broke my Bowie knife...

Joined
Jul 31, 2002
Messages
2,954
The sad little 'smilies' don't do justice to the profound agony I've endured. This was my favorite knife; it was also one of the first big knives I made, and I poured my heart and soul into it. Though I started making it 5 or 6 years ago, I only finished it a few months ago. It was my constant companion ever since.

It actually happened about 2 weeks ago. My knife had just claimed its 16th and 17th raccoons with applomb. (If I include the mortally wounded coons that I merely finished off with this knife, the numbers would be 3 or 4 times higher) But number 18 was a bittersweet victory. As the coon tried to run past me, I slowed him with a quick cut somewhere in his hindquarters. I then reared back to deliver the death blow with all my adrenaline enhanced might. Unfortunately, I failed to notice the steel bar laying beneath him in the grass. There was the familiar sound of my blade ringing as it cut, coupled with the ghastly harmony of flesh and bone being cleaved. And then, that gut-wretching "clank". I intantly knew from the vibrations that something bad happened. I tried to cut the coon again, but my blade was now nothing more than a club. (many don't realize that a nick in an otherwise razor sharp edge will render a chopping/slashing knife useless) A notch about 4 mm deep had been chipped from the edge, and when I got home, I also noticed a crack running a half inch up into the belly of the blade.

I cried for two days. No kidding.


I first tried to grind out the notch, hoping that if I was careful enough, the crack wouldn't grow. Of course I was wrong. Within another week, the last 3 1/2 inches of the tip snapped off during some cutting.

I've now reground the blade into a classic Rio Grande Camp Knife profile, and it's still around 17 or 18 inches long overall. But it's just not the same. My beloved friend, my Bowie, my Son, is dead. I can't believe how much performance was lost along with that point. The thing just won't cut. I don't understand it. I guess the harmonics just got thrown off too much. You know what's really weird? It actually feels quite a bit heavier now. When I first handed it to my wife after I reground it, that was also the first thing she said. "It feels heavier now. Kinda clunky."


I'm slowly moving past my mourning, and turning my attention to designing a replacement. When I origionally conceived my Bowie 6 years ago, I chose stainless steel (ATS-34) since I wanted a big display knife. Years later, when I decided I'd get more joy from *using* it, I was doomed to failure. Next time, I'm going with a good high carbon tool steel, and finding a good smith to differentially heat treat it.
 
the possum,


Sorry to hear that..:(

But on the good side you will get to make a new one...:D
 
Why on earth would someone hunt or trap racoons and use a Bowie knife. When I was a kid I trapped hundreds of coons, beaver, rats, etc etc. Never once used my knife to kill one. Would ruin the hide if I had. Single shot .22 was used from a distance especially on coons and fox. I might be missing something but seems a bit of overkill if you will excuse the pun. Keep'em sharp.

PS just make a new one.
 
I'm sorry for your loss. A handmade knife is hard to replace. I feel terrible when I break/loose even a cheap production piece. I can only imagine how I'd feel if it was a knife I'd made myself.

Let me get this straight, though.

You've been running around southern Illinois with a 21" long bowie knife, hunting racoons using only a knife?

Umm.. I'm not against hunting or anything, and I pretty much hate racoons, but.. I've never heard of anyone intentionally hunting racoons using just a knife.

Each to his own, I guess.

Out of curiousity, what do you do with the racoons once you've bagged them?

-- Rob
 
sorry to hear that you broke the knife. We do get attached to things that work really well. but, knifing 'coons up close and personal...well, on word on that..RABIES!
 
#18 bravely sacrificed himself to deploy the steel bar and end your reign of terror...for now... ;)
 
Originally posted by baraqyal
Let me get this straight, though.

You've been running around southern Illinois with a 21" long bowie knife, hunting racoons using only a knife?
-- Rob

Ummm... Yes.
I really don't mean to turn this into a discussion about my hunting style. I've typed many pages trying to explain this to non-knife people over at shooters.com.
I have a .45 on my hip, and usually a heavy loaded shotgun of some sort in my hands. But there are numerous places around the farm where it simply isn't safe to shoot. Thus, the knife. And as you probably noticed, this kind of hunting is fast and up close, not like sniping them out of trees. When an angry coon is about to jump on your face, there's no such thing as overkill!

Never really cared much for traps. Just not my thing I guess. Some people like to hunt with bows, some with blackpowder guns, etc.; I really enjoy hunting with a knife. I didn't think that concept would be so hard to grasp on a board full of knife nuts. :)
And to be honest, I guess I really shouldn't even call this hunting. I do not do it for sport or for the fur. I am trying to eliminate destructive vermin from around our farm. They are overpopulated and make a mess of everything they can get into.
 
possum - Better hope the racoons don't find that missing 31/2 inches of blade steel lying around. Pay back is a bitch. Watch your back. :D Sorry about the knife though.
 
I understand possum's reasons for his hunting style. There are situations where discharging a rimfire or centerfire firearm is not in one's best interest but vermin populations still need to be controlled. I've had problems before with feral cat and even squirrel populations exploding to the point where they HAD to be culled back. Thankfully, Mr. pellet rifle sufficed. I'm not brave enough to try to take out an angry racoon or even a cat with a knife. Maybe a squirrel, but they are hard as Hell to chase thru the trees.:p Little bastids are FAST!
I kind of envy folks who are brave enough to take game/vermin like feral hogs and even racoons with a knife.:eek:


Possum,
I'm very sorry to hear about your loss. Use this oppurtunity to make yourself an even better Bowie and HAPPY HUNTING:).

All the best,
Mike U.
 
Your "Bowie knife" sounds more like a heavy dagger/short sword. For your next one I'd definitely stay away from stainless steel and stick with a steel more suited for sword. Should be lots of info on that here. Out of curiousity, what were your blade dimensions? length, width, and thickness?
 
Originally posted by the possum
But there are numerous places around the farm where it simply isn't safe to shoot. Thus, the knife. And as you probably noticed, this kind of hunting is fast and up close, not like sniping them out of trees. When an angry coon is about to jump on your face, there's no such thing as overkill!

Duh. A farm. :) Hehehe, for some reason I just kept visualizing the suburbs of St. Louis or Springfield.

That makes total sense.

I hate racoons. They remind me of giant, angry rats - only a little smarter and slower.

I hope you get 'em all.

Watch out for rabies! :eek:

-- Rob
 
Back
Top