Edge Dulling

[Robert Ptacel]

I've noticed this with other sheaths with plastic inserts that taking the knife out and reinserting dulls the edge as it rubs the liner. How are the ESEE sheaths in this regard?

 

[PunisherLcr]

Between a few of us we've got two Esee 5s (kydex sheaths), 3 Izulas (injection molded sheaths) and there is absolutely no edge dulling from the sheaths on any of them.

 

[tarditi]

I've got no problems with my Izula (plastic), HEST (Kydex) or RC-5 (Kydex).

 

[Robert Ptacel]

Thanks for the reply guys.

 

[unit]

I will say it depends on how you define sharp and how clean you keep your gear.

If you like to keep your knives really REALLY sharp and have sharpness tests you like to perform (beyond answering the question, "will this cut what I need to in the field?"), then yes, the sheaths will dull the knives a bit. We are talking about silly levels of sharpness here.

Additionally, if you get debris down in the sheath and fail to clean it out, it can cause some dulling issues.

HOWEVER, I have never found a Kydex or molded plastic sheath that would not do this to some degree, and ESEE sheaths are among the best I have experienced, and they are among the easiest to clean and keep clean...so if you are not a total dolt, you ought to be fine.

If you use your knives in the woods and don't worry too much about sharpness tests, you will likely conclude that your knives will stay VERY sharp while using these sheaths.

 

[qborchert]

I had a CRKT knife that would dull from sheathing and drawing it, never once had it happen with any of my ESEE's.

 

[stjones]

I haven't seen the problem with my HEST, 3, 4 or Izula.
I love the 1095 cause it's so easy to bring a razor edge back.

 

[djacobs28056]

I was drawing my esee the other day (Right after I got it) and a sliver of sheath came out with it.