cocobolo fighter

Joined
Jan 30, 2004
Messages
4,030
I thought I'd post these pics and see what you guys think. This was my first time to use cocobolo and I like it a lot even though it clogs up belts and sandpaper. It finishes nicely and is pretty hard and oily.

Thanks for looking,
Ray Laconico
 
I really like the knife, but let me give what is my humble opinion:
I think your grind needs to be a little longer, there is too much space between the blade and the guard.
Also, for fighters and smaller knives, where precision is required, I like to see handles that are a little more sculpted. (unless it has a more gripable material on the handle)
 
I think this knife has great lines and is extremely clean as it is. The guard and spacer set up is sweet. Very nice sheath too.

As for honest feedback, I agree with Walking Man. I wanted to add some details to my opinion.

I have a rule that the ricasso / choil needs to be at least 3/4inches long before the sharpened edge starts. This is because I personally feel that where there is a ricasso, there is the oportunity that the user / customer will place their index finger in the ricasso / choil area to choke up. (Its a matter of training and user habits.) Too short and some folks still automatically put the finger in there and get cut (or get their gloves cut up...)

I think for the blade length on this knife, the ricasso is a touch too long. It could be a 1/4inch shorter and it would make all the difference. Its a bout proportion. On much longer, slender blades, you could use a longer ricasso. I have seen some of Tom Ferry's and Jon Christensen's Bowies and Fighters with blades of about 9-10inches with ricassos almost 1-1/2inches long.

Your handle shape looks like it is in the unfinished state. Because there is some taper to the handle, security and grip probably not too bad. Perhaps a bit more rounded over the 4 corners for a more elliptical profile in cross section, particularly in the rear 1/3 of the handle. It lets your pinky and palm "cup" into the grip better. I mention this because I have done very similar work to yours and later realised I could modify the handle without dinging up the rest of the knife by just working on the rear 1/2 - 1/3 of the handle.

Pardon my ramblings, but I hope this makes sense. And of course, no offense intended - your work is darn fine. Jason.
 
WalkingMan and Jason Cutter, Thanks for your input and advice. That's what I like to get when I post my knives. I only wish I'd get more.
Jason, I'm a big fan of your work. You are very talented in making knives and sheaths.
I usually tend to make the ricasso a little long. I guess that's the way I liked it but I thought you guys are probably right so I just finished grinding a 10" blade a few minutes ago with only a 1" ricasso because of your suggestions. What do you think of this one's proporions?
 
raylaconico said:
WalkingMan and Jason Cutter, Thanks for your input and advice. That's what I like to get when I post my knives. I only wish I'd get more.
I would like to suggest that if you want opinions and critism that you emphasize that you are looking for ways to improve your knives and honest opinions. Most people here tend to be very polite, and will not give critisms unless asked for. "See what you guys think" may not bring in the advise your are looking for. I hope that helps!
 
Walking Man said:
I would like to suggest that if you want opinions and critism that you emphasize that you are looking for ways to improve your knives and honest opinions. Most people here tend to be very polite, and will not give critisms unless asked for. "See what you guys think" may not bring in the advise your are looking for. I hope that helps!

I'd ditto that. I guess sometimes, I also have in mind a forumite's attitude to suggestions before I stick my foot in... and then sometimes I stick both feet in.

And that blade looks great. Ricasso size is not even an issue there. Hmmm... its got a little Ed Fowler-ish profile in the forward 1/2 of the blade. Not sure if its just the photo but I really like that type of blade. Now I'm waiting to see that finished up. Jason.
 
Back
Top