Can we seperate the traditional folders forum from the fixed blades forum?

Joined
Jun 23, 2018
Messages
328
This is essentially only the traditional folding knives forum. It'd be great to see a seperate category with fixies and machetes. It seems any fixed blade postings get lost in the shuffle of traditionals here and end up mostly in other places ie mfg categories like Becker, Ontario, etc. It's something I'd be pretty interested in.
Thanks
 
I doubt youll get that...


I see no reason for it.

Traditionally/historically fixed blades mean either outdoor/hunting knives, or kitchen knives. Both of which do already have their own areas here.

And if there are so few posts/threads about them that they get lost in this forum, then I highly doubt they're worth a dedicated forum, since this area really does move Verry slowly.

A new area would be extremely tiny and slow for what little content that would get filtered there. IE; if it isnt here, how can it be moved there?
 
Traditional fixed blades can also mean military knives and bayonets, ethnographic knives, vintage or antique Bowie’s, bill hooks, khukuries, machetes and a huge wealth of similar items, which are current scattered all over these forums. Some of it gets posted under Levine, the Sword forum, Traditional knives, General, makers sub-forums (like Himalayan Imports) and just about anywhere else. Where does a discussion on the evolutionary history of the Kris knife, Civil War D-guard Bowie’s, or the esoteric markings found on 18th and 19th century English bayonets belong? These are huge and highly popular subjects for those who enjoy historical knives, that fills entire library’s with published reference books and many museums halls with exhibits. The subject of traditional vintage and antique knives is far broader than the production output of the relative handful of industrial-age pocket knife makers; and yes, they made a huge variety of fixed blades as well.

We probably should have a Vintage and Antique category, under which we can roll in Traditional Folders and Fixed Blades, Swords, and add a Military Knives and Bayonets and an Ethnographic knives section as well.

I get it that delving into historical subjects can drift into politically incorrect areas such as the beauty and desirability of antique Ivory mounted knives, the intricacies and identification of Nazi era daggers, knives carry and use in warfare, or even for headhunting and cannibalism. But, these subjects are already discussed here, they are just scattered all over rather than concentrated where those who have an interest/disinterest in the subject know to go, or avoid.

n2s
 
Back
Top