- Joined
- Jul 12, 2004
- Messages
- 570


I bought an Exskelibur II about a month ago and decided to order an Exskelimoor II as well since I was intrigued by the bog oak scales. The knife arrived on Friday and I spent the weekend playing around with it.
The Exskelibur II arrived with perfect fit and finish while the Exskelimoor II had some issues that needed fixing. First, the liner lock wouldn't fully engage as the part of the blade it slides across when open wasn't ground down enough. Second, one of the blue titanium liners had some very rough burrs along one edge. Fortunately the Moor II shipped with the little spanner needed to remove the pivot screw so I was able to disassemble the knife and file down the offending areas.
And while the Bur II can be operated one-handed as it's a very smooth opener, the Moor II is impossible to open that way as the detent is very hard and locks the blade up with an audible click when closed.
On the plus side, the Exskelimoor II looks great with the two blue titanium liners and the bog oak scales. I have some experience with bog oak, or morta, as it pertains to pipes and was pleased to see that the scales on the knife were hard and dense yet still lightweight. They appear to be hand sanded as there are imperfections here and there but still look great.
The two knives seem to weigh about the same and the Moor II is only a hair thicker even with the dual liners. The back of the Moor II is completely open while the Bur II is partially covered with G10. The Moor II also lacks a nail nick which is kind of odd given that two-handed operation is a must. The blue metal clip can be moved for tip-up or tip-down carry on both knives and on the Moor II the screws extend all the way into the metal liner while on the Bur II they only anchor into the G10 itself.
The 440C blade is easy to sharpen and stout enough for some fairly hard use and the wood scales provide plenty of grip.
All in all I prefer the smoother function of the Exskelibur II but the Exskelimoor II excels enough in the looks department that I can forgive some of its quirks. I guess I'm more tolerant of minor flaws on a $50 production knife but the complete overhaul of a brand-new knife really shouldn't be a requirement for first-time use.