Recommendation? Camillus Eagle Scout Knives

D

DoomisnoDishonor

Joined
Nov 7, 2018
Messages
1
tl;dr: Should I consider Camillus knives, since I know they're 1095 steel, 100% US made, and BSA approved, or are they going to be subpar for sure? Hi all! New here, but I've been blacksmithing and bladesmithing quite a while and collecting knives for years. Now, as a soon to be Eagle Scout, I'm looking for things to ask for as a gift. While in the Scout shop today, I noticed a new set of knives. The BSA has been gradually changing their official knives, and now have a line of Camillus ones with exclusive Eagle Scout inlays. However, from what I've heard, Camillus doesn't make quality knives. Knowing that, I asked about them and now know they are 1095 steel and 100% made in the USA. They also appear to be high quality, with a flawless fit and finish. I also have never had an issue with an official BSA knife. Is there a chance I'm be too critical, or should I look elsewhere?
 
Is Camilus made in the USA? Used to be.
 
I was speaking with my boss about this yesterday. He asked where Camillus was made. I told him in China since Camillus folded in 2007. He showed me a BSA Eagle Camillus knife available online from BSA for $179. I showed him the same knife, without BSA markings/shield, online for $20. I kid you not.
 
We just had a thread similar to this, see if you can find it for other options
 
I'd avoid Camillus. Other, more reputable, makers like Buck offer official Scout models (got my Eagle Scout badge around,1960, if I recall).
 
Get the Buck, it's more knife for the money when you factor in the forever warranty.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top