Create a high-value, economical three-knife set for under $100?

Joined
Nov 7, 2011
Messages
2,104
I thought this would be kinda interesting to see people's choices. Say that you have a buddy who's just getting into knives, and you want to help him choose a basic set of knives to get started that will cover all the basics for an active or outdoors type of person. You want to get him the best possible quality blades that will serve him well, but he has only $100 to work with. Let's say you want to stick with production blades (as opposed to trying to make your own out of sharpened files, saw blades, whatever :-) ).

What would you recommend as the best quality production knives in each of the following categories, that would keep the total cost under $100, and yet be reliable and effective blades for your friend to depend on?
1. A small fixed blade or moderate folder for EDC (let's skip multitools and stick with pure blades for this discussion),
2. A mid-sized fixed blade in the 3.5" to 7" range for an all-purpose field, hunting, or camp knife.
3. A large knife (a machete is ok) to use a multipurpose chopping, wood prep, and other tasks (let's skip axes for this discussion and assume a large knife/machete can be useful at least in some cases).

Here are mine:

1. Folder/small fixed: Becker Necker, $36. 3.25" fixed 1095 carbon steel blade, 0.165" thick. Excellent and economical small fixed blade for EDC.
OR (as an alternative, if the friend wants a stainless folder)
Cold Steel Medium Voyager ($35). Has 3" Aus8a stainless steel, and Cold Steel's excellent Triad lock. Very solid little folder for the money.

2. Field knife: Condor Rhodan ($28 street price). 5.25" 1075 carbon steel blade, nicely contoured plastic handle. Good field knife. Enough belly for skinning, enough heft for other tasks.
OR (as a stainless alternative)
Mora Bushcraft stainless blade ($27). A 4.25" Sandvik stainless blade good for an all-purpose field knife.

3. Large knife: Condor Bolo machete ($32). 15" carbon steel blade, good for wood processing, chopping, brush clearing, other large knife tasks.
OR (for a longer, thinner machete that's better at clearing grasses and brush)
Tramontina bush machete ($8). 18" 1070 carbon steel blade.

Cost: $96 for the first choices, or $70 if the friend wants the stainless options plus the longer machete.
Look on your friend's face when he learns he can get three great knives for well under $100? Priceless.
 
folder- Cold Steel med. Voyager 30 bucks

fixed blade- Mora 2000 25 bucks

Chopper- Condor Golok 30 bucks
 
This depends on your buddy a bit. If he's really going to do much with the chopper, then I *think* that's where you want to focus your dollars. Otherwise, I'd put more money in the EDC and go cheap on the rest of it. With that in mind...

Chopper centric kit:
Becker BK9...76
Mora #2.........10
Vic Classic....14

Total.............100 on the nose.

Folder centric kit (my son's suggestions here, btw):
Ontario machete....21 (honestly, I'd go with a Kabar Kukri machete but that busts your budget by $9)
Mora #2................10
CS Recon 1..........59

Total.....................90

Just for fun, mid-sized knife centric:
Ontario machete...................21
Becker BK2.........................60
Kabar dozier folding hunter....19

Total..................................100 on the nose.

Interesting challenge.

---

Beckerhead #42
 
Victorinox farmer. 19 bucks
Mora Companion MG. 12 bucks
Tram 14 inch machete. 8 bucks

Prices will vary but it's a safe bet you can do everything for under 50. Heck, you could even ditch the mora if you have the other two.
 
Victorinox farmer. 19 bucks
Mora Companion MG. 12 bucks
Tram 14 inch machete. 8 bucks

Prices will vary but it's a safe bet you can do everything for under 50. Heck, you could even ditch the mora if you have the other two.

+1. What he said, except Shotgun forgot "spend the remaining 50 bucks on beer."
 
Victorinox farmer. 19 bucks
Mora Companion MG. 12 bucks
Tram 14 inch machete. 8 bucks

Prices will vary but it's a safe bet you can do everything for under 50. Heck, you could even ditch the mora if you have the other two.

This has to take the prize for the lowest dollar setup! :-)
 
One other observation about this thread. Notice how there are certain brands who seem to be frequently represented in these discussions about high quality, low-cost knives? It seems that companies like Becker, Mora, to some degree Cold Steel, I'd also say Buck, and also companies like Condor, are making very high value knives for affordable prices.

Just goes to show: you don't HAVE to spend a lot of money to get a great knife.
 
Govt issued U.S. (demo) pocket knife $20.00
Cold steel Master Hunter factory second $ 35.00
Ranger RD7 used with not even a scratch in the blade coating $45.00
 
One other observation about this thread. Notice how there are certain brands who seem to be frequently represented in these discussions about high quality, low-cost knives? It seems that companies like Becker, Mora, to some degree Cold Steel, I'd also say Buck, and also companies like Condor, are making very high value knives for affordable prices.

That's a really true point. It is still amazing to me, despite the now-large pile of knives I've got, at the incredible value some of these companies offer.

1. Folder/small fixed: Opinel No.6 $10.95
2. Field knife: KA-BAR Mark 1 $45.65
3. Large knife: KA-BAR Cutlass Machete $43.52

Sure it comes out to $100.12, but if your buddy can't find twelve cents under the couch then he's destined to be eaten by a bear out in the woods anyway :D
 
Council Tool Hudson Bay 37 dollars
Buck Paklite Skinner 12 dollars
Enzo Trapper 50 dollars


Enzo trapper for $50 ????? They alone are over the $100 limit.


Victorinox farmer. 19 bucks
Mora Companion MG. 12 bucks
Tram 14 inch machete. 8 bucks

Prices will vary but it's a safe bet you can do everything for under 50. Heck, you could even ditch the mora if you have the other two.

This ^^^^^^^^
 
Back
Top