Chosera water stones grit progression/starting set?

Joined
Mar 6, 2012
Messages
909
I'm going to start freehand sharpening on water stones (water stones just appeal to me for some reason, so I'm going for that).

I nearly bought two Arashiyama stones (1000 and 6000) from a US store, but then I found a store in the EU which carries Chosera stones. The reduces shipping cost means I can buy Chosera stones for about the same price as the Arashiyamas, so I think I'm going for that.

The problem I'm having is deciding on which stones to get. I was thinking of getting two stones to start with. One not too course sharpening stone and one finishing stone. I've watched virtuovice's videos where he recommends 400/600-1000-3000 or 400-800-2000 and then onto compounds. I thought I'd skip the courser stone for now and start with a 1000 (or possibly an 800). The 1000 seems like a good start, but I'm not sure which grit to get for the finishing stone. I was thinking 1000-3000, but then I started looking at the 5000 stone. Would that be too big of a jump? I mean, the Arashiyama stones sell in 1000 and 6000.

While I do have strops and will probably finish on them, I'd like to get a good edge (eventually, with practice) straight from the stones, for my own satisfaction :).

Right now I'm thinking about one of these combinations:
1000-5000
1000-3000
800-3000

I'd appreciate any advice on this.

Lastly, what do you think about stones glued to a base? The Choseras come both with and without a base. I've read that stones with a base are less prone to cracking, but many seem to prefer baseless (with an additional stone holder or other contraption).
 
Not sure how much Choresa stones differ from japanese water stones, but I have the latter in the 1000/6000 combo. The 1000 works quickly enough that I dont really need a rougher grit to start with, yet its fine enough that I dont have to work too hard with the 6000 to remove the previous scratches. The 6000 leaves a mirror polish and a very sharp edge. For scandi grind knives, I dont even strop after the 6000... maybe a few passes on plain leather but its not necessary. Not sure how much your looking to spend, but I got my combo stone for about $50 on ebay.
 
Thanks for the reply. Sounds like 1000-5000 would work, then. From what I gather the Chosera stones are just harder and faster cutting Japanese water stones. I'm sure a decent combo stone would be enough for me to start with, but I'd still like to get the "good stuff". I intend on starting out sharpening kitchen knives and scandi fixed blades since I don't have many beater folders to practice on.
 
Yes, progressing from 12micron(chosera 1K) to 2.8micron(5K) is fine for sharpening; however in mind that for mirror finish a 3K in between can quickly reduce 12 microns scratches to 6, it's now easier for the 3micron to reduce 6 to 3micron scratches.

Other grit size in between were recommended by others because the resulting/finishing edge serrated/toothiness that ideal for certain steels & tasks.

Main purpose of strop is to refine & clean the finished sharpening teeth.

Have funs!
 
I see. So it might be better to get 1k and 5k to practice sharpening on and then get a 3k later on when I'm happy with the sharpness but want a nicer finish/speed things up? Thanks for the info.

Edit: I ordered the 1k and 5k chosera without bases (baseless had free shipping and were in stock, otherwise I would probably have gotten with base). Should get them next week (hopefully).
 
Last edited:
Back
Top