Different blade question.

Joined
Aug 3, 2006
Messages
116
I have been looking for a new fixed blade. I am looking for opinions on why some may choose a tanto blade over a regular straight or curved blade. Is a tanto just a matter of you like the way it looks or durability, easy sharpening. I dont really see were a tanto blade has any other advantages over a traditional blade but I have never owned either. What is yalls thoughts?
 
Tantos generally have stronger tip for piercing,
but I think a regular plain edge (PE) is overall more practical.
 
I have been looking for a new fixed blade. I am looking for opinions on why some may choose a tanto blade over a regular straight or curved blade. Is a tanto just a matter of you like the way it looks or durability, easy sharpening. I dont really see were a tanto blade has any other advantages over a traditional blade but I have never owned either. What is yalls thoughts?

The same as yours. I don't see any advantage.
 
I prefer the tanto for piercing and ease of sharpening. I also like the looks of a tanto done well... Emerson, Brend, Lum, Warren Thomas
 
A few points on tantos:
I don't buy knives for piercing, I buy them for cutting.
I have never had a spear point break when "piercing" something.
The consistent round edge of a spear point will pierce much better than the angled end of a tanto: what's the point in having a piercing blade if it can't pierce.
Tantos are know for their ability to slay zombies, so everybody should own one just in case...
 
The strength of the tip is about the only advantage of the Tanto design. I favor the drop point to all other designs but I can do just about anything with my Tanto's that I can do with other designs. IMO though, they don't fillet fish very well. (Just a joke)
 
An advantage to the Americanized tanto is a stronger tip, but IMO it looks ugly, but some others love American tantos, I prefer a normal curved blade, I don't see the use of a tanto for my purposes, I don't stab extremely hard materials, I only use my knife to cut or eat.
 
I generally prefer spear points over tantos. I just recently got an Emerson from a generous fellow who gave me a CQC-7 and I like it a lot more than I thought I would. It just gives my rotation more variety.

I have a Hinderer XM-18 with a "spanto" edge (tanto point with a spear point curve) that gets the best of both worlds. Only problem with that is the blade is pretty thick.
 
If a tanto has a regular "V" grind, instead of a chisel grind as some tantos have, the secondary edge is useful for making straight cuts, such as along a piece of paper, cutting out a coupon. Tantos have their strong and weak points, just as every other blade design.
 
One advantage of an Americanized tanto (with straight edges and sharp angles) is that you get 2 points. The tip, obviously, and a secondary point where the blade turns upwards towards the tip. Some people like this secondary point for making draw cuts. For example, if you want to make a shallow cut into a cardboard box (enough to cut the cardboard, but not what's inside the box), an Americanized tanto excels at this, as does a sheepsfoot or wharcliffe. However, unlike the sheepsfoot or wharncliffe (where the spine drops down to meet the straight edge), the tip (which a sheepsfoot doesn't have) is at the thicker part of the blade, giving it much more strength than a wharncliffe tip (which is minimal).

The obvious drawback of the Americanized tanto is the lack of curves, which make other cutting tasks more difficult. Of course, there's in-betweens between the straight and angular Americanized tanto and your typical droppoint/clippoint. But all will be some degree of compromise.
 
Compromise = CQC 15
 
Well the tip is very strong (pierce armour) and the slight curve in the blade can increase swing slashes, cuts, etc, works better for swords though.

No overall benefit, harder to skin (imo) with a tanto than, than say, a drop point.

If your choice was a bowie or a a tanto i would take the tanto, but I would take a drop point or spear point over both, all things being equal.
 
Back
Top