Dodo Impressions

Kublai

Gold Member
Joined
Oct 19, 2000
Messages
597
Just got it. Great design - I'm quite happy with it. I'm not sure if any data was posted regarding lock strength tests, but fro some reason, it was my impression that this model was part of the MBC series, however, it seems otherwise; it's not as stout as the other folders in the MBC line. There are no inlayed liners in the G10 scales, the pivot is not of the large variety and I have no idea if the lock is durable enough for an MBC rating.

Regardless, it rides very discreetly, is very legal, light, slim, fits well in the hand, and is pleasing to the eye.

The blade seems to have great cutting efficiency for 2 inches. Add the Spyder edge and I don't know if it could get much better. Also the grind, particularly along the downward slope from the spine to the tip is very well done.

When closed, the blade isn't held in place as strongly as the ball bearing detent on my Salsa. This is due to the spring loaded piston on the ball lock. It seems that if the spring was stronger and provided more resistance against the ball, the blade would not open so easily from the closed position; also this increased pressure would eliminate the side to side play when closed. It seems there is a reason for everything that Spyderco does and I wonder why a stronger spring was not considered for the piston.

I like the how the back spacer replaces a stop pin and how the angled front portion of the spacer is flush with the "tang" of the blade. Also, the dual finish of the blasted -type on the spine and the satin finish on the flats is a nice touch.

Because the tang rides along the ball when opening the blade, I thought the action would be smoother. For lack of a better description, the opening is a bit "scratchy."

I don't want to come off as too critical...I love this knife. Just want to throw in some input. The Dodo is unprecedented in design and function and is a must have for Spyderco enthusiasts. My regards to Eric Glesser and the Spyderco crew.
 
This weak lock in closed position is the reason why I won't buy the Dodo. Its design is definitely what I really like (love), but I already have a Meerkat with similar closed position locking problems (some of my pockets have nice holes now). If Spyderco confirms they will have a new serie made with a strong spring (and maybe another color ;) ), i will reconsider my opinion, that's for sure !
regards to the Spydie crew
 
Thanx for the input Kublai. New concepts always require refinement and I'm sure the Ball bearing lock is no exception. The balance of the spring tensions has been challenging. One spring keeps the knife open and the other keeps the knife closed and is the back up if something should happen to the first one.

sal
 
Anything is possible. Practicality becomes a question though. What would be gained by a titan frame Dodo, considering it would have to be a totally new design?

sal
 
I like it! I find I can "pop" it open very readily; somewhat of a surprise, considering the short blade (less mass than most other "easy poppers"). In fact, its short length makes it extremely fast-opening (the pendulum principle). The action on mine seems extremely smooth.

Due to my normal carry mode (clipped in right pocket, next to rear seam), I'm not concerned with the lighter "closed" tension. As already expressed, it's LEGAL!! Considering its aggressive cutting ability (despite its short length), and its comfortable and secure handle, it will replace my previous EDC (the other knife had a longer blade; comforting to have, but if I ever needed it defensively it could create an additional level of problems ...).

All in all, the speed of presentation, secure grip, aggressive blade format, legal constraints and light weight/portability make this a real winner, in my book. The quality, of course, is what I've come to expect from Spyderco. Thanks!!
 
I was thinking of the salsas but I guess the lock in the regular and titanium version salsas still allows the tang to be the same(?) so it's not a completely new design. I've been waiting for a titanium framelock S30V production knife other than a Sebenza that's under 3 inches bladelenth, but there doesn't appear to be one on the horizon. How about a mini ATR?;)
 
Back
Top