CRK Umnumzaan vs Hinderer 3.5" XM18

B

Biginboca

Gold Member
Joined
Mar 17, 1999
Messages
1,690
Not a "which to buy thread" because I already own both and they are my favorite knives. I am just wondering which of these others on the forum like better, because I just can't pick a favorite! Every day it's a process trying to decide which to pocket. I actually wish I could find a definite reason why one is better. I would flip the other and settle into a 1 knife edc.

It seems like most on here prefer the XM since it gets tons of recommendations while the Umnumzaan sits unrecognized in the shadow of the Sebenza. I love the Umnum because it is tough, handy in a number of grips, and the only knife I have ever owned that feels like it will never "wear out". It doesn't hurt that it also cuts like a mini light saber.

The XM is just a total tank! Feels like it could cut any other folder in half and locks up like it doesn't even have a pivot. Certainly doesn't cut like the Umnumzaan but does the job good enough for my edc needs, which aren't cutting apples and such.

So for those who have handled/owned both these knives, which do you prefer and why?
 
Both excellent knives. I have been carrying the XM-18 more recently, but the Umnumzaan still gets some pocket time. I think the ergonomics on the XM-18 is the deciding factor for me. The umnumzaan is thinner and I think may carry in my pocket better, but when cutting I have not yet found a knife that matches the XM-18 for ergonomics. Very comfortable to use and hold. I especially like the flipper as a finger stop for tougher applications.
 
I prefer the Umnumzaan by a wide margin for a few reasons.

  1. Cutting performance is much better.
  2. Ceramic ball RIL. I'm a fan! I would love to see this adapted to the Sebenza / other knives.
  3. Ergos are better in my opinon. There was a time when I felt if the knife didn't hug your hand completely (ala Military) it wasn't good, however I think my views have changed a bit. The Umnumzaan feels great in a variety of grips and positions and never feels insecure.
  4. Simplicity! The Umnumzaan has half the parts the XM-18 does. Elegent simplicity leading to perfection.
 
My vote goes to the Umnumzaan. I have both and the XM mostly sits while the Umm gets most of my pocket time and the SnG gets the second most carry.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top