how good the quality is? I will try the sun bleaching, although finding a spot to do it will be difficult because i live in a condo in a city lol. id like to run this knife through some hurdles before i decided to keep it with my pack.

Do you have a balcony or even a window you can open? Given that it has a lanyard and bail, you could conceivably hang it outside your door or window for a time. Just mark your calendar or you're likely to forget it!

The first thing I would do to run it through its paces is to set some tasks to it. Carving, whittling, and stripping branches. Don't know where you live, but start with evergreens. If you're into bushcraft, make a small fire using little bits of wood you've prepped with the knife. When you get home, clean it, dry it, and hang it back outside. Get ready for Christmas (or recover from Chanukah) by breaking down some cardboard boxes. They'll play hell with the edge, and watch out for metal staples, but it will give you an idea of how the blade performs in cutting and in sharpening. If you aren't good at sharpening, this will give you a chance to practice. Read up here and watch YouTube vids on sharpening principles and techniques.

And if the smell starts to abate, bring the knife in for kitchen chores. Hope you're not a vegetarian, because a good task to run that knife through is to quarter a couple of chickens and then spatchcock a couple more. A five inch blade is a good size for those two chores. Go after a couple heads of cauliflower and broccoli, too (they are particularly good tossed in a little olive oil and salt and then roasted under 375° for about 20 minutes or lightly browned and go great with the chicken you just prepared).

Another thing people neglect is to practice chores that seem to be too light for the knife. But these can give you an idea of how a heavy knife really feels in the hand. For instance, some knives are real beasts for their size while others are really handy at even larger dimensions. Go after some tomatoes. Open some envelopes. Cut some tags off new clothes. Slice bread. See what works and what doesn't.

Then, once you know how the knife handles with these chores and isn't going to snap off at the handle, you can start going he-man on it with fun things like light batonning (stay away from cured hardwoods and watch out for knots--you know there's a whole cadre of folks here who think batonning is evil, so read their posts to get the pros and cons of it because it's a great way to destroy a blade that isn't up to the task), cutting soda bottles, and so on. Just remember it's not an axe, no matter how well it might do choppy-violent-conan-the-barbarian-type tasks. Personally, I get a lot of joy out of putting a cabbage up on a fence post and practicing knife-fighting skills on it. Cabbage is cheap and it flies all over the place when the leaves begin to come apart. As long as the knives can handle the swing and you don't hit the post you'll be fine. A rake cleans up the mess nicely. If you're in the woods, you can leave it for the skunks, raccoons, rabbits, opossums, and porcupines.

Don't ever throw this knife. I have a gut feeling it would break.

Then, after a month or two of this, you have yourself the makings of a first-rate knife review. Post your thoughts and your experiences, sprinkle in a few choice photos, including ones of friends holding their noses at the stinky horn scales, and your post see will a ton of traffic.

Have at it, D'Artagnan!

Zieg
 
Last edited:
I grabbed one of those in an online "auction" a few months back for like 20 bucks just for kicks.
It stunk so bad I wouldn't even put it in my hand till I wrapped the handle with duct tape and the blade steel was so soft and filthy it plugged up my ceramic stones immediately and the burr just kept folding over.
Rubbish is what I expected in this experiment and precisely what I received.
Pitched it in the recycling.
 
Never had cause to give a knife a vinegar bath. I assume that it will rust the bolster, blade and tang.
 
Never had cause to give a knife a vinegar bath. I assume that it will rust the bolster, blade and tang.

These bone or whatever handles smell worse than a west Texas stockyard on an August afternoon.
But agreed, that soup can damascus will rot in a vinegar bath.
 
The knife looks like the sort thats sold by a guy named Rody Stan.:rolleyes: Really, check it out on the evilbay.
 
I agree, if the steel won't hold an edge, it's not much good.

Just a side comment here. None of my bone, or antler handled knives has a bad or horrible smell.

I can only imagine what sort of road kill they used!

Sorry, I don't have any sage advice to rid the horn of the smell of rotten death!
 
Back
Top