Chicago Cutlery USA boning/ utility knife ?

Joined
Feb 9, 2008
Messages
5,421
I have an old Chicago Cutlery 61-2 USA made boning knife made of 1095 carbon steel. I like the way it feels in my hand. The blade is thicker than an Old Hickory. Im thinking of using it as an utility knife for fishing and such ,if I can find a sheath that fits it. The knife is very sharp. Do any of you know how the edge would hold up? Will it dull quickly? 1095 steel is used in USMC Kabars . So should I expect this knife to be as hard?
 
My grandmother had one of these as part of a set, and the edge on all of them held up really well, as long as it wasn't abused - which meant none of the rest of the family got to touch her knives.

If you're just cleaning fish, it would probably work okay, but the blade is thicker than any fillet knives I've seen, and is nowhere near as flexible as a fillet knife would be. Thickness translates into more resistance when cutting, less flex means it can be permanently bent if you were to fall on it, or hit something too hard while cutting (hence my grandmother's family ban regarding her knives). Also, IIRC, the handle adds a bit of weight to the knife, so carrying it around for a day, along with all the other fishing gear you have, might get old after a while.

That's my thoughts. This knife might serve well for what you want, but I think a commercial one (Rapala, etc.) would be better.

thx - cpr
 
I wont fillet fish with it. I have knives for that. Its to be used as a multi purpose knife. Its sharper , right now, than any knife Ive ever had. Hair whittling sharp.

2008-10-25.jpg
 
I know what you mean by sharp - Chicago's and Old Hickory's are my favorite brands in kitchen knives; those old carbon blades hold up for a lifetime and then some if you take care of them. Whether it would dull quickly would depend on what you do with it; in my opinion, it will stay sharper longer in the kitchen doing food prep and the like, than it will making fuzz stick & cutting tent stakes out in the woods. One advantage of a good carbon steel like 1095 is that you can sharpen it really well on a small standard stone. I couldn't tell you if it's as "hard" as a Kabar, someone else may be able to answer that one for you.

The bottom line is, your 61-2 would make an okay utility knife; I have several old "kitchen" knives that go camping with us and get a lot of use, though I have my preferences for a shorter, slightly thicker blade. And remember: DON'T CHOP ANYTHING WITH IT. I learned the hard way with an old Russell that these blades are not tempered for chopping. You'll lose chips out of the blade really fast doing that. (My wife is PO'd to this day over me ruining her Russell.)

Regarding sheaths, you might find someone here on the forums who can make a simple kydex sheath for you. The stiffness would help protect the blade. And if nothing else, you can make a sheath out of milk carton plastic and duct tape. I did that more than once as a kid. :)

thx - cpr

ps - by the way, when I mentioned "...if you were to fall on it..." earlier, what I meant was while it was sheathed, not loose. I remember these types of knives from my childhood (smokehouses, pig slaughtering time, etc.), and how the blade could take a "set", in other words a permanent bend, if you sat on it, fell on it, leaned on it, etc. while it was in it's sheath.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top