Chopping weekend

shortwinger

Gold Member
Joined
Apr 7, 2010
Messages
1,085
This weekend me, my son-in-law Brandon and his brother Afton got out and put some kukris to work. I had two things that had to be done. One, some autumn olive trees have begun to take over a bank just outside my yard and block my view. So they had to go. Then, I am making some new hanging perches for the birds of prey and I needed six straight 8 foot trees of about 4-6 inch diameter.

The olive trees are like a weed and grow very fast. Not only are they pretty tough, they are also springy and diffucult to chop because they give. We brought out one of the Tracker knives I got from Nepal and my HI Bonecutter. The Tracker has a nine inch blade while the Bonecutter is a standard size. Both did a great job biting deeply into the olive tree. I doubted that the Tracker could hold a candle to the Bonecutter but was very impressed and shocked with how well it did. I would say that they went toe to toe for about 30 minutes. We switched back and forth with the two and it was really a tie. Even Brandon was impressed with the Tracker and he has a very nice CAK.

Later we went out to chop the bigger trees. We had the Tracker, Bonecutter, CS Gurkha kukri and a desert version of a Standard Jungle. Certainly this is where the rubber meets the road. We were cutting maple and hickory, the hickory being by far the harder wood with a core that feels like you are cutting through rock.

On the way to the area where we were going to cut, a downed tree about (6 or 7 inch diameter) blocked our path and the Bonecutter made quick work of it. We found some suitable trees and got to work. Brandon had the Tracker, his brother had the Jungle and I started with the Bonecutter. Brandon got the first tree down quicky with the Tracker and I cut it to size just as fast with the Bonecutter. The jungle started to show what people on the forum talk about when people ask for advice on which model they should buy. Nothing anyone can say could teach this lesson like a few hours in the woods!

About a third of the way through a hickory, the jungle began to show why it is not considered a heavy chopper. First it doesn't bite as deeply because it doesn't have the same belly weight. Being shorter, it is further handicaped and it also transmits more vibration. Lastly, because you have to swing harder, you get tired faster, your hands hurt within minutes and you roll the kukri when you strike much more. Once the Bonecutter got into the same tree the difference became crystal clear. Even though this is hard wood, the Bonecutter took deep bites and blew big chunks out with each chop. Once the tree was down I was again supprised when the Tracker made equally short work of the tree.

It was a fun workout and as always, great to get out with the kukris. The all did well but the experience highlights that the kukri is a tool and each type has its own niche. The jungle would excel as a hiking/light camp knife while the Bonecutter and Tracker certainly proved themselves as the big boys on the block. All the blades left the woods with no damage at all to the blades after over an hour of hard chopping. Sorry their are no pics but we were too busy working!
 
Great story, only leaves one wanting for pics...
When you say the BC is a standard size, do you mean the 18" OAL or the 22" OAL (I guess there are some 16" specimens out there too)? Also, do you know who the Kami is? Finally, any damage at all to any of the blades, or do they all pass the test?
Thanks for sharing!
 
sounds like fun.

I'm curious though - how did the CS ghurka perform compared to the HI? Which one would you say performed best OVERALL?
 
When you say the BC is a standard size, do you mean the 18" OAL or the 22" OAL

I think it is about 17 inches but for some reason I am drawing a blank on the dimensions, but 17" is about right. (My allergies have my head in a different universe.)

I am pretty sure the Bonecutter is made by Murali, I will check tonight to be sure and get a measurement for you. And lastly, no damage at all to any of the blades. I didn't even sharpen mine after, just a quick cleanup of the sap with a scotchbrite and some oil.
 
Last edited:
I'm curious though - how did the CS ghurka perform compared to the HI? Which one would you say performed best OVERALL?

We really weren't out testing or doing a manufacturer comparison, we just took out what we had in our trucks and went to work. The CS did good as usual. I have a few different shapes and sizes of kukri and I would have to say that it would be difficult for anything to really outshine my Bonecutter. Even though it is a big kukri it is small and light enough to carry without any noted difference from a BAS type. Because it is so light and traditionally sized (meaning not a monster thick spine) and doesn't have a sever bend in the spine, it is actually a decent cutter, slicer and slayer of watermelons and pineapples. But when it comes time to work it really comes alive. This Bonecutter is a perfect example of; when you feel it you just know it will be good! As soon as you pick it up it just melts into you hand. The balance is perfect and like I said, it chops like a chain saw. So overall the Bonecutter and Tracker did the best. IMHO, the added belly weight of the hand hammered steel seems to help the Nepalese kukri edge past the CS when it comes to heavy work like trees or branches over 4 inches in diameter, especially prolonged work and the CS can also be a little sticky in certain woods. But don't get me wrong, the CS holds it own in everything I've ever thrown at it and I love it.

Please keep in mind that we are on an HI forum so I don't want to get too much into specifics of other manufacturers. This was just about me and some friends doing work and having fun with our kukris. One of the neat parts of this story is that we all "just happened" to have a kukri in our trucks. Have any of you experienced that since you got into the kukri that lots of your friends got them too? Right now, if I had a barbecue, 75% of the trucks would have a kukri in them! A mini Gurkha unit here in Virginia!!!
 
Last edited:
Back
Top