field/camping sharpener for the Izula

Joined
Jan 7, 2009
Messages
119
I was on Tadgear.com tonight looking at some stuff when I cam accrossed this thing called the Sterling Superior Sharpener http://www.tadgear.com/shop.php?id=87
I think this looks like a cool and functional sharpener, but could be wrong. Does anyone here have any experience with this thing. The other one I was looking at was the Lansky Quick-Fix:confused:
 
Looks cool. Small and anodized, but i have never had much luck with these types of sharpeners (tungsten carbide pre determined angled-bits). Interested with what others have to chime in on this type of "last-ditch" sharpener.
 
i'd just get a 5$ diamond pocket stone. those carbide tips remove way too much material for my liking.
 
those things do not hone your edge, they literally scrape steel off of it, take otis' advice and get a small pocket sharpener like the DMT Diafold or Mini-Sharp key ring
 
i usually just take along my sharpmaker, or steal a single rod from it and use that.
 
Sounds like I will just stick with my first choice and go with the Lansky Quick Fix. This Sterling Superior one sounds like it is good for survival when u need a good edge in a crunch, but not for fine tuneing an edge. Thanks for the input. Anyone have any experience withe the Quick Fix? I am looking at the KSF kit for a home/pack sharpening kit
 
I actually have one of these little guys. It's aluminum and weighs almost nothing, so I carry it as an emergency sharpener. But I do mean "emergency."

Haven't had much success with it freehand. It really has to be well braced against a flat(tish) surface, like a tabletop, or it tends to sort of skip down the blade. I wind up with a wavy, serrated-blade kind of look.

And it seriously chews up the metal. I'm talking curlicues of steel maybe half a mil wide but like 2/8 or even 3/8 inch long! :eek:

So, I carry it as a last ditch. It's inexpensive, super light, not bulky at all, and from the looks of it, you could run over it with a truck and it'd be just fine -- not too many parts to go wrong. But I sure wouldn't like to use it with any regularity on any knife I cared about.

And if I EVER allow it to touch the edge of my beloved Izula, there'd better be hostile forces landing on American soil, or zombies, or aliens, Godzilla -- something, or one of you fellas will need to shoot me as I've clearly lost my friggin' mind.

I should add that I think it's limitations are limitations of the TYPE of sharpener (carbide), not particular to the Sterling. I understand this is a small business making a quality product, and I wouldn't want to sound negative concerning Sterling's execution of the carbide sharpener. It's a high quality version of this type of thing. It's just not my type of thing, not for regular use, anyway.

Anyway, just my two cents. :)
 
The DMT diomond sharpening cards are really nice, the size of a credit card and can be carried in your wallet.
 
Since we are on the topic of sharpening knives. Has anybody used JREs EMS sharpening system?
 
I was on Tadgear.com tonight looking at some stuff when I cam accrossed this thing called the Sterling Superior Sharpener http://www.tadgear.com/shop.php?id=87
I think this looks like a cool and functional sharpener, but could be wrong. Does anyone here have any experience with this thing. The other one I was looking at was the Lansky Quick-Fix:confused:

I cringe when I hear one of these types of carbide sharpeners scraping away metal. :thumbdn:
 
I use carbide scrapers ONLY for re-establishing a bevel on a knife that's been SERIOUSLY beaten up (so usually it belongs to someone else!). I then start with a coarse diamond stone and work up through, undoing the waves that it put on the blade. :barf:

You also have to be careful with those. The angle can vary greatly depending on the manufacturer. The ones that Benchmade sells, for instance, have a whopping 60-degree inclusive! Yuck!

My recommendation: get a DMT coarse/fine diafold. They're reasonably priced, lightweight, and tuck nicely in a back pocket or backpack. Also easy to use in the field since you can just use it like a file. :thumbup:
 
Back
Top