First Electrolysis Trial - Success! (with photos)

Joined
Mar 3, 2011
Messages
398
I first heard of the electrolysis process in talking with a fellow tool restorer Gary Bridge, who has been using electrolysis to remove dirt and oxidization from antique hand planes. I was impressed with how easy and effective it sounded. I had to try it, and Gary was generous enough to walk me through the process at his workshop in Spicer, MN. We used the process to remove the rust from a vintage Great Neck 3.5 lb axe head, and were quite impressed with the results.

This was just my first test. There's a lot more to this process than first blush; amperage, types of steel, homemade tricked-out electrolysis buckets. You can bet I'll be doing some more testing and research on this in the future

Here's the Great Neck before. It's not terribly rusty, but still in need of a clean up.

BMC_elec_2.jpg


BMC_elec_1.jpg


What you'll need:
A large, non-conductive container large enough to hold the tool and enough of the electrolysis solution to fully submerge it. We used a rubbermaid tub.

A battery charger capable of delivering 2 amps or more.

An electrolyte solution mixed in a ratio of 1 tbsp washing soda to 1 gal water.
This is an alkaline solution and will irritate the skin if not washed off. It will also irritate the eyes, so handle it carefully and flush with copious amounts of water and seek medical attention if it does get in your eyes.

A piece of mild steel to use as an electrode. We used a flat piece of 1/8" mild steel.
This is also called a sacrificial electrode. It will corrode with continued use. Stainless steel is not recommended, since the contained chromium will inhibit the passage of current, and can contaminate the electrolyte solution.

The tool you want to clean.
Clean it thoroughly with a degreaser before beginning electrolysis, this will ensure maximum conductivity.

A scotchbrite pad or soft bristle brush.
You will use this to gently clean the tool when the electrolysis is complete.


First off a word of safety: you are about to stick two electrodes into a bucket of conductive fluid. Do not stick your hands into the solution once the current is flowing. Secondly, this process produces hydrogen and oxygen, it's recommended that this process be conducted in a well ventilated area to prevent combustion. Do not cover the container once the process has begun.


What you need to do:

1. After you've degreased your tool, connect it to the NEGATIVE lead on the unplugged batter charger. You may need to clean a small portion of the tool with sandpaper to ensure good contact. Then place it in the non-reactive container. NOTE: If you accidentally connect the tool to the positive lead, the process won't work at all.

BMC_elec_4.png


2. Add enough water to fully submerge the tool. Pay attention to how much water you add, and add the appropriate amount of washing soda in a ratio of 1 tablespoon to 1 gallon.

BMC_elec_6.jpg


3. Connect your sacrificial electrode to the POSITIVE lead on the battery charger and add it to the tub with the solution. The charge will travel between the two electrodes in a 'line of sight.' This means that the side of the tool facing the electrode will have the best results. We stopped the process halfway and turned our axe head 180º so that both sides received the same results. Some folks create cylindrical sacrificial electrodes to eliminate the need to rotate the tool. It's also important that the tool and the sacrificial electrodes do not touch. The current between the two must travel through the electrolyte solution for the process to work.

BMC_elec_3.jpg


4. Once you have everything connected properly, and have double checked it, plug in the battery charger and turn it on. If you need to rearrange or rotate the tool, turn the batter charger off and unplug it before sticking your hands in the solution.

5. After you've initiated the electrical current, the tool should begin bubbling. These bubbles are the hydrogen and oxygen mentioned earlier. If you do not notice any bubbles, unplug the battery charger, double check your connections, and try again.

6. Let the tool 'cook' in the current for a couple hours. You should notice that the surface of the solution will become murky and gunky, this is all coming off the tool! It may take up to 12 hours to fully clean your tool. Check it periodically

BMC_elec_7.jpg


7. Once the tool is free of oxidization it should appear dark, almost black. Unplug the battery charger and remove the tool. Use the plastic scouring pads to clean the remaining gunk off, it should come off fairly easily.

8. Rinse the tool well and dry it thoroughly. Once dry, coat it with oil or other anti-rust product. Often times the tool can begin to rust again almost immediately.

9. Dispose of the electrolyte solution down the drain or by pouring it out outdoors. Apparently, your lawn will love the iron rich solution.

And here's the Great Neck after:

BMC_elec_8.png


Overall I was really happy with the results. It's no where near as loud as grinding and sanding, and not stinky at all like vinegar. Lately I've been finding that the etch on steel after a vinegar soak is pretty lackluster. It usually goes away with a coat of oil, but the electrolysis made the steel look really really good. There was a little paint left on the Great Neck, and it should be noted that paint comes off in the electrolysis as well as rust.

I should be rehanging the Great Neck sometime next week, and will have even more pics of it all cleaned up. Gotta find the right handle though. The eye is just a bit larger than standard.
 
Thanks for the thorough tutorial, I've always been interested in this method. I'm curious to see if this becomes you're preferred method. The results look good, I'm looking forward to seeing it hafted.
 
Good job.
I use electrolysis quite a bit. I use a 5 gallon plastic bucket and almost fill it with the solution. You can use it several times and I only change it when it gets really grimy looking. I use two 5/8" rebar for the electrodes (one on each side so I don't have to turn the axe) and hook the charger to one and connect the other one with a car jumper cable. I just stand them up and clamp them to the rim of the bucket. After a while they will get rusty and I just clean them with a wire wheel. I've never had to replace them.
I lay another rebar across the top and suspend my piece from it with a chain. I use a 15 amp charger and find it works very well. Takes about 6-7 hours for a severely rusted axe.
Jim
 
A few questions.

What setting was on the battery charger? Does it matter?

What is "mild steel"? It would have to be something bigger than the axe, correct?

Did you use anything to separate the two pieces (sacrificial steel and axe)? The piece of metal you have looks thin and would have problems staying upright?

Thanks!
 
More thanks to Nick for posting this.

While "researching" the vinegar soak method and the potential benefits of adding some salt to the vinegar, I found a reference to electrolytic rust removal that disputed the common explanation that electrolysis will transform the surface rust back into good metal.

This was written by a chemist named James W. Swonger. His full text is linked below.

"There have been extensive discussions of an electrolytic method in the
past which I have stayed clear of. In that case it appears that the
rust removal is accomplished by creating hydrogen gas underneath the
rust coating and 'blasting" it off
. This would explain why some of
those black dense oxide coatings are not removed."

"The electrolytic method should not remove much metallic iron but on
the other hand what ever is on the surface as rust and gets "blasted"
off is not likely to be redeposited as metallic iron back on the piece
from the same location from which it originated."

"In other words what is turned to rust ain't gonna get put back where
it once was."

from
http://yarchive.net/metal/rust_remove.html


Make your own Washing Soda:
From the link below, a method to make Washing Soda (aka Laundry Soda) from common Baking Soda:

Spread baking soda on a cookie sheet and bake for an hour at a little more than 300 degrees.

from
http://antique-engines.com/electrol.asp
 
Last edited:
A few questions.

What setting was on the battery charger? Does it matter?

What is "mild steel"? It would have to be something bigger than the axe, correct?

Did you use anything to separate the two pieces (sacrificial steel and axe)? The piece of metal you have looks thin and would have problems staying upright?

Thanks!

I'm not sure what setting we used on the Great Neck. I was too excited to see it fizzing like a giant alka-seltzer tablet. I've read online that it should be 'turned up full,' others say to use a 2-amp charge. Also heard that the higher the amperage the faster the process works. The lack of clear consistently tells me there's no 'correct' setting.

Mild steel is just regular carbon steel. I think Gary got this piece at Home Depot or someplace similar. I've read you can use rebar too.

There's nothing between the axe and the steel plate, except the electrolyte solution.

The piece of steel we used was actually taller than the tub. It's partially submerged in the photo, that's why it looks smaller. It just rested against the side of the tub. I don't think it has to be larger than the axe, but the larger the electrode (or maybe this would be the anode. I don't know for sure) the more 'line of sight' it will have with the axe. Although I read that some folks just use rebar, so it doesn't have to be a large plate.
 
This is a great method for delicate or high tolerance parts. I use it on old crank shafts and micrometers I get at the flea market. It is esentially the reverse of electroplating, and amperage, iirc, is based on surface area of the cathode (rusty part). A larger anode (surface area) will work with better efficiancy longer than one with more mass and less area. A large thin plate vs. rebar. But a heavier anode will last longer before being "sacrificed."

This is the same process that causes the zinc anodes on boats to deteriorate rather than the boat. Its just that the contact of dissimilar metals create the charge in electrolyte (water) solution. It is sped up considerably by applying greater current.


Kinda surprised I don't see it more often on here.


-Xander
 
Back
Top