I guess great minds think alike!
I, too, have been thinking the same thing, and this is the result from last weekend. I hadn't posted it because my effort was a fail. Not a catastrophic fail, but a fail none the less. At least I learned somethings...
I used Amazing Crafting Products mold putty to make the mould. It's a two-part clay that you knead together -- when it's an even yellow you've kneaded enough and only have minutes to form it. That puts some pressure on the operator. Since it still has the consistency of modeling clay, you have to press down pretty hard to make it form around the sample -- in this case a pair of the Grivory scales. It's this pressure where I went wrong.
This type of mould material -- the two-part -- does not require heat of any kind. It sets up like a rubber epoxy. When the right time passed I removed the scales (easy) and found that the side with the hex holes had somehow shifted sideways -- probably from the pressure I was applying to make sure the "clay" got around to all the surface details. Note that only the center hole is cocked to the side. This, of course, would show up on any piece cast from this mould, making that cavity fairly useless.
Also, the "clay" had fissures in it from the required kneading. I don't see any way of getting those out, even with lots of pressure. It resulted in "folds" of the clay which showed up in the end of the same scale with the cocked "hole". Seen clearly here:
Of course, these folds showed up on the cast parts.
I had a lot of West System epoxy left over from some wooden kayaks I'd built so I mixed up a batch and added microbeads as a fairing compound to make sanding easier (plain epoxy is a b*tch to sand). That's why the cast scales show up as an off white instead of clear. Since the cast scales were so far off I didn't bother sanding them down and abandoned this method. I have a different system on order which uses a more liquid medium for making the mould which should form over the parts better -- you just have to keep them from floating!
I'll keep you posted on how it works out.