Cold Steel Trail Master San Mai Test

Joined
Jun 23, 2008
Messages
1,428
Hello everyone, I'm Drew and I've been hanging around this forum for a while now commenting mostly on outdoor/military fixed blade knives which is what I rely on everyday at work and play.

Wow, I must have been tired this morning when I posted these pictures because I left out the most important part of the intro to a test or review, the description of the knife being used.

This blade is a Cold Steel Trail Master. It has a 9 1/2" convex ground stainless steel blade and a total length of 14 3/4". The blade is approx 1 1/2" wide and 5/16" thick with a clip point and a false edge measuring approx 3 1/4". This particular knife weighs 18.3 Oz. The double guard is also made of stainless steel and the handle is made of a rubber called kraton with a wide lanyard hole near the end. This knife does have a full tang which is covered/encapsulated by the kraton handle and I really enjoy this configuration because it creates a very secure grip even in wet conditions or without the wrist tie. The sheath, (partially visible in one of pictures) is a belt sheath made of nylon/cordura. It has a belt loop and is ambidextrous with the retainer strap able to secure either side of the guard. There is a leg tie also at the end of the sheath. Although this sheath is made of quality material, I much prefer the Secure-ex sheaths that many of their other knives are available in. This is the one minor complaint I have about the setup because it really limits the carrying options of this blade to upright belt attachment only.

There are a couple of things as well which are not so visible in my pictures because of clarity issues with my camera. This blade is made of a laminated 3 layers of steel that CS calls San Mai III, just like a laminated plywood you can see the separate layers when looking closely at either the spine of the knife or near the edge. The outer layers are 420J with a satin finish and the inner layer which comprises the cutting edge is made of a harder stainless called VG-1. I do not know the process by which these layers are combined but I can tell you they won't be separated as this is a very stout blade and there is no conceivable way I could see bending or breaking it with my own two hands or feet prying (within reason).

Another thing which is not so clear in the pictures is the final honing of the convex edge. There is no bevel like most other factory knives which to me means less friction and a stronger edge and an extra hand process which requires skilled attention.
Also it deserves mention that after the chores pictured and quite a bit more sandy, dirty brush clearing there was virtually no distortion and no chipping on the edge and it was still shaving paper the full length of the blade.

My personal opinion of the San Mai blades is very high and I would highly recommend this or any CS fixed-blade knife to any one who needs a sturdy, reliable tool in the outdoors. There aren't many recent reviews on this knife and hopefully mine can answer some questions and help some of you come to a decision on your own knife needs. Feel free to post any questions or comments. Thanks.
 

Attachments

  • Grapes1.jpg
    Grapes1.jpg
    26.5 KB · Views: 256
  • socks1.jpg
    socks1.jpg
    32.8 KB · Views: 283
  • Phone Book 1.jpg
    Phone Book 1.jpg
    48.4 KB · Views: 250
  • Dead Wood1.jpg
    Dead Wood1.jpg
    62.5 KB · Views: 229
  • Diggin' 1.jpg
    Diggin' 1.jpg
    56.4 KB · Views: 236
Last edited:
Still very sharp
 

Attachments

  • Split 'em.jpg
    Split 'em.jpg
    53.2 KB · Views: 118
  • Super Clean.jpg
    Super Clean.jpg
    45.5 KB · Views: 117
  • Timber.jpg
    Timber.jpg
    44 KB · Views: 146
  • Shredder.jpg
    Shredder.jpg
    18.3 KB · Views: 136
Last edited:
I had a sanmai trailmaster for years. The factory edge held up for a long long time. I have since sold it, since I have a bigger, more expensive chopper. The only thing I would change would be the handle material. The krayton tended to get a bit grippy and soft in hot weather.
 
Thanks for the review! The Trail Master has been on my mind for a long time, but when I finally bought one, I went for the version in SK-5 as the VG-1 is quite expensive. May I ask how much you've paid for yours?
 
Great review........I have one that I have had for years, the oloder CarbonV version. I have had it rehandled by the gang at Bark River and Mike and the Gang put their wicked edge on it before sending it back.

They make great blades for customizing and personalizing. How is that SK5 version working for you Morales, I have wondered how the SK5 compares and stands up in use, may have to get another :D

cerberus
 
I got mine for around $275 after shopping around for a long while. Worth every penny. I actually got the TM and a Natchez bowie with the money I had been saving for a satin Battle Mistress. Perfect compromise of size/weight have made this knife my favorite outdoor companion.

Cerberus, when the time comes, I too will be sending in the TM for a maroon micarta, I didn't know the BRKT took on mod projects. That makes it easy to decide, they are extremely friendly and helpful people every time I've called. Maybe you could post a picture, I really like seeing mods on the CS blades.
 
It is funny that so many of you mention the handles on the Cold Steel Knives as being a down side to an otherwise nice blade.

I had been saying this for years and then about ten years ago I started doing something about it and ended up fixing a few of them.

DSC01469a.jpg

palmerTM7.jpg

tmtnto.jpg

TMatak21.jpg

DT04.jpg

DSC01066.jpg

CSTMwood.jpg


Besides the poor grip, cheap appearance and durability issues there are other good reasons to get rid of the rubber handles.

Every single one of them that I strip the rubber off of looks like this or worse even brand new out of the box.
ShimpTM01.jpg
 
If I may chime in. I love the Trail Master, and I am in favor of getting them rehandled. That does make a world of difference. In fact it was vjb.knife who did mine and it is holding up great. As a matter of fact, the first picture that he posted here in this thread is of mine.:D When you get it rehandled it is like having a brand new knife.
 
VJB, I see you've added a bit more girth on your modifications. That is the #1 complaint that there is with the handle I've read aside from "looks cheap". I've read another report on tang corrosion on the Carbon V blades as well. This fellow here was also reworking an old handle for a friend. http://www.britishblades.com/forums/showthread.php?t=40844

This is also my all time favorite mod on one of these knives. Not to take away from the time and effort you put into crafting your beauties VJB. Thank you for your added input. I especially like the 1st picture cause you kept the coffin-shape handle.

Just to continue with more positive I enjoy the factory kraton for its added grip and coffin shape. The rubber handles keep the cost of these knives (IMO) well below what the blades themselves are worth and I don't find them to be too small/too "grippy" for my hand. In fact, having the thinner handle helps relax my grip and prevent fatigue.
 
Last edited:
If I may chime in. I love the Trail Master, and I am in favor of getting them rehandled. That does make a world of difference. In fact it was vjb.knife who did mine and it is holding up great. As a matter of fact, the first picture that he posted here in this thread is of mine.:D When you get it rehandled it is like having a brand new knife.

Hey JCS,

Great to hear that you are liking the knife and that it is holding up well. I hope you enjoy it for many years to come. I liked that handle as well.
 
I got mine for around $275 after shopping around for a long while. Worth every penny. I actually got the TM and a Natchez bowie with the money I had been saving for a satin Battle Mistress. Perfect compromise of size/weight have made this knife my favorite outdoor companion.

Cerberus, when the time comes, I too will be sending in the TM for a maroon micarta, I didn't know the BRKT took on mod projects. That makes it easy to decide, they are extremely friendly and helpful people every time I've called. Maybe you could post a picture, I really like seeing mods on the CS blades.


If you go over to their forum, they have now outsourced all mods to a third party for the bark river handle mods, I am not sure how that effects other knives. the guy that mike has doing it now does awesome work, and he has Mikes blessing and recommendation, so that speaks volumes of his work.

VJB...that recon scout looks awesome btw....

I will try and get some photos up of the rehandle.

cerberus
 
How is that SK5 version working for you Morales, I have wondered how the SK5 compares and stands up in use, may have to get another :D
I don't have a Carbon V version, but a BK9 in 0170-6C. So far I can't really tell the difference between both steels. At the moment I'd say it's more about blade geometry than steel in terms of performance. I'm gonna run more tests on these two blades and see what happens.:D
 
Back
Top