Buying a new monitor-help

Joined
Nov 20, 2001
Messages
2,600
Buying a new monitor for the mini. I have found flat CRTs ~17" for about 100-130 bucks. I'd like a flat panel LCD, only because My desk is so small, so I'd have to get a smaller one (which is fine), but they're up an additional 100 bucks. 230+ is just way out there, unless they're a ton better. Any advice? I'm generally shopping at Big Box stores. Thanks.
 
I have found flat CRTs ~17" for about 100-130 bucks.
You have to watch those closely. Many low-cost flat CRT monitors aren't what they appear. Often they are a regular monitor with a flat piece of glass on the front.

Sorry I can't recommend an LCD for you. But the hardware forum over at computing.net is the place I'd go to find out.

Best Wishes,
-Bob
 
A monitor is one thing about a computer on which I won't compromise.

My logic: it's what I spend hours and hours STARING AT! I don't stare at my processor, my RAM, or my hard drives....you get where I'm going (though I do have a good looking, glossy black case for all of it). Yes, crappy other components will mess with my enjoyment, but for me, it's mostly what I stare at. So the monitor needs to provide both quality (stuff must "sparkle") and quantity (it must be big so I don't have to "squint").

Some of the nicer flat panel LCD monitors are quite nice (I've seen some crappy ones). Last summer, I upgraded from a 17" CRT to a 19" LCD (though I wanted something larger). I've always been a fan of Viewsonic (having owned a couple CRTs from them in the past...but not my most recent), so I kept them in mind when shopping. Though I paid a fair amount more than you have listed (and about 25-50% more than I'd hoped to spend), I couldn't be happier with what I got. I purchased the Viewsonic VX910. Yes, there are better out there, but I feel this one is certainly worth the extra money. I paid something over $425 (plus tax).

As I said, Viewsonic had always been a brand I've loved, but when I bought, I also wanted to make sure what I selected was actually something that performed well and others liked. I looked at a handful of models on some computer sites. Also, for the past couple years, I've researched almost all of my purchased on Epinions.com. There, the monitor I had selected was well received by a handful of people and the brand was also well rated overall. I'd recommend spending some time poking around their site. Here's the place to start.

Other things on which I won't compromise: shoes (if my feet aren't happy, the rest of me isn't happy) and my eyes (I only have one pair, so I make sure they're working well and in perfect focus).
 
Ron Andersen is a wise man. The keyboard, mouse and monitor are how you interact with the computer.

Still if you're willing to order online, decent 17" LCDs can be had for less than $230. Less than $200 even. Of course you can't be too choosy about brands.

The fact is that a good CRT will always produce a better picture than any LCD. LCDs are taking over the market because of size, power consumption and maybe most importantly, marketing.
 
Start watching www.spoofee.com - they often list good deals on LCDs if you check frequently. Yesterday they had a 17" Viewsonic for $139 after rebates (link) but I think that deal has sold out in most stores.

Ron is absolutely right here - a good monitor is worth its weight in gold; and LCDs do have one big advantage that hasn't been mentioned yet - since they don't refresh the same way that CRTs do, they are much less stressful on the eyes.
 
i have routinely stared at my mitsubishi 22 in crt at 1600X1200 res for 8+ hours a day and left my desk without any eyestrain

my dell 1901 lcd at 1280x1024, on the other hand hurts my eyes after a few hours


with that being said, if your eyes can take it, I can recommend the dell lineup of LCD's for their quality and price(on sale)
 
=Voodoo= said:
i have routinely stared at my mitsubishi 22 in crt at 1600X1200 res for 8+ hours a day and left my desk without any eyestrain

my dell 1901 lcd at 1280x1024, on the other hand hurts my eyes after a few hours


with that being said, if your eyes can take it, I can recommend the dell lineup of LCD's for their quality and price(on sale)


I agree, I have had a Dell 2405fpw for a few months now and I don't regret buying this for one minute! 24 inches of LCD widescreen looks fantastic!
 
If you are buying a professional graphics CRT and have the video card to drive it well, it will be superior to even the best LCD panels. Most people don't have the desktop real estate for a 22inch monitor. They also balk at paying ~$1,000 for the monitor. Those people will never know the joy they are missing if they use a monitor all day or are critical viewers for lesser period of time.

That being said, I find the best LCD's are a good choice for software development and general office duties. These aren't cheap but, you get what you pay for. I have a pair of Samsung's on this computer as I type that were ~$1k a piece 3 years ago. The solid image they provide is worth every penny.

If I had my choice though, it would be a pair of 22" CRT monitors.

If find the current generation of consumer grade LCD panels are very hard on my eyes if I use them for any length of time. What good is a monitor/panel that is cheap if it hurts your eyes.

I will also note that I very sensitive monitor/LCD images. My friend has 20/10 vision and isn't bothered with flicker or eye strain on monitors that will send my medicine cabinet looking for relief. YMMV
 
If you are buying a professional graphics CRT and have the video card to drive it well, it will be superior to even the best LCD panels.
If I had my choice though, it would be a pair of 22" CRT monitors.
The fact is that a good CRT will always produce a better picture than any LCD.

Those are my feeling to, and why I couldn't recommend a specific LCD screen in my first post. I'll never give up my 21" Trinitron, at least not until plasma monitors become affordable.

Perhaps you simply need a bigger desk? :D

Best Wishes,
-Bob
 
I favour Viewsonic too. I have a CRT and an LCD as well. Both are great, although it helps if you have a good video card too.
 
Amen to those putting the monitor at the top of the list of important computing products. Nothing is more important. My favorite is my 19" HP LCD monitor. It is brighter than most and large enough to use a high res mode and still be able to read text. I have a 17" IBM that is pretty good and a 17" NEC that would run in third place. You'd have to see the HP to believe it. The bad news is that it is around $400. Personally, I think it's a bargain.
 
Back
Top