First Impressions: Gerber LMF II

Joined
Oct 26, 2001
Messages
1,438
Well, I got my first knife in a long time in the mail yesterday, a Gerber LMF II ASEK. I have to say that I was a little worried about buying another Gerber, since their quality seems to have gone down hill in recent years. When it arrived I was extremely impressed with it. Hair popping sharp out of the box, and the handle is amazingly comfortable. The blade feels a lot larger than 4.9 inches long, probably because it is over an inch wide. The glass breaker on the pommel looks like it would really function as intended, although I haven't gotten a chance to test it yet. The hammer platform actually works quite well, which I found surprising. My only complaints so far are that I wish the blade spine was a little thicker and that the serrations took up less of the blade. Otherwise I think this knife represents a good value for the money. Hopefully I'll have a chance to perform some actual field testing over the next few days and update this review a little.

Lagarto
 
I'm glad to see someone finally got one of these. I e-mailed Gerber about producing a non-serrated version and they promptly replied. They said they are considering it so we can only hope. Anyway I will still buy one when I can afford it. I look forward to hearing more of your experience with this knife. Thanks!


John
 
Well, I managed to do a little more testing of the knife this morning. First off, I used it to peel an apple for breakfast, a task which it accomplished quite easily, and unlike some knives I've used for this had a perfect grind and edge angle to remove only the skin, without cutting into the fruit. I then used it to dice a few carrots, another kitchen chore which the knife handled with ease. I know tomatoes are supposed to be a real test, but I didn't have any on hand, maybe tomorrow. Next I took the knife and used it to cut a few half inch diameter green branches off a small tree, and again the blade performed admirably. Finally, I used the LMF to attack a 1.5 inch diameter piece of cured oak I keep around for this purpose. The knife proved to be a little light for heavy chopping, but did cut about halfway through with 3-4 strokes. I also attempted to whittle a point on this stick, and although the blade did have some difficulty I managed to get a point in the end. Overall I felt this was a good simulation of cutting and shaping tent pegs, or possibly treenails to make a raft. I didn't have any roadkill handy, but I did have some rubber tubing, which I felt might approximate animal hide. I had no problem slicing this open, both vertically and horizontally, and I'm sure the knife would work for light skinning chores. Edge retention was good, but not overly spectacular so I decided to test the built in sharpener, of which I was highly skeptical. To my surprise a few passes did bring the edge back to shaving sharp, but I did have to use a lot more force than I do with the sharpmaker. I think this system works well for touch ups, but I wouldn't want to use it on a seriously dull edge.
On the negative side, the sheath retention system wears on the handle a little bit and is grating down the rubber on the upraised section where the handle meets the blade. This could probably be alleviated with a few pieces of duct tape at the point of contact or possibly a light coating of epoxy, but I feel that this shouldn't be necessary and wish the factory would revamp the design. Also, I can't find any way to attach the safety knife to the main system without interfering with the "draw" of the main knife. Not a real drawback, but I bought the ASEK model hoping the two could be piggybacked. Lastly, as stated above I feel the knife is a little light for serious chopping, and wish the spine were a little thicker, but this probably exceeds the design specifications in the first place, so not a real serious complaint. I do feel that a non - serrated version or a version where the serrations take up about 50% of the space occupied by the current version would represent a significant improvement, but overall I feel this is a great knife, capable of handling most camp/survival chores, although maybe a little over-hyped. Just my two cents. Sorry for the long post.

Lagarto
 
GerberLMFII.jpg
 
Man, that's a great photo of that knife. You can really see how the sheath wears a little, if you look closely.

Lagarto
 
Don't have one yet but will soon (hopefully). The blade reminds me a little of a finnish knife, exept for the sereation. Looks like a must have outdoors.
 
I had one, never really used it for anything, it was a nice hefty knife though, for 100$ you cant do much better. I ended up getting one of the old BMF's to replace it.
 
Thanks Lagarto. I'm still 50/50 about getting one of these. I'll keep looking around and hopefully find a good enough deal that justifies it!
 
new to bladeforums. Just wanted to mention that LApolicegear has the LMF II for $59. I almost bought one, but bought a TAK1 D2 instead.
 
Thanks for the tip dmckindly, that's all the reason I needed to get one! Man do I love a bargain! Just went and ordered it, I can't wait!
 
Thanks for the tip dmckindly, that's all the reason I needed to get one! Man do I love a bargain! Just went and ordered it, I can't wait!

Probably the best price I've seen online. I ordered a Gerber Trifold shovel from them a couple weeks ago and received this:

All in-stock items are in the process of being shipped immediately. Your order contains merchandise that is temporarily on backorder. Please be assured that this merchandise is currently en-route to us and will be arriving in our warehouse shortly. Your order will remain in open status in our computer system until the merchandise has arrived back in stock. As soon as we receive the backordered product, your order will be filled and shipped out to you immediately. A shipping confirmation email will follow at that time.

I called them and the really nice rep told me they were having issues with Gerber and didn't know when my shovel would be in, so I cancelled my order. You may want to call them on the status of your LMF II.
 
I also tried ordering a LMF II from them (lapolicegear) last year and I never got any reply. Two weeks later when my other stuff arrived (no knife) I called them and got the "backorder" spiel and canceled. They charge you and never tell you it's on backorder, better check first.
 
would it be possible to cut off the plastic clip that is digging into the handle ? it would still have the two snap closures on top ?
 
Goldie,
I guess you could probably do that with a dremel easily enough, but I'm not sure that I would want to rely on just the upper straps for rention in a parachute jump or other tactical situation. For us civilian dweebs though it would work just fine I believe. Or as I mentioned, just put a very light coat of epoxy on that point of the handle where it contacts the sheath, I think that would protect it as well.


Lagarto
 
Back
Top