Damascus etching gone wrong!

DaveReb

Gold Member
Joined
Sep 15, 2007
Messages
1,499
I recently got a Damascus Leek in trade off the board. It was supposedly a Proto-type given out for testing to a well known forum member, so the blade was unmarked, except for a very tiny hole. When I recieved the knife the blade finish was quite dull, I was told the first blades were only dipped once instead of twice like the current knives, so the etching was pretty faded. The condition of the rest of the knife was perfect and I was very happy with the trade. Of course I couldn't leave well enough alone so I proceeded to do some research on how to re-etch a Damascus blade. I posted here as a matter of fact, and was told to use Radio Shack Etchant fluid. After trying all the local Radio Shacks in the area...I found out the item was discontinued and no store in the district carried it. The next alternative I found was using vinegar. So following the directions I warmed the vinegar on a hot plate and set the blade in the solutuin. While the blade was soaking I got involved in another project and I lost track of time forgot to check the blade. I remembered about 20-25 minutes later and by that time the blade was dark black . I pulled the knife out of the vinegar and rinsed it off, then wiped the residue off with some WD-40. While the blade did etch...it also etched the layers in a 3D pattern. The blade was no longer smooth but had a textured finish! Now what:confused: I ended up cleaning off all the black and polishing the blade, which gives it silvery two-tone appearance. I also had considerable work on the pivot area of the blade, since the ball detent rode on the textures, it was pretty rough opening and closing it. Once I got the contact area's all smoothed out I at least have a functioning knife now. All in all the knife still works although I do have some slight vertical play, which I don't recall having prior to the etching.
IMG_0896.jpg

IMG_0897-1.jpg

Anyways I just want to post this info in case anyone else is planning to re-etch their Damascus blades, pay close attention to time, so you don't overdue it, and ruin your blade like I did. Lesson learned..let someone who know's what the hell their doing re-etch my blade!

Dave
 
I actually prefer a subtle etch on damascus. Sucks that you messed the bade up, maybe you could polish the blade up so it gets its smooth action back.
 
Sounds as if you etched enough to remove some of the contact between the lock bar and blade tang..thus the vertical play.

:(:(:(:(:(
 
Well at least it doesn't look horrible. If it's any consolation I've done far worse to far more valuable knives.

Like my Boa here, it was my first experiment with "dark side" edge grinds. I re-profiled the edge flat with the primary grind. If the knife were a satin finish to begin with it wouldn't have been so bad.

At least the knife cuts like a razor.
Boazeroedgeclose.jpg
 
Sounds as if you etched enough to remove some of the contact between the lock bar and blade tang..thus the vertical play.

:(:(:(:(:(


That's what I think as well. There isn't alot of movement, and there isn't any side to side movement so it's not a total loss...it will be a beater knife for me.

Dave
 
Well at least it doesn't look horrible. If it's any consolation I've done far worse to far more valuable knives.

Like my Boa here, it was my first experiment with "dark side" edge grinds. I re-profiled the edge flat with the primary grind. If the knife were a satin finish to begin with it wouldn't have been so bad.

At least the knife cuts like a razor.
Boazeroedgeclose.jpg

I don't feel so bad now:D,

Yeah, the blade doesn't look too bad, kind of unique actually, and it is as smooth as ever.

Dave
 
Dave,
Sorry to hear about your knife getting etched away. . .wish i would have seen your post prior to etching the blade. I would have mentioned that a very important step is to use finger nail polish on the spots that you don't want etched so that the knife still works smoothly. If it makes you feel any better i've forgot about knives soaking before, and had to do quite a bit of work to get them right again.

Gavin
 
I personally think the blade looks cool as is...its a shame it altered the functionality, but it looks neat.
 
Dave,
Sorry to hear about your knife getting etched away. . .wish i would have seen your post prior to etching the blade. I would have mentioned that a very important step is to use finger nail polish on the spots that you don't want etched so that the knife still works smoothly. If it makes you feel any better i've forgot about knives soaking before, and had to do quite a bit of work to get them right again.

Gavin

Gavin, thanks for the tip. I'll file this advice away, as this conversation will likely come up again. Do you use regular fingernail polish remover when done?

Merry Christmas!
 
DV, acetone (nail polish remover) is what I use. I personally coated the last blade I did with thick Superglue (never thought about using nail polish, thats a grand idea)

Acetone is also an excellent chemical to remove all contaminants before oiling the steel.
 
Back
Top