Collection- On Going Reviews, Impressions, and Comparisons

Joined
Mar 5, 2009
Messages
2,206
I'm starting this as a kind of Inventory of my collection as well as to give my thoughts on each knife in my collection, as well as to give comparison shots to others, this way if a member is looking for a comparison between two knives I happen to have, they can see that I have them and ask for my comparisons and contrasts of the two or at least just a comparison shot. I'll start with pictures and then move on to some short to long thoughts on each depending on how much experience I have with the particular knife.

First the Axes, Machetes, and Saws, basically anything sharp, that's not a knife.
Inventory:
Condor Bolo Machete
I've had this one for awhile, but haven't used it much. While I like the blade thickness for durability, it definitely makes it quite a bit heavier, more suited for things like saplings and thicker vines as opposed grasses/bushes. I really like the blade shape of this one, didn't come very sharp from the factory, but was easy to put an edge on. I don't really care for the handle, the plastic isn't all that grippy, if I were using this all day I'd definitely want a wrist loop, I feel because of the extra weight I would tire more, and with the extra forward weight it could potentially swing out of ones hand easier. I also got the leather condor sheath which I really like I need to order the Condor sheath for my golok as well.
Condor Golok Machete
This one I've actually gotten to use quite a bit recently on two hikes in the snow, I absolutely love the weight, balance, and especially the handle. The ball on the end of the handle makes for a very comfortable and secure grip, it also seems to make it easier to use the wrist technique to avoid fatigue your whole arm, sharp and thin enough towards the tip cut thinner grasses, but the middle will easily cut through 1.5-2in branches in one swing. Stays sharp decently well, light enough to not be tiring. This is what I keep in my woods bag most often.
Cold Steel Kukri
This came super dull and the grinded edge was painted over, took awhile to get and edge on it, haven't really used it much, may have to take it out on my next outing.
Bahco Laplander Saw
I was lucky enough to find this at a local gun shop on clearance for $9 about a year ago. I've used it quite a bit in the last week or so, cuts easily and quickly. Definitely money well spent. This is another Item I keep in my woods bag along with the golok and Bravo-1.
Sven Saw 15"
Haven't used this too much, just once car camping. One thing I do notice is that because the teeth on the Sven saw are bigger than the Bahco once it gets going it really chews through the wood fast, but it is definitely more difficult to get going and get started again when it binds, I prefer this saw for larger diameter wood, which makes me think I should have gotten the 21" instead.
Gransfors Bruks 25"
My girlfriend got this for me for Christmas last year. Goes through wood really well, came with a decently sharp edge, though it was noticeably asymmetrical, after sometime sharpening it was even and shaving sharp. Love the handle, very comfortable and ergonomic. Cuts through wood well, and not bad at splitting despite the narrower head.
Wetterlings 19"
I was very pleasantly surprised by this axe, the finish is right up there with the Gransfors, the hammer side of the head is finished unlike the Gransfors, which I like, and the finished cutting edge goes farther back, the grind was also even on this one from the factory. The handle finish is different, slightly more grippier which I don't like because it doesn't slide through your hand as you swing as well, but not enough to notice really. If I were to buy another axe in a different size say 13", I'd probably go with the Wetterlings because of the cheaper price, yet IMO equal quality to the GB, you're just giving up the 20 year warranty.


IMG_2052.jpg


Machetes Comparison:
IMG_2053.jpg


Axes:
IMG_2054.jpg
 
Last edited:
Fixed Blades:
Inventory:
Bark River Bravo-1 (A2)
I absolutely love this knife, I've really been using it recently comparing it to a Mora for wood working. I was actually expecting the thin scandi grind to do better with wood, because I thought the thicker Bravo-1 would just not be able to bite in as well, but it turned out to be the opposite, the Mora did as well as I expected, but the Bravo-1 surpassed it, it just really digs in and take nice large chunks out the the wood. The handle is VERY comfortable, I thought because its smooth it wouldn't be very grippy especially when wet, but using it in the snow and dropping it into the snow while I was using the saw or golok, made no difference in how well I could hold on to it. It has good edge holding, and feels as tough as a tank. The one small down side so far is that it has developed a couple rust spots after being put into a wet sheath and put away for a couple weeks (didn't know it was wet, probably just some drips that didn't get blown out), however they were easily removed with some 800 grit sandpaper in about 10 seconds.
Benchmade Rant 10505 (N690C0)
I was lucky enough to find this knife at a farmer/ranchers store on clearance for $35. I really like the steel bolster and pommel as well as the steel instead of the usual 440C version. I think this was an older version. Great for the price, however after using it today on some wood carving I don't really like and it performs on wood, I mean it does fine, but the edge feels thin like you wouldn't want to twist it too much if you got it stuck into the wood too deep. However I think it would do extremely well as a hunting knife used for butchering, skinning or gutting.
ESEE Izula (1095)
Since adding the micarta handles for the Izula I like it 100% more, and I liked it quite a bit when it was just cord wrapped. Great little alternative to a folder for tougher jobs. I keep this in my edc bag. I also recently got the pocket/belt clip add on to the sheath which I really like, BladeHQ is releasing a "Venom Green" version soon it seems I'll have to pick up one of those as well, though I might have to dye the handles black on that one.
Gerber Freeman (440A)
Not sure how long ago I got this one, but its been awhile, years before becoming a knife nut, and was quite happy with it back then, of course the handle probably fit my smaller hands back then as well (cub/boy scouts). I really like the blade shape on this one and feel of the handle if it were about 50% bigger around. The leather sheath that came with this one is probably the main reason I prefer kydex sheaths, about the 4th or 5th time resheathing the blade the edge cut right through the sheath about 1/4 from the bottom, so now you can see about an inch of the edge. I don't like the steel at all because of edge holding.
Mora 846G (12C26)
Great knife like all moras, holds an edge decently, very sharp, easy to sharpen, does well on wood, I keep this as a back up knife in my woods pack. I really like the grippy rubber handle, and deep sheath on this model.
Mora 780 (1095)
The handle on this one is about the same as the handle on my condor bolo, semi-grippy plastic, though the guard on this keeps your hand in place well, don't like the sheath on this one at all, though I've never had it come out it doesn't seem like it would stay in very well. Both my carbon Mora's have a really good patina going on them from camping/food prep
Mora 911 (1095)
Good grippy rubber handle like the 846, the sheath is good as well, almost like a combo of the above two.
Schrade Trail Boss (440A, USA Version)
I got this one a long time ago as well at Bi-Mart because I thought it was cool looking and really liked the green rubber handle because it gripped so well, and the handle is great on this knife, cool blade design, down side is the steel, decent sheath as well, a nylon sheath with plastic insert.
Scrapyard Knives Scrapper 5 (52100)
Awesome knife, love the handle and blade size and shape. I also really like 52100 steel after using this and the RMD. Useful choil, though it probably didn't have to be quite as large, its about a finger and half choil, would have prefered a smaller one, or no choil even.
Scrapyard Knives Scrapivore LE (52100)
Haven't really gotten to mess with this one yet, though as soon as I make a sheath I'll probably edc it for awhile, I really want to make some micarta or g10 handles for both this and the swamp warden. Pry bar works pretty well even without the sheath covering the edge if held correctly. This is suppose to be ran up to about 64hrc so it should have some awesome edge retention. It was noticeably more difficult to sharpen than either the S5 or RMD.
Swamp Rat Knife Works Ratmandu (52100)
Great, beefy blade, I really like the handle on this as well, this is my SHTF knife, slightly thicker than the S5 as well as heavier. Like that its full tang. Comfortable handle.
Swamp Rat Knife Works Swamp Warden (52100)
I haven't really used this one much either, not until like the Scrapivore I make a sheath and handle, I tried it cord wrapped, but just wasn't up to par with the Izula's micarta handle, I do however like that it has a larger handle than the Izula and that its 52100.

IMG_2057.jpg


Medium Fixed Blades:
IMG_2058.jpg


IMG_2059.jpg


Small Fixed Blades:
IMG_2060.jpg
 
Last edited:
Folders:
Inventory:
Benchmade Monochrome (N690Co)
Benchmade Ritter Griptilian (CPM-M4)
Benchmade 710-1 (M390)
Benchmade 805 TSEK (M390)
Bradley Kimura II (14C28N)
Kershaw OD-1 (14C28N)
Opinel #7 (1095)
SOG Flash 1 (AUS-8)
Got this for christmas, my only assisted opening, not really big into combo edges, but its fun to play with, the arc lock is basically just like a right handed only axis lock, this one has blade play, and I'm not really a fan of the steel.
Spyderco Military Black G10/Titanium (CPM-M4)
Spyderco Paramilitary 1 (CPM-S30V)
This was my first "Real" knife and still one of my most carried, I don't mind the edge/corner sticking out when its closed really, does have slight blade play. I've also found that this is what of the early productions because it has the old style jimping and philips screws.
Spyderco Paramilitary 2 Grey G10 (CTS-20CP)
I like this knife nearly as much as my other P2, however I don't like the G10 color, gets dirty very fast, even the blue dye from my jeans ends up on the handle every day I carry it. I would have preferred a darker grey. I will say for the steel though, yesterday I accidentally dropped it point down into a steel sink from about 1ft up, I expected the tip to be chipped off at least 2mm, however there was only a very slight deformation of the first 1/2mm of the tip that took about 30 seconds to work out on some 1000 grit sandpaper.
Spyderco Paramilitary 2 Carbon Fiber (CPM S90V)
This is one of my grail knives, and ended up being very difficult to get a hold of even though I ordered it about 7 months before it was released (original was stolen out of the mailbox, had to scramble to find another 2 weeks after it was released). Luckily my particular knife has perfect fit and finish, love the grippy carbon fiber, the compression lock is my favorite lock and its even smoother on this knife than on the para 1, and because of S90V's edge holding it is my favorite steel.
Spyderco Manix 2 Blue G10 (CPM-S30V)
I really like the Manix 2 model in fact its my favorite Spyderco after the Para 2, I can open and close it one handed easily, just by manipulating the lock, great ergonomics, with the choil it just locks into your hand and I really like the blade shape and size. I don't have a regular production one because I much prefer full flat ground knives and sprint run steels.
Spyderco Manix 2 Foliage Green G10 (CTS-XHP)
Spyderco Manix 2 Tan G10 (CPM-M4)
Like that its M4, but not really digging the G10 color, I wish it was more of a brown/tan instead of a vampires idea of a tan.
Spyderco Delica (ZDP-189)
I use this as my work knife, lots of card board cutting 3 days a week, its my most worn looking knife, the saber grinds rather thick, so the edge goes pretty high up, but now that I reprofiled it, its easy to keep shaving sharp with a strop every once in awhile. I've really used this one hard, dropped on the concrete a few times, but besides some loss of paint on the clip and some scuffs/light scratches on the blade its still in great shape, not even any blade play at all. Definitely a great work knife.
Spyderco Ladybug Hawkbill (H1)
Collector #13, this knife came with a near mirror finish, I was very surprised the level of polish on the edge of this knife, and was hair popping sharp.
Spyderco Ladybug (ZDP-189)
This came hair splitting sharp from the factory, great keychain knife, I like the color as well.
Spyderco Salt I (H1)
Used this crabbing as a bait knife, washed it off in the ocean water and put it away dripping wet, took it out 3 months later to use as my edc during summer swims in the river/pool and never a hint of corrosion, though I will say that the yellow in the FRN did fade slightly when it was left on the seat of my car in the sun. Easy to sharpen, not great edge holding, but can get screaming sharp easily.
Spyderco Bug (3Cr13MoV)
ZT 200KW (154CM)
Absolute tank of a knife, feels like a fixed blade when locked open, I really like the satin finish compared to the regular coated blades on this one. Easy to sharpen, grippy, and with the choil, guard/flipper it just really locks into your hand when you use it, much like the Manix 2.


Forgot the Para 1 in my pocket in this shot
IMG_2062.jpg


IMG_2063.jpg


Spyderco's:
IMG_2080.jpg


IMG_2065.jpg


4in Blades:
IMG_2067.jpg


3.5in Blades:
IMG_2068.jpg


3in and smaller:
IMG_2069.jpg
 
Last edited:
Multi-tools:
Inventory:
Leatherman Supertool
Leatherman Micra
Victorinox Swisstool X
Victorinox Swisstool Spirit X
Victorinox Swisschamp
Victorinox Super Tinker
Victorinox Pioneer/Harvester Silver Alox
Victorinox Cadet Black Alox

IMG_2072.jpg


SAK's
IMG_2073.jpg

IMG_2078.jpg


Multi-tools
IMG_2074.jpg

IMG_2079.jpg
 
Last edited:
My 2nd and 3rd attempts at sheaths, I figured I could pay $30-$50 per sheath or buy all the equipment I need to make them myself for $80, the first one didn't turn out very pretty, retention isn't great (didn't heat it up enough), however I'm very happy with these two. Great retention, not too hard not too easy, though I prefer it to be a little on the harder side to pull out. Both have drain holes.
IMG_2082.jpg
 
Back
Top