Dust Resistance: Roughout vs Smoothout

Horsewright

Knifemaker / Craftsman / Service Provider
Joined
Oct 4, 2011
Messages
13,055
We've talked a little about this before but I thought I'd post up some pics here. Roughout leather work is very popular in the cowboy world because of its durability. I was asked how I treat roughout and what kind of finish that I use. The simple answer is I don't. When making something out of roughout leather I oil it during construction or after completion depending on the item and thats about it. Thought these pics might illustrate what I'm talking about.

So last weekend we had out booth set up at our local rodeo.

JsWVxeF.jpg


So we started setting up about 2pm with the gates opening at 5 pm and the show starting at 7pm. Lots of walking around setting up the booth and then. Its a dusty rodeo grounds and I'm on dirt and gravel almost the whole time. Here's the smoothout boots I wore on Friday and am wearing in the pic above which was Friday before the gate opened:

YmvsbrP.jpg


Saturday a little different schedule but the same amount of time on my feet in the same conditions. Here's the roughout boots I wore that day:

j5q82Bf.jpg


And side by side:

QHQjTr6.jpg


So on Sunday after the rodeo I brushed the smoothout boots off and smacked the roughout ones a couple of times and both were good. I think the smoothout is just more of a dirt and dust magnet.

We're using this storage shed as a temporary tack room as we are having a new one built. We only have saddles we use on a daily basis in here.

T2sVl40.jpg


The back of my saddle has both smoothout and roughout:

cXdENBs.jpg


SR9UEtN.jpg


Nichole's is the same:

Zhr0JXC.jpg


Qw6n76O.jpg


Our daughter's all roughout:

Xgf26ZQ.jpg


These are using working saddles and get cleaned a couple times a year. So roughout can and does collect some dust and dirt too but it just seems to me that the smoothout does collect it more. Whadya think?

Funny thing. We had three pair of roughout spur straps there at the rodeo and didn't sell a one. First time ever we didn't sell roughout spur straps there at that show.

8B144fX.jpg


Feel free if you've done any roughout work to post some pics here:

R1uxyFv.jpg


5rllCOX.jpg
 
Thanks Dave for the post and all the pictures. I appreciate though put into this. I'll give it a try with rough out and will oil it accordingly.
 
Thanks Dave for the post and all the pictures. I appreciate though put into this. I'll give it a try with rough out and will oil it accordingly.
Ya bet post pics up here of how it works out. Also forgot to mention, if you'd used a finish on a project and it layed the nap down a little judicious sanding will fix er up.
 
This is something I’ve been debating on. It seems in WW1 that the soldiers wore “shoes” that were rough side out. But they were treated with some kind of shoe grease. Then between WW1 and WW2 the services went to a flesh out painted shoe. When troops actually went into battle during WW2 those shoes did not hold up. The Quartermaster department went back to rough out shoes/boots. And it was standard issue that troops were issued with what they called leather “dubbing”, some kind if leather treatment to help waterproof the footwear. I think those are historical facts but I could be wrong. Rough out leather looks great and it may have better weather proofing qualities.

Jon
 
Lots of dubbin brands still out there. Ya sometimes hear the word dubbin instead of conditioner used in the cowboy world.
 
Back
Top