Dilemma: Yet another which to buy question.

P

Peruna1998

Joined
Sep 8, 2009
Messages
1,124
Okay, folks, I will be turning 35 relatively soon. As such, I will be getting myself another knife. I know, another knife?!?! This will be a special one. I've narrowed the field down, but I would like some advice. I am looking at either a Case/Bose Norfolk, a Case/Bose Tribal Spear, or a Menefee Swayback. To date, I have one custom knife, a Bret Dowell single-blade Trapper (which I carry 50% of the time, lovely knife -- thanks, Vincent!). My question is do I go Case/Bose Collaboration or custom. If Case/Bose, do I do the Norfolk or Tribal Spear. Now, I know the standard answer is, buy them all. Believe me, I would if I could. However, I started my own business this year. What, you started a business in a recession with the worst economy since the Great Depression? I have my reasons. I am an attorney. I am blessed with wonderful partners, a great practice, and great clients. We are making a profit for the year. Not much yet, but hey, we only started in January and had start-up costs. So, I cannot do it all for the foreseeable future.

I value the your thoughts and comments. I've read a lot on here and you've steered me right so far.

BTW --- Elliott, I am sure you'll read this. After reading the how to outfit your ranch thread, I read "Lonesome Dove". I am now reading the series. I find your signature quite amusing.
 
I'd recommend the Menefee custom. Rick does great work, and his work won't be so affordable or attainable forever.

- Christian
 
GO custom. Get the Menefee. His work is only going to get more expensive as time goes by.
 
The easy answer is go custom & get the Menefee, however, a couple points to consider.

Unless you have a line on one of his knives that you can get now or saw one in the exchange, &/or Makers section, the wait is fairly long (I heard close to 9 mos, but I could be wrong).

If you have to wait for Mr. Menefee to make you one, I'd suggest getting one of the Case/Bose knives. Which one? Whichever one you really like. The Norfolk is very nice & has 2 blades (Opposing) & is 3 3/4", while the Tribal Spear is fairly large (4 1/8", I believe) & has a single blade. It's up to you.

You could get one of the Case/Bose now for your 35th B-D, put yourself on Rick's list & reward yourself for a successful 1st yr when your # comes up.

Just a thought.
 
CL01 said:
You could get one of the Case/Bose now for your 35th B-D, put yourself on Rick's list & reward yourself for a successful 1st yr when your # comes up.

Just a thought.
Click to expand...

Last I heard the wait was around a year for Rick's knives (and totally worth it).

I would get on Rick's list and get a Case/Bose while I waited.
 
wagglebee said:
Last I heard the wait was around a year for Rick's knives (and totally worth it).

I would get on Rick's list and get a Case/Bose while I waited.
Click to expand...

Well, there you go. Then, I would definitely say get one of the Case/Bose, put yourself on Rick's list & reward yourself for your 1 yr anniversary of your new business. See, you can get both (Well, at least 2 or 3).
 
+1 for the custom on order, and the Case/Bose right now.

I usually have 1 custom on order per year and you don't feel the hurt so much when you are putting a few dollars in an envelope every week...it adds up fast. 6mos to a year is a good waiting time as far as saving the money goes.
 
Wayne,these guys already had good ideas.I love that Tribal Spear & eventually I'll get one,too
There are a few internet dealers that have some of Rick's knives,as well.
Happy Thirty Fifth B-day & Congrat's on the Business,too
-Vince
 
I have a Norfolk and I considering picking up a Tribal Spear. Between the two Case knives, I would prefer the Norfolk for office carry. The Tribal looks great but I would be less likely to EDC it.

Happy B-day and congrats on the business.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top