According to the Buck website, both have blades of 420HCand both are made in China. I have neither, but I do have another Chinese made Buck, the "Colleague". I found my "Colleague" to have good fit and finish, a solid lockup, good edge retension for the steel that they used (440A). I have read other threads about Chinese made Bucks and most of them are complementary on the fit & finish and overall quality. Most seem to feel that the price is more than reasonable for what you get. I certainly do.