Classifying a knife

Joined
Aug 28, 2009
Messages
7,951
Just how do you decide what group a knife falls into? I am not sure how other makers go about their design process, or if they sit down and think to them selves "I am going to make a Skinner" or "a Bowie" and so an and so forth. When I sit down to design the only thought in my head most of the time is "I want to make a knife" or "What will fit on this piece of steel":o

This is what happened with the Dan Seaver Damascus I have, I never really thought of what it would be used for or what category it would fit into, the same thing with my first knife and the two Bowie like knives I have done. I started off with the idea of making a couple of folders when I ordered the steel, but once I got it in hand it evolved into this

DSC02123.jpg


Overall Length: 8 15/16”
Blade Length: 4.3”
Cutting Edge: 4.2”
Handle Length: 4.7”
Grind: Full Flat

Just what would I call this knife? I am trying to do a little write up on it to go along with the knife when I send it out to my brother next week for his birthday. It now has blue dyed birch burl scales that have been shaped fairly thin, but still has a near dead flat top, other then the radius edges for comfort. I am leaning towards the bird and trout class, but am unsure. I don't think he will use it much. He saw the pictures of it and commented on how much he liked it, but once he found out how much money I have in materials on it he said he could never afford it, he's a single dad with 2 teenage boys so money is tight for him. He hunts and fishes when he can afford to get out, but would never buy anything like this for himself.

Once I get the sheath done I will post some pictures of the completed knife.
 
EDC (every day carry)
it is useful for most things folks would use a knife for and will excell at many things
-Page
 
It could easily fall into the 'hunter/utility' category too.
 
Just what would I call this knife?

A great knife for that perfectly cooked steak! What can I say, it reminds me of a steak knife. A really nice steak knife. Make 3 more just like it and you'd have a nice set. Nothing wrong with a great steak knife. It would get used more often than a bird and trout knife.
 
To me the shape/size is in the classic hunter family. Very nice shape, flows really well from handle to blade. That will sure be pretty when all done.


-Xander
 
What type of knife gets top dollar? THAT's the type of knife it is. ;-)

Or... add some cooooool prefixes to boost the price such as:

"This is a one-of-a-kind custom made, gentleman's tactical, san-mai, variable edged, survival, combat, bush, camp, hunting, tanto, water proof, emergency, drop point, bowie tipped, dagger backed, selective ricasso, recoiless, adjustable pitched choil, hand-made polymetalic engineered satin-mirror finished blade with an all natural synthetic, ergonomic, organic, Asian, polyphonic, tropical, Celtic, herbal essence, low-fat, free market, PETA approved, laser carved and inlet handle."

I just think it's a really nice knife.

LonePine
AKA Paul Meske, Wisconsin
 
A great knife for that perfectly cooked steak! What can I say, it reminds me of a steak knife. A really nice steak knife. Make 3 more just like it and you'd have a nice set. Nothing wrong with a great steak knife. It would get used more often than a bird and trout knife.

Well I thought that it kind of felt like a steak knife too:p but it would be one expensive set of steak knives, between the steel and the scales I have about $100 into it, then there is the ime it took me to make just the one:o

What type of knife gets top dollar? THAT's the type of knife it is. ;-)

Or... add some cooooool prefixes to boost the price such as:

"This is a one-of-a-kind custom made, gentleman's tactical, san-mai, variable edged, survival, combat, bush, camp, hunting, tanto, water proof, emergency, drop point, bowie tipped, dagger backed, selective ricasso, recoiless, adjustable pitched choil, hand-made polymetalic engineered satin-mirror finished blade with an all natural synthetic, ergonomic, organic, Asian, polyphonic, tropical, Celtic, herbal essence, low-fat, free market, PETA approved, laser carved and inlet handle."

I just think it's a really nice knife.

LonePine
AKA Paul Meske, Wisconsin

It isn't getting any dollars, its a gift, one that I hope my brother likes:D
 
EDC (every day carry)
it is useful for most things folks would use a knife for and will excell at many things
-Page

It could easily fall into the 'hunter/utility' category too.

To me the shape/size is in the classic hunter family. Very nice shape, flows really well from handle to blade. That will sure be pretty when all done.


-Xander

These seem to fit the knife well, guess I could call it a light utility hunter, good for all tasks
 
You've got to start forging.Then you will be thinking "what can I hammer this into?" and "How many knives can I get out of this piece of steel?"

Doesn't matter what you call it.It's a very nice knife.Your brother will just call it,"My favorite."
 
You've got to start forging.Then you will be thinking "what can I hammer this into?" and "How many knives can I get out of this piece of steel?"

Doesn't matter what you call it.It's a very nice knife.Your brother will just call it,"My favorite."

You know the only time I think of how many I can fit on a piece of steel is when I am ordering for a particular design, other wise its what fits the steel. I don't know whats going to happen if I ever try to make a knife to fit what someone wants:o

As fort forging I don't know if that is in my future or not, it is beginning to look like my elbow surgery didn't take so swinging a hammer might be more than I can do:(
 
You know the only time I think of how many I can fit on a piece of steel is when I am ordering for a particular design, other wise its what fits the steel. I don't know whats going to happen if I ever try to make a knife to fit what someone wants:o

As fort forging I don't know if that is in my future or not, it is beginning to look like my elbow surgery didn't take so swinging a hammer might be more than I can do:(

Listen to your doctor and keep a positive attitude.I wish you the best with your elbow.
 
When I sit down to design the only thought in my head most of the time is "I want to make a knife" or "What will fit on this piece of steel":o
You mean we're suppose to design? Hehehe. I thought we were supposed to just start hammering/grinding and see what shows up twenty minutes later.
 
One of my most popular styles is almost exactly like that. Just make mine about an inch longer and about 1&1/4" from spine to edge. I also sometimes change it from a clipped point to a drop point. Myself, I dont worry too much about classification. I just call them knives. Merry Christmas!
 
This one is .885" from spine to edge, but it isn't sharpened yet, so it could drop a few points by the time I sharpen it. I just dyed the leather for the sheath then its time to glue and stitch. Normally I glue and stitch first, but I want the thread to stay the color it is right now so I had to dye the leather first. Hopefully I will have everything done tomorrow night and post pictures on Tuesday before taking it to the post office to send it to my brother.
 
Classic German hunting knives called 'Nicker' have blades less then 1" wide.
The blade shape reminds me of those
 
Back
Top