Fallkniven PXL?

Joined
Jan 28, 2009
Messages
2,687
i've been eying this blade for some time and it looks great. it features "3G" steel which is what i'm most curious about. anybody have experience with it in this knife or another knife? it is a beautiful knife IMO. its a great balance between modern and traditional styling. the price is a bit steep for a production, but it looks like its worth it. the F&F looks amazing too. what do you guys think...experience, opinions, worth the $250?

heres a pic for you guys:
FN34.jpg
 
It's a great knife. Excellent fit and finish. Very heavy. Very smooth. Personally, I prefer a full flat grind for superior cutting.
 
theres been a lot of good writeups on it if you do a search.you might be able to get one cheaper on the exchange section,too, ive seen some as low as 175.00....
 
Last edited:
I always admired this knife and always wanted one - but its out of my price range. As it stands, if I got this knife - it would pass my ZT300 as my most expensive knife that I own.
 
The steel quality and retention is much better with the lamminated 3G steel compared to s30v. It kind of depends what you're gonna use it for. A 0300 series model is made much more for impact tasks than a PXL. So you might conclude that a liner-lock knife with a 62 HRC blade is less suitable for such tasks than a Ti Mono-lock, 58-60 HRC blade. I recently purchased a PXL and own a 0301 for about a year and a couple of more s30v blades. These are great for outdoor work since they dont rust easely. I'm not sure what 3G will do? I'm gonna use it for normal EDC.

I am in love with this knife and esspecialy with the white Micarta scales.
But my 0301 still gives me a wonderfull stout feeling!!

My pics :D

15f12a5e.jpg


0779b1f1.jpg


cf20620d.jpg


692642d0.jpg


4f47ea88.jpg
 
That is a gorgeous knife - not a huge fan of the swedge for EDC, since it makes it "meaner" looking, but what a beauty.
 
The steel quality and retention is much better with the lamminated 3G steel compared to s30v. It kind of depends what you're gonna use it for. A 0300 series model is made much more for impact tasks than a PXL. So you might conclude that a liner-lock knife with a 62 HRC blade is less suitable for such tasks than a Ti Mono-lock, 58-60 HRC blade. I recently purchased a PXL and own a 0301 for about a year and a couple of more s30v blades. These are great for outdoor work since they dont rust easely. I'm not sure what 3G will do? I'm gonna use it for normal EDC.

I am in love with this knife and esspecialy with the white Micarta scales.
But my 0301 still gives me a wonderfull stout feeling!!

My pics :D

You should have no worries with Fallkniven's 3G steel. It is stainless and resistant to corrosion.

3G steel is a core of Super Gold Powdered Steel (refered to as SGPS or G1) laminated with VG2 steel.

I have had no rust/corrosion problems with any of my 3G knives.

Kevin
 
I've handled the PXL a couple of times and it has always impressed me, but I just wish it came in tip-up configuration, that's the only thing stopping me from buying one.
 
thanks for the pics wouter1967! it really is amazing everytime i look at it. and bearcut, that statement that it surpasses your $400 folders may have just sold me on it;)
 
Got an ivory micarta PXL a while back and would definitely say it was a bit of a rockier relationship than some of the other reviewers who've had this knife. When I first received it, it seemed like love at first site... beautiful fit and finish, nice aesthetics with classy lines and overall look, nice even lamination lines, and smooth action. I actually really appreciate the swedged spearpoint as it looks really nice in my opinion and helps greatly with piercing abilities. The only "flaw" at the time was the ridiculously early engagement of the liner lock... However, it still seemed very solid and light spine taps did not induce any failures, nor did firm pressure from my hand in trying to defeat the lock. After thousands of openings, the lock has moved over slightly so that the liner almost completely engages the left side of the blade tang. Needless to say, I don't think the lock will ever travel all the way over to the right in my lifetime. I'm not worried because the lock seems sturdy enough for my daily uses, and the I wouldn't use it for stabbing anything anyway.

Soon after use, it became apparent that there were some things that I personally found somewhat annoying about the knife design-wise. First, it's pretty thick and heavy for its size. It's almost the exact same weight as a stainless steel Spyderco Catbyrd, while being about the same thickness as a ZT 0300, though nowhere near as wide, to give an idea about the specs. It's a much beefier knife than pictures would suggest. The front edge of the bolsters on mine were surprisingly sharp enough to scrape paint. That along with the tip down clip and the thickness of the knife, caused some painful cuts and scrapes when trying to reach in my pocket past the knife for anything else. Blood was spilled on more than one occasion. Likewise the liners were also really sharp. Because the liner lock was so strongly sprung on mine, my PXL would tear my thumb up over the course of a day after unlocking it. Finally, while the thumbstud was really nice to look at, it became really annoying and uncomfortable in use. Due to the strong detent, the sharp edges of the thumbstud would again do a number on my thumb over the course of a day, and its length would cause it to snag very strongly whenever I inserted or removed the knife from my pocket (especially on the clip-side).

That said, I really really enjoy my PXL as an EDC after I sanded all the sharp edges down, and replaced the thumbstud, probably ruining the knife's resale value, but making it a much better user for me personally. However, I would say that some reviews comparing the PXL to the Sebenza seem somewhat exaggerated to me. Is the PXL a really nice knife? Absolutely. As to whether it's worth its high price? Maybe. There are definitely other quality knives that are finished as nicely or nicer, and there are those that function as well or better or are made from comparable materials for less money. However, not too many share the PXL's aesthetics so it really comes down to how much value you place on that in relation to the whole package.
 
The only "flaw" at the time was the ridiculously early engagement of the liner lock... However, it still seemed very solid and light spine taps did not induce any failures, nor did firm pressure from my hand in trying to defeat the lock.
Yes, it's got a very early lock-up. Thats one of the +point to me. Mine is very easy and smooth to un-lock. Hardly needs any pressure. Maybe they improved this part or you where just unlucky. It depends on how the blade connects to the lock-up. Grafite powder can be used to make this work smoother and lets the liner-lock let go easyer.

First, it's pretty thick and heavy for its size. It's almost the exact same weight as a stainless steel Spyderco Catbyrd, while being about the same thickness as a ZT0300...It's a much beefier knife than pictures would suggest.
True. The PXL is heavyer, beefier as to be expected. But hey, if lightweight is wat's needed everyone knows that Spyderco is the Brand to get. Still...a ZT is even beefier, heavyer and more agressive. To me taking out something else out of the pocket where my 0301 is put is no joy to me. Thats what I consider rough surface. I'll make some pics with both in one shot to compare.

the sharp edges of the thumbstud would again do a number on my thumb over the course of a day...
I think the thumbstudd is a little to pointy after using it for a couple of weeks. A broader studd would be more comfortable. But I dont suffer from to strong detent. Maybe they improved this part to?

You've absolutely got some good points mentioned. I do not use the PXL long enough to be 100% satisfied. One thing is for sure though, the blade steel is of much higher quality than the s30v Sebenza uses.

Thanks for your feed-back :)
 
Got an ivory micarta PXL a while back and would definitely say it was a bit of a rockier relationship than some of the other reviewers who've had this knife. When I first received it, it seemed like love at first site... beautiful fit and finish, nice aesthetics with classy lines and overall look, nice even lamination lines, and smooth action. I actually really appreciate the swedged spearpoint as it looks really nice in my opinion and helps greatly with piercing abilities. The only "flaw" at the time was the ridiculously early engagement of the liner lock... However, it still seemed very solid and light spine taps did not induce any failures, nor did firm pressure from my hand in trying to defeat the lock. After thousands of openings, the lock has moved over slightly so that the liner almost completely engages the left side of the blade tang. Needless to say, I don't think the lock will ever travel all the way over to the right in my lifetime. I'm not worried because the lock seems sturdy enough for my daily uses, and the I wouldn't use it for stabbing anything anyway.

Soon after use, it became apparent that there were some things that I personally found somewhat annoying about the knife design-wise. First, it's pretty thick and heavy for its size. It's almost the exact same weight as a stainless steel Spyderco Catbyrd, while being about the same thickness as a ZT 0300, though nowhere near as wide, to give an idea about the specs. It's a much beefier knife than pictures would suggest. The front edge of the bolsters on mine were surprisingly sharp enough to scrape paint. That along with the tip down clip and the thickness of the knife, caused some painful cuts and scrapes when trying to reach in my pocket past the knife for anything else. Blood was spilled on more than one occasion. Likewise the liners were also really sharp. Because the liner lock was so strongly sprung on mine, my PXL would tear my thumb up over the course of a day after unlocking it. Finally, while the thumbstud was really nice to look at, it became really annoying and uncomfortable in use. Due to the strong detent, the sharp edges of the thumbstud would again do a number on my thumb over the course of a day, and its length would cause it to snag very strongly whenever I inserted or removed the knife from my pocket (especially on the clip-side).

That said, I really really enjoy my PXL as an EDC after I sanded all the sharp edges down, and replaced the thumbstud, probably ruining the knife's resale value, but making it a much better user for me personally. However, I would say that some reviews comparing the PXL to the Sebenza seem somewhat exaggerated to me. Is the PXL a really nice knife? Absolutely. As to whether it's worth its high price? Maybe. There are definitely other quality knives that are finished as nicely or nicer, and there are those that function as well or better or are made from comparable materials for less money. However, not too many share the PXL's aesthetics so it really comes down to how much value you place on that in relation to the whole package.

I know this is an Old post, hope you are still watching here. I have observed a lot of what you mention here. I'm curious where you found a thumbstud to work with it? I'm considering modding mine.
 
Yes, it's got a very early lock-up. Thats one of the +point to me. Mine is very easy and smooth to un-lock. Hardly needs any pressure. Maybe they improved this part or you where just unlucky. It depends on how the blade connects to the lock-up. Grafite powder can be used to make this work smoother and lets the liner-lock let go easyer.


True. The PXL is heavyer, beefier as to be expected. But hey, if lightweight is wat's needed everyone knows that Spyderco is the Brand to get. Still...a ZT is even beefier, heavyer and more agressive. To me taking out something else out of the pocket where my 0301 is put is no joy to me. Thats what I consider rough surface. I'll make some pics with both in one shot to compare.


I think the thumbstudd is a little to pointy after using it for a couple of weeks. A broader studd would be more comfortable. But I dont suffer from to strong detent. Maybe they improved this part to?

You've absolutely got some good points mentioned. I do not use the PXL long enough to be 100% satisfied. One thing is for sure though, the blade steel is of much higher quality than the s30v Sebenza uses.

Thanks for your feed-back :)
My TK4 has pushed the Delica4 & Caly3 zdp189 into disuse.
TK4 is very light, fits a pocket better, & 3G is great steel.

Whoops, didn't realise it was a necro.
 
Back
Top