My first "decent" production knife was actually the 940-2, I purchased it from Amazon and was fulfilled by Chicago Cutlery. The knife was promised to me on a certain date, obviously that didn't happen for whatever kind of shipping issues. So I first call up Chicago Cutlery to see what the deal was since its "fulfilled" by them. They had no records of my invoice number, so I call amazon and straighten all that out, but in the meantime as I'm on the phone with one of the representatives (at Amazon) she told me the main cause of the knife being late was because it was "coming from over seas" that really peaked my interest and was a HUGE red flag to me as we all know BM is USA made, correct? SO I immediately called Benchmade and was able to get Corrines email (she told me on the phone there was a 5% chance it was a fake because like you said the 940-2 are relatively new), was able to send her pictures of the knife (once received) so she could verify its authenticity and I was a happy camper. I guess what I took from it all..either order from the company directly or deal with a member here on Bladeforums, that way you'll hopefully never have to deal with what I went through or what your going through now..I hope this helps and I apologize for making it so lengthy.
PS. I highly doubt you have a fake.