Chinook--Strengths and Limitations?

[TIZWIN]

My friends--another thread on this forum that discussed modifications to various Spydercos elicited a generous description of the Chinook II from Mr. Cox. His post reminded me of an earlier one he wrote, some time ago, describing the execution of the back-cut with the Chinook. I wonder if he might revive that description and further explain additional usage of this knife, whether defensive or more prosaic and utilitarian. Of course, I invite other admirers of this knife to contribute.

I have owned a Chinook II for about two and a half years. Its superb construction cannot be denied. But it is my impression, possibly wrong, that the knife was designed by Mr. James Keating (and others?) as a defensive, robust folder, meant to facilitate the back-cut.

My concern here: is the knife designed too exclusively around that technique? Does not the blade shape discourage the straight thrust? The handle design does indeed provide a very secure grip, and consequently a very good edge index. However, this same handle doesn't lend itself to reverse-grip-edge-in, in the manner of pikal. Other point-driven methods may not work well.

I'm ready to learn more about the usages of this fine knife. Further questions would include: why no Boye Dent? Is the vaunted lock strength sufficient without it? And what clip mode do others prefer? Tip-up, tip-down, strong side, weak side?

I've got one in my hand at this moment (when I'm not typing), and I'm all ears.

 

[kbuzbee]

Tizwin, I have no doubt you are correct, Mr. Keating did indeed create this design with the intention of a forward grip SD style. It does grip fine (for me) in reverse but the sweep of the blade makes it (to me) less effective than a hawkbill blade in that position.

Mr. Keating's design intentions aside, the Chinook II is a great utilitarian blade and I think most people who regularly carry it value it for it's every day functionallity above (or at least in addition to) any SD function it may have.

If SD is your primary reason for carrying, I would humbly suggest matching the technique you prefer to the design that fits it best. That may be a Chinook II but more likely a Mili or a Pikal or even a Civilian.....

I've carried a knife every day for 40+ years. I use them EVERY DAY to cut or open something. I've never needed one for SD so I choose my EDC for what I know I will use it for. SD is a very distant (read 'but still existant') factor. I suppose, faced with that situation, I should envision the BG as a bag of charcoal or fertilizer and just slice the top off That's a technique I've definately mastered over the years!

Take care, my friend and choose the tools that make your life better.

Ken