Convex the best for all purposes???

Joined
Mar 7, 2002
Messages
759
Just curious, but a lot of posts seem to be touting the effectiveness of the convex edge. Most seem to be refering to chopping ability. Just wondering though, for a Khukuri that would lean more to the martial arts and slicing way is that really the best type of edge. Wouldn't these new edge profiles on the HI knives or other profiles be more appropriate for those uses. Don't know, just curious.
 
Originally posted by cucharadedragon
Convex the best for all purposes???
nope.

But don't tell Cliff Stamp I said that...:eek: :D :D :p
 
"But don't tell Cliff Stamp I said that..."

:D :D :D ;)


As long as it is a sharp convex edge it should do fine. Doubtfull you would notice much of a difference on a khurk, edge wise, given any Martial Art uses.
 
In addition to carving;
the area of blade used as a draw knife
works better with a flat or even hollow grind.
This allows a shallower cutting angle.
 
Good point, Bruise.

Bruise has hit on it -- Before metal armor, weapon edges were flat ground or almost hollow ground. With the advent of metal armor, edges tended to be either convex ground or saber ground for edge retention. The function of the weapon went from slice to shear.

This edge geometry shift happened in europe just after the migration age, and the shift also occurred in Asia around the feudal periods (14th to 15th c.?). Before that time, the protection used by combatants was little more than skins and furs and a shield (bamboo, and leather, or heavy cotton cloth in Asia), and the flatter grinds prevailed against these softer armors.

These days, the blade geometry is still determined by the use of the cutting tool. When a really sharp edge is called for, but the material being cut is relatively soft and cutting done withouut impact, hollow or flat grinds are used. (i.e, straight razors, woodworking and leather tools, light duty chisels or gouges, craft knives). When the edge doesn't have to be so finely honed but it needs to stand up to impacts and abuse, you more commonly see the convex or saber grind (some Axes, adzes, heavy use chisels, blades meant to cut metals or stone/sheet rock).
 
Back
Top