Burt Foster Buckeye Bowie

Joined
Feb 28, 2002
Messages
13,348
Burt Foster – an ABS Mastersmith hailing from Bristol, Virginia – is a maker who has been on my radar screen for some time. I had really liked what I had seen of his work in photographs, and perhaps more importantly, many knife aficionados whose opinions I trust and value have spoken very highly of his work.

When this bowie became available, I was more than ready to take the plunge.

orig.jpg


This knife features a 9 ¼” blade of forged and differentially tempered 52100 with an overall length just over 14” . The handle is a solid piece of California Buckeye burl, secured to the full hidden tang with three domed nickel silver pins. The knife can be disassembled by removing those pins – no glue has been used to secure the handle. One thing I have noticed about Burt’s work is his consistent use of premium quality handle materials for his knives. Whether the handle is crafted from walnut, ironwood, maple, horn or ivory, you can be sure that it will be of the “grade-A” category.

orig.jpg


The blade features a flawless hand-rubbed satin finish on the blade flats, set off nicely by a domed or rounded a mirror-polished spine. This type of finish offers both functional and aesthetic benefits: should you need to get your hand up on the spine for a push-cut, the rounded spine will prove more comfortable, and it just plain looks great. Burt credits Tim Hancock as the inspiration for this two-tone finish. The following image shows this feature fairly well:

orig.jpg


And here you can see that the underside of the choil is similarly domed and polished:

orig.jpg


The nitre blued damascus guard and ferrule on this knife are fashioned from a two bar twist of mild steel and nickel. The swirls in the damascus nicely complement those in the wood handle. The following image shows another feature of this knife that I like: the year it was made bracketing the Mastersmith stamp. Since a well made and well cared-for custom knife such as this will likely out-last its original owner, it’s nice to have the date of manufacture indelibly marked on the blade itself.

orig.jpg


When you have high expectations of a knife the chances of being disappointed are that much greater. My admittedly high expectation have been met and exceeded. This knife exhibits flawless fit and finish and has a wonderful feel in the hand – very quick and well balanced. While I would love to see Burt’s take on a large bowie with say, an 11 ½” blade, it is hard to imagine actually needing more knife than this. Case in point, Burt won the ABS cutting competition at Bowie's Hammer-in in Knoxville, TN in 2004 with the knife below that has “only” an 8 ½” blade (the rules allow for up to 10”).

orig.jpg

Image from www.burtfoster.com

Finally, one of the added treats that come with every Burt Foster knife is a top quality sheath produced by the maker. You’d think I would have been smart enough to actually take a picture of it, but alas, no. You can catch a glimpse of it in the photo below from www.rehobothcustomknives.com :

orig.jpg


How much do I like this knife? Well, the matching hunter should be joining it in a few months. :)

Roger Pinnock
 
I like this one a lot. Burt's MS logo with 20 and 05 on either side is a nice touch. The Damascus is really nice. One might predict that the pattern in the Damascus and in the handle could conflict - but the opposite is true. The long clip is just right and the up-curved grind line where the swedge meets the spine is a nice detail.

In fact, I see that little curve as important for Burt's subtle use of an "S" curve moving from end to end of the knife - something my eye-brain connection translates as 'beautiful.'

Really nice pictures too, Roger.

Buddy T
 
I like his camp knives a lot. He is a very personable fellow himself too.
 
I want to say that Burt will be up there with the best Mastersmiths within just a few years, but then I see knives like this one and I'm inclined to say he might already be there.

He's got an amazing frame handled damascus bowie on his website right now that could probably pass for a Tim Hancock knife.

Burt is a great guy and an extraordinarily talented knifemaker. I own 4 of his knives already and that number will only grow. Hold onto this one, Roger. It's an absolute beauty!

(And, as I say just about every time I comment on one of your posts, THANK YOU for sharing these great pictures)
 
Can't add much to what has already been said, but I like it, I like it a lot. I couldn't agree more with the comments about Burts work also from the images I have seen and the comments I have heard, I intend to get a first hand look in June!

Stephen
 
So YOU'RE the lucky SOB who scored that one! LOL!!!!
Roger, that is one of the nicest ones I've seen in a while and now I think I'll have to keep an eye open for one of his... another maker on my list!
Thanks for sharing!
 
While his name isn't as widely recognized just yet, I feel his quality is already there.

VERY clean, EXTREMELY well executed knives, of VERY cool design.

That's what you'll always find on Burt's table at shows.

Add to that, he's such a darned nice guy, and you really can't lose.

Heck, he even made Steven Garsson a little bit nicer. He ought'a get some sort of NLT award for that! :p

-Nick-
 
Congrats Roger,Burt Foster's knives are Flawless.I can't find one single Defect or Flaw on mine,NOT ONE.And I'm probably the worst Nit-Picker around-with the possible exception of Steven Garrson(Sorry Steven,couldn't resist ;) )I like this one alot,is the top clip sharpened or no?Yep I'd definately buy another of Burt's knives in a heart beat. :cool:
 
The combination of materials chosen for this knife go together wonderfully. This is the best looking knife from Burt Foster that I have personally seen, and that is saying something.
 
and an excellent person.

Those of you saying that he COULD be a Great Master Smith have not looked at much of his work lately, that bowie is a top notch example of what he is doing right now.

Let me say, categorically, that you MUST buy the knife directly from Burt, and talk to him. In this particular case, purchasing from a purveyor, or another collector is missing one of the best parts of a Foster knife. That is Burt, himself. Nick called him a nice guy, and he is that, but there is truly so much more to it. He made me feel somewhat ashamed in some things that I have said on the BladeForums, and there are very few people on the planet that could phrase things in such a way, that I would feel that way, instead of telling them to go get f*****d.

I spoke to him on the telephone last night for 1 1/2 hours. I find conversation with him to be mentally and spiritually stimulating, and he probably feels the same way.

He is an artist who has a well formed idea of what he wants his work to look like. There is no mistaking one of his blades as someone else's work. It is clean, well balanced, uses top notch materials and has more than a little of the "gee whiz" factor going for it. His sheath work is designed to complement the knife. The work is not flashy, in the way that anodized titanium or gemstones can add "pizzaz" to an otherwise ordinary, ho-hum knife. The work is breathtakingly precise and solid, the way a BMW 500 series feels to drive. Burt makes knives that you long to hold, and actually feel drawn to use for the designed purpose.

In the fixed blade arena, I do not believe that there are any "up and comers" that do work remotely close to that of Burt Foster, and for that matter, Nick Wheeler. Nick is in something of an experimental stage of his career, but the work is top notch, and he is not even a Journeyman, yet. I believe that they are both, for whatever reason, very similar in style and struggle.

I call it the Don Fogg School of knifemaking, for I have seen no one else whose work is of this type. It is an extremely unforgiving way to attempt to make a knife, and excuses and BS will not make mistakes any less apparent.

For my money, to own either one of their knives is to hold art and craft intertwined in a functional, useable package that makes the purpose that much more pleasant, something that you can actually look forward to, instead of a chore. Or you can just do what I do, and simply marvel at the greatness that is these little wonders.

Best Regards,

STeven Garsson
 
I consider Burt Foster to be one of the best bladesmiths in the world right now. And, that Wheeler kid ain't too bad either! :p :)
 
Thanks for the comments guys. Steven, although I didn't purchase this one directly from Burt he was good enough to take the time to provide detailed information about its construction as well as mapping out what he was going to do on the companion knife. So I didn't miss out on interacting with him.

All the best.

Roger
 
Thanks guys for all the kind words. Steve, by the way, people line up to buy knives from Nick because he never stops experimenting. That's why his work is so aggravating! Just when I think I've got him, he goes off and does something new and blows everyone away.
 
Simply a gorgeous knife. While there are many makers who's work I would like to own, unfortunately there can be only a few I choose to plunk my pennies on their tables. Burt definitely falls into that category. The quality is readily apparent at 10 paces. Nice guy as well, always has time to talk.

I have an "experiment" in progress with Nick at the moment. Here's to hoping he doesn't drop the test tube :D
 
Wow, Burt just keeps surprising me too. That buckeye Bowie is a stunner, the guard and ferrule are a beautiful compliment to the handle material, and the blade is pure elegant simplicity.
Now excuse me while I go handle the knife in my avatar :D
 
I'll second, or third, everything that has been said about Burt Foster.

I have a 52100 hunter on order from him that I am scheduled to pick up this summer when I am back in the States. While the sale will not add much to Burt's financial portfolio, it is symbolically important (for me at least). I have sold knives that I previously owned from more famous makers, and generally refrained from buying any new knives, preferring to invest the money in my own knifemaking tools and education.

But Burt's work is different for two reasons. One, I felt I simply needed to own one of his knives--the urge was pretty much irresistable. Two, I truly feel it is part of my bladesmithing education. Just being able to handle and examine practically flawless work is a great help in improving one's own work.

Okay, three reasons: it is also the most reasonably priced (underpriced?) stuff out there.

Thanks Burt,

John Frankl
 
Back
Top