Bucklite Question

C

CAD

Joined
Jan 11, 2006
Messages
2,091
Hi all,

I'm interested in the first and second generation Bucklite 422's

Which handle is thicker and which one do you like the best....First or Second Generation? And why?

Thanks

Chris D:D
 
The first 422's had a wee thicker handle. The handles were different, just the feel of them. A slight more weight and a solid feel with the first. But they were radiused and some of the pivot pins were brass. The handles were smooth on the inside and the handles of the second generation had holes 'drilled or formed' on the inside. Which allow debris to collect in them. With use they'll develop blade wiggle. Which is no big deal for me, as I'll carry it anyway. The item I liked about the 2nd generation models was it came with a lanyard hole. A feature I've always liked. You could also get them with a fuller hollow grid which improves their cutting performance. But the 2nd generation had 420 steel and the 1st could be found with 425 steel. A plus for the 1st. They all were clip points which I've never liked and caused me to shy away. Another item I like about them is their pivot pins have heads on them. Which the 110 has never had. So, some features I liked about them, others I didn't. DM
 
David Martin said:
The first 422's had a wee thicker handle. The handles were different, just the feel of them. A slight more weight and a solid feel with the first. But they were radiused and some of the pivot pins were brass. The handles were smooth on the inside and the handles of the second generation had holes 'drilled or formed' on the inside. Which allow debris to collect in them. With use they'll develop blade wiggle. Which is no big deal for me, as I'll carry it anyway. The item I liked about the 2nd generation models was it came with a lanyard hole. A feature I've always liked. You could also get them with a fuller hollow grid which improves their cutting performance. But the 2nd generation had 420 steel and the 1st could be found with 425 steel. A plus for the 1st. They all were clip points which I've never liked and caused me to shy away. Another item I like about them is their pivot pins have heads on them. Which the 110 has never had. So, some features I liked about them, others I didn't. DM
Click to expand...

Thank you!!

Chris D
 
Speaking of bucklites. I am able to get a 424 right now brand new for $15.00. Is this a good knife and for that price.
 
Ryan, welcome. There are some Forum rules you need to be aware of. Our level of membership does not allow us to ask the value of a knife. Moderators frown on such activities that others pay for. Consider deleting your last sentence.
My thoughts are, a 424 is a good quality knife anyone would be happy with and I wouldn't even think about it. DM
 
CAD, here is a photo showing the two generations. The top model being a 2nd and the bottom a 1st. DM
 
(426's)The top knife is a 94 as it came out the Buck plant doors. The bottom model I made the blade from a Selector Skinner blade and had it mounted in the early handle. The bottom model had a clip blade in it with no year date. The blade it has now is a 91. So, 425 steel. You can see the difference in the 2 handle styles. The top is lighter. Don't get me wrong, I like them and told you both sides of the fence. The bottom is my wife's favorite knife which she uses a lot. The top one being mine has seen a Lot of wilderness country from my pocket. Both have a little blade wiggle. Which some here are OCD about. Both blades are well centered and don't rub on closing. Another item many on this Forum are OCD about. Just in case you had a flavor toward. That's the long and short of your question. Hope this helps. DM
 
David, which do you prefer, the Bucklite or the Ecolite? I have a preference, but would love to know yours.
 
Doc, I don't own a Ecolite. But I believe it has metal liners and I would prefer that to the Bucklites. As long as the pivot pin has the heads. DM
 
The Ecolite doesn't necessarily have metal liners. It has spine and bolster support, but not a full liner.

I like the Ecolites better, personally. It feels like I've got a real knife in my hand...



 
This half liner helps wear and strengthen the knife's support. A full liner would be better but this is a good step. I'll have to find one. DM
 
David, I picked up a ²nd gen 422 for my daughter who needed a light pack knife that she wouldn't feel bad about losing. While the blade looks to be a good blend of staying keen yet is easily touched up, I am not as confident about the thinness of the handle. While Buck would likely cover breakage nobody wants a broken knife on a camping trip. Seems like your confident of yours however. Any further thoughts?
 
I am confident of mine as I put it thru much mileage. Opening cans of beans, whittling fire sticks, sharpening tent stakes, pruning shrubs, cleaning fish, birds and chickens (forcing it thru bones), ect... I took mine (the top knife) on a 3 day wilderness canoe rafting trip and it was the only knife I carried. It and a hatchet. I haven't malleted it thru stuff only pushed it. Nor did I pry with it. I had no thoughts toward will it hold up. DM
 
Here's an example of one with the features I'm speaking of. I've used it for years on mostly the same items as above and it has no blade wiggle. Plus, a blade shape I like and it's light enough. The feature it's missing is a lanyard hole. DM
 
David Martin said:
I am confident of mine as I put it thru much mileage. Opening cans of beans, whittling fire sticks, sharpening tent stakes, pruning shrubs, cleaning fish, birds and chickens (forcing it thru bones), ect... I took mine (the top knife) on a 3 day wilderness canoe rafting trip and it was the only knife I carried. It and a hatchet. I haven't malleted it thru stuff only pushed it. Nor did I pry with it. I had no thoughts toward will it hold up. DM
Click to expand...

All right then, will give it a swing. Thanks much.
 
great thread full of info, thanks y'all.

also David that finger grooved one is gorgeous. classy user....
 
Etymologist, your welcome. Hope you keep visiting and let us know how your trip goes.
jbm, thank you. You're welcome. It feels good in the hand. I like some width to a knife for comfort and the paperstone is durable. DM
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top