Buck Slimline - Very Lame

Joined
Jul 28, 2011
Messages
5,782
Got told day before that we were going to a b-day party for a nephew.

He works in the (light) trades and fishes. We discussed just getting him a gift card for a big box fishing/hunting store but I suggested I get him a knife. My wife agreed as it was more "personal".

I didn't have any of my own modified preferred traditional knives laying around (not Buck) and I figured that being a young guy, he would prefer something more modern looking.

So I trotted down to my local *Mart store and got him a Slimline.

He was very happy with the gift and he's not a knife knut so as far as the gift thing went, it went well enough I guess. He's happy and I suspect the knife will be serviceable for a long enough period that he won't think less of me for it.

But towards the end of party, I asked him if I could see it (since it's sold in bubble pack it's impossible to inspect ahead of time).

WOW is all I can say. I've handled a good number of lock backs in my day but never, ever have I seen a sloppier one. The blade had a ton and I mean a ton of vertical play. The lock bar bounced up and down like a trampoline and the even the nice big pivot rivet/pin thing moved up and down visibly in the frame.

Yes, I know I theoretically "could" inspect the knife before buying it but a) the *Mart store could barely find the time to unlock the case for me, much less let me cut open and inspect the items before buying them and b) I'm busy and was rushed and really have an expectation that I can buy an item like this uninspected.

And yes, I know I could return it to the vendor but a) my nephew won't be disappointed too much and I certainly wasn't going to be a bummer to him by telling him the knife I just gave him was junk and b) I have no expectation that any of the others at *Mart were going to be any better.

And yes, I suppose I could take back the gift from my nephew and send it to Buck but at this point, it's just not worth the time or postage. There are other brands that offer better modern folders in this price point.

You know, I told myself I would steer clear of Buck but, for the sake of old memories, I gave them another try. Will be a very, very, very long time before I try another.

Seriously Buck, your stuff is weak.
 
Wow... that sucks. I don't have too much experience with Buck knives as the only one that I have is a Vantage, and that is one nice little knife. Maybe you would have been better off getting him a Kershaw Skyline or something like that. I would send an email to Buck and let them know what you experienced just to see what they say about it. I would think most companies want feedback on thier products, both good and bad. Just my $.02!
 
Seriously Buck, your stuff is weak.

There's a bad apple in every bunch. :D
I would have taken the time to open the box and inspect the knife. I've received a few knives in the mail, and I won't name companies(it wasn't buck), where I had to send the knife back for an exchange.
 
I've had my Spitfire in my pocket for the last couple of weeks, almost the same knife and it's fine. The design seems to tend towards "lock rock" for lack of a better term but I've yet to see how it impacts the function of the knife. Actually I just tried my Spitfire and it does have vertical play. I don't see where it effects the function at all as it locks solid, blade is centered, still cuts what I want it to. It just has vertical movement if you grab the blade and handle and move it in that direction. Nothing side to side.
 
Last edited:
It must not be too lame if you are willing to stick your nephew with the knife and not let Buck or the store you bought it from make things right....and then if course there's the obligatory hate thread....
 
I have a Buck Vantage and a Alpha Dorado in S30V and got my wife a Spitfire. All were nice knives. :thumbup: Sorry you didn't get something you liked. It happens sometimes.;)
 
My slimline has the same thing, the entire pivot assemble moves slightly in the handle. But FWIW, it does not seem to really effect the use of the knife.
 
Back
Top