Bradley knives

Joined
Apr 5, 2006
Messages
200
It seems like bradley knives don't resell well on the forums.
Every-time someone lists one...me included there seem no interest.
bump price drop, over and over ......

Is there something wrong with these knives as the resale is non existent.
Anyone else notice this
 
I guess it's because they're just nothing new and there are lots of other options in the price range. Plus they're made by Benchmade, and Benchmade's resell for a decent bit less for the most part as well. The Bradley Alias, for instance, is a pretty nice knife and good alternative to a Sebenza if you can't afford one (not that it's close to on par with the Sebenza, but a good choice for half the price). However, it kind of seems a little bit overpriced. It has those lines coming down the sides of the blade like lots of Benchmades (not actual grind lines) which makes it obvious it's completely CNC'd and not hand finished at all, not even to polish off those machining lines that will actually make a zipping sound if you run your fingernail along them. That's one thing I didn't care for on the Bradley. They also have an extremely flimsy lock bar like many Ti frame lock Benchmade's. That was the kiler for me. My Alias has a good bit of lock rock and just squeezing the knife lightly will flex the lock bar up and down against the blade tang. Just a super thin, super flimsy lock bar with very little lock bar face to contact the blade tang.

Because of this, I think it's a little overpriced and definitely not worth the new price on the secondary market. For about $40 more, you can get a Pro-Tech TR3 Manual which has almost the same design but is much closer in fit and finish and robustness compared to the Sebenza. Same exact blade shape, better handle shape and just outstanding fit and finish as well as a very sturdy design and lots of nice little touches with the design. Also, you can get a Zero Tolerance 0550 for the same price as an Alias and it will be much more robust with better fit and finish and even though it's a lot more of a hard use knife, it's still almost as good of a cutter and great EDC with a much better value and better quality in my opinion. I don't know, these are just some of my thoughts.

If Benchmade would touch up the Alias' blade by grinding off those machine lines and giving it actual vertical grind lines (getting rid of the texture and at least making it look hand ground or hand finished), cut the lock bar much thicker and giving it a big, flat lock bar face like the Pro-Tech TR3 Manual, and maybe gave got rid of the blue hardware and replaced it with some polished hardware as well has upgrading all the hardware, I think it would be a much more popular knife.
 
It seems like bradley knives don't resell well on the forums.
Every-time someone lists one...me included there seem no interest.
bump price drop, over and over ......

Is there something wrong with these knives as the resale is non existent.
Anyone else notice this

I think this is true for the vast majority of knives ever made & sold. Few knives, whether full custom or factory-made retain their original sales value, let alone go up in value.

Also, people chase trends, so what you paid premium for today is going to lose it's lustre a few years down the road with few buyers.

Buy knives because you like them, be prepared to sell them at a loss, or learn how to wheel & deal by trading. Be surprised, not expectant, when a knife goes up in value.
 
Very well put ADragg and CWL.

I do believe in the trend thing.. As it seems like tactical is in for now.


Thanks again
 
IIRC, the Alias I had some problems, but I think the Alias II was a much better knife.
Which one was ignored on our Exchange?
Sonnydaze
 
It is the Alias 1... It seems like an excellent knife to me. Smooth as a baby's behind.......
 
Ti framelock with s 30v steel and excellent fit and finish for $200 is overpriced? What knives do you buy in that price range: are they really superior then - I am genuinely curious.
I had to wait for a while for this knife to come back in stock in the online store I use. And I am happy that I have got it for the price. It is probably not talked about so much here: not as much as some new or some cool tactical models, or some "super strong tanks" which appear to be the fad these days. But I personally do not see anything wrong with the knife, price included!
 
They are fairly expensive knives, and relatively plain looking. Well they look about as plain as a Sebenza but the Seb has some magic appeal that keeps their pricing high. Most used Benchmades sell for quite a bit less, so that brings the pricing of the Bradley down too. ZT knives sell for more but they are more elaborate looking and they are in vogue right now.

I bought an Alias 1 because I like the size and the blade shape. I like the knife and have it in my EDC rotation, but I wouldn't place its value significantly higher than my Benchmades. My Barrage 581 with M390 steel was a lot less than the prices I see on most used Alias I's.
 
Ti framelock with s 30v steel and excellent fit and finish for $200 is overpriced? What knives do you buy in that price range: are they really superior then - I am genuinely curious.
I had to wait for a while for this knife to come back in stock in the online store I use. And I am happy that I have got it for the price. It is probably not talked about so much here: not as much as some new or some cool tactical models, or some "super strong tanks" which appear to be the fad these days. But I personally do not see anything wrong with the knife, price included!

I don't mean to offend anyone who owns one and I do think it's a decent knife. I own one myself. I don't it's "way overpriced" or anything. I just mean overpriced mildly. I think a lot of Benchmades in general are a little on the pricy side for what they are. They're quality knives but they just feel a little too mass-produced for what they cost. I realize they're built in the USA but these are just my impressions. I think the Alias should be more along the prices of most of their other models. Maybe in the $150 range. I think most of their knives should be shifted down by $20-$50 or so, honestly. I just think that the Alias is a little bit overpriced because it gets into that $200 dollar range and for the same price or a little more, you can get a better knife in my opinion. Like I posted earlier, the ZT 550 and Pro-Tech TR3 Manual are better choices for around the same price. The Pro-Tech is a bit more, but completely worth it with quite a bit better fit and finish and a better design. I think the Pro-Tech TR3 is exactly what the Alias should have been. Fixes each of the problems I have with it. I also just feel it's a bit overpriced because it's a knife with flaws, in my opinion. Mostly that the lock bar is just extremely flimsy. I can literally grip the knife lightly and the lock bar will substantially move up and down, scraping vertically up the blade tang. The detent on mine is also EXTREMELY weak. It does have a nice smoothness.

It is a pretty nice knife and it does have a good look and feel and a great blade shape that makes for a great EDC. I just wish the lock bar was at least half again as thick as it already is. I also wish they'd use polished hardware instead of trying to get the Sebenza anodized blue look (they could at least use a darker blue more like the Sebenza. The blue looks sort of cheap and faded to me). The other main thing that would make it much nicer to me is if they grind of those machining lines that make it completely obvious the blade wasn't even touched by anyones hands (completely CNC'd), replacing the cheap look with some nice looking grind lines, such as on most Spyderco's, and giving it a more hand-made look/feel. I think they should do this with a lot of knives, because a lot of knives have that texture. Benchmades just cost too much to feel and look like they haven't been built or even finished by hand at all. All just my opinion.
 
IIRC, the Alias I had some problems, but I think the Alias II was a much better knife.
Which one was ignored on our Exchange?
Sonnydaze

Correct me if I'm wrong, but the I and II are built exactly the same, the II is just a smaller scale. The Alias II is the smaller version of the Alias I, not a second edition of the Alias. It's just the equivalent of the Small Sebenza, but they're still the exact same knife. I think there's only ever been one design for the Alias. I don't believe there's an upgraded version?
 
Hey guys just wanted to add to the alias 1 lock bar experience. I got mine second hand from a local knife shop ("the classic edge" near richmond Va) for an incredible deal but later noticed a little lock rock issue. I sent it into benchmade where they actually replaced the entire locking scale and fixed the rocking issue. Not more than a week later after cleaning the knife the issue reemerged. I suppose it's possible i didn't reassemble it properly but i gave it a couple more tries and was unsuccessful. I think benchmade voids the warrantee if you take the knife apart so I guess it was a mistake to perform maintenance in the first place. Lame right? Got a small insingo sebenza on the way to show the bradley whos boss.
Cheers
 
Don't know why you had trouble, I would guess they might do better if they did everything them selves and was a true mid-tech or whatever CR and Hinderer are. I personally do not own one, but handled a few at GP Knives and and handled some CR knives (also do not own any) and was much more impressed initially by the Bradley regardless of price. It was smoother and felt better in hand. I am not after either one of those right now, but would consider an Alias first personally. I would however have a little more pride of ownership with a CR knife than a Bradley.
 
A high pricetag might make people think twice and skip over the item. Especially if it has a few blems on it.
 
Hey guys just wanted to add to the alias 1 lock bar experience. I got mine second hand from a local knife shop ("the classic edge" near richmond Va) for an incredible deal but later noticed a little lock rock issue. I sent it into benchmade where they actually replaced the entire locking scale and fixed the rocking issue. Not more than a week later after cleaning the knife the issue reemerged. I suppose it's possible i didn't reassemble it properly but i gave it a couple more tries and was unsuccessful. I think benchmade voids the warrantee if you take the knife apart so I guess it was a mistake to perform maintenance in the first place. Lame right? Got a small insingo sebenza on the way to show the bradley whos boss.
Cheers

That's almost exactly what happened with my Alias, except I didn't disassemble it at any point. Mine is so bad the lock slips out of place if you apply even pressure to the spine. :barf:
 
Ti framelock with s 30v steel and excellent fit and finish for $200 is overpriced? What knives do you buy in that price range: are they really superior then - I am genuinely curious.

http://www.spyderco.com/catalog/details.php?product=421
S30V? check
Ti RIL? check
Top notch F&F? check
Price? $50-70 less.

FWIW, the Bradley Kimuras are often considered the best "bang for your buck" flipper available today and tend to re-sell well. It's just the folders that seem a bit over priced. Also the Bradley Mayhem (which is also a bit pricey). YMMV. If it's worth it to YOU, that's really all that counts.
 
Back
Top