Does Size Really Matter?

Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Messages
7,350
I've been needing a slicer for some time so I just purchased a Victorinox 12" slicer with grantons and fibrox handle. They no longer carry the Forschner name - I don't know why and it doesn't seem to make any difference to the knife. I've read tons of excellent reviews, and at less than $40 delivered the price is certainly right.

The knife is inexpensive because the blade is stamped rather than forged but it has a sturdy feel and doesn't feel at all like a "cheap" knife. The fibrox handle is big and sturdy and has a matte, almost "sandy," finish so it isn't slippery - it feels good in the hand. The blade tapers from handle to rounded tip and has a comfortable amount of flexibility. The knife was razor sharp right out of the blister pack. I already used it to slice a barbecued brisket and it cut paper thin slices like a laser! The slices just fall right away from the granton blade. I am thoroughly pleased with the new addition to my knife block.

Now comes the source of my consternation - every silver lining has a cloud, or something like that. Along with the 12" slicer came a little pamphlet that showed some other models including a 14" slicer. What? 14"? Yes - 14". I didn't even know there was a 14" model. So my question is Does Size Matter? Have I "cut myself short?" Am I doomed to a life of inadequacy? My wife keeps telling me that size doesn't really matter and a couple of inches doesn't make any difference - but I don't know, I think she is just being kind. My brother is a food service professional and he uses a 14 but he slices really big roasts like steamship rounds on a carving station at banquets, etc., and it is unlikely I will ever do anything like that. Do I need to order the 14? Maybe I should check to see if it will fit in my block and then decide.
 
Last edited:
Size may get in your way. Depends on what you do, but simply using a 14" slicer is going to take a lot of space. IMHO, unless you are carving huge things (like steamship rounds), don't go there.
 
One advantage to a longer slicer is when presentation & texture matters. If you have a long enough slicer you can make the cut in one heel to tip pass. This technique takes sawing back and forth out of the equation thus leaving the surface texture smooth and more appealing to the eye and pallet. Does this matter to 99.99% of the people who cut food be they pro or not? I really don't think so.

The most common reason for desiring added slicer length is for making quicker work out of large cuts. Its just an efficiency thing here.

As Dan pointed out size can get in the way too. If you work in a cramped space or use a small cutting board you would likely want a shorter slicer.
 
I personally don't see the need for anything larger than 8 inches and even that's on the big side for what I do.
 
almost universally I use 27cm knives aside from a 30cm yanagi

yes size does impact what you do but if you are not carving large items a victorinox 14incher is not essential

nothing a home cook can do can rival what a pro needs really so its a minor thing

can you do the job with what you have? if so perfect if not then the 2 inches matter. Like for a chefs knife/gyuto I can't do what I want with a shorter blade without compromising.

I cant slice blocked tuna how I want with less than a 30cm blade and longer is better 40cm would be fantastic but the issue comes in how the hell do I transport said knife to work on a daily basis and how the hell do I work with it in my work space.
 
Back
Top