CPM 3V Magnum Tanto XII vs CPM 3V Magnum Warcraft Tanto vs CRKT Hisshou YK-30 vs ???

[Bladelana]

Can you guys help me make a purchase decision? There are so few reviews of the Magnum XII...

How do these large 12"-13" bladed tantos compare to each other and to alternatives?

Are there any other non-traditional alternatives that also have modern kydex/plastic sheaths in these large blade sizes?

I'm not interested in san mai blade materials.

Thank you!

 

[Man with no name]

I have some of the 12" Tantos in my collection, but personally I prefer the feel and balance of the 9" bladed versions. And as for the Warcraft I really like the medium or 5 1/2"model that is being discontinued.

 

[jencarlos]

i personally would get the magnum tanto xii. it'll be the highest in quality overall imho

 

[nephron]

I also like the Trailmaster and its got a secure ex sheath. Not 12", sorry but 9'ish is my favorite.

 

[45Shooter]

If you want a more traditional Japanese style blade better at stabbing and slicing, it's the Hisshou all the way. If you want an Americanized tanto in a super steel for less specialized use - Cold Steel. either one.

 

[Larry Turko]

I have both the CS magnum tanto XII and the CRKT Hisshou. The hisshou is an inch longer and heavier but both are awesome. One day I may get the Warcraft 12 blade tanto as well. All three are knives the survivors on the Walking Dead should carry. What else can I say other than; Awww! What a rush!