Recommendation? First real SS Utility/fighting knife

Joined
Apr 28, 2021
Messages
138
I was pilling money for a CRK pacific, planning to build a high-end gerber ultimate like kit. I met some guy that convinced me to make a priority task list.

The priority of task are based on how often you do it, the quantity of tool's work needed and how important is it to succeed. All that based on personnal need and experience, meaning the list isn't universal and is subject to change in the future.

With that in mind, I did the following list;

4.Featherstick (both the shaving and chipping type) 121

5.Chopping small branches 212
5.Batonning up to 2,5-3" lumber 311
5.Removing object (medical) 221
5.Cutting clothe 221

6.Striking fero-rod 231
6.Making notche 222
6.Last resort self defense 321
6.Cutting paracord 231
6.Openning can of food 321

7.Carving wood wedge 322
7.Light prying 322
7.Preparing fish 322

8.Cutting fruit 332
8.Digging small hole 323
8.Smacking stuff 332

9.Breaking glass 333

It is to note that I have a mutitool, hatchet and saw to go with my knife, largely influencing the priority.

With all that in mind, my knife spec have changed a lot, bringing me closer to the standard.

Mandatory;
-"Ugraded" stainless steel (vg10, s30v and such)
- 4-5" blade lenght
- 0.140-0.188 blade thickness
- "Straight" clip point (no inward curve), drop point or harpoon point
- Point in line with the handle
- Metal guard
- Synthetic handle
- Hand-filling handle
- Full tang
- No serretation
- No second hand

Flexible;
- Finger choil
- 300$ budget
- no recurve
-no sawback (can have 3-4 notch though)

Plus but not needed;
-Pomel
-Lanyard hole


It would also be good to note that I'm planning to buy another knife, so I'm not looking to save a couple of buck here. I will might buy other blades later on, but to complete the current one and not upgrade it.

And before somebody ask, I bough a cheap knife, 7" sawback bowie knife thinking it would be what I wanted and let's simply say I made my experience.

Ps; any other task you think I forgot or should consider?
 
Last edited:
Mandatory;
-"Ugraded" stainless steel (vg10, s30v and such)
- 4-5" blade lenght
- 0.140-0.188 blade thickness
- "Straight" clip point (no inward curve), drop point or harpoon point
- Point in line with the handle
- Metal guard
- Synthetic handle
- Hand-filling handle
- Full tang
- No serretation
- No second hand

Flexible;
- Finger choil
- 300$ budget
- no recurve
-no sawback (can have 3-4 notch though)

Plus but not needed;
-Pomel
-Lanyard hole


It would also be good to note that I'm planning to buy another knife, so I'm not looking to save a couple of buck here. I will might buy other blades later on, but to complete the current one and not upgrade it.

And before somebody ask, I bough a cheap knife, 7" sawback bowie knife thinking it would be what I wanted and let's simply say I made my experience.

Ps; any other task you think I forgot or should consider?
A couple things I would suggest about the tasks real quick, I Don't use knives for digging unless its absolutely necessary! :) If I need to dig a hole I make a digging stick. Its just a stick with a sharpened end. Works as well and I am not ruining my blade. Dirt can dull knives pretty quick in my experience. Especially if you hit rocks.

Also What do you mean by removing objects? Splinters and such?

As For knives, Bark River did the Aurora and Aurora 2 in a stainless run. I think the Bushcrafter 2 is also made in S30v and Elmax. They don't have a metal guard though. The fallkniven S1 is close but slightly thicker than you want and Also no metal guard. If your stuck on that, the only one I could think of would be something from buck, or possibly one of the Helle knives. Although I cant think of any specific models. Good Luck! let us know what you choose.
 
Except for not having a larger metal guard, here is your knife. A Cheburkov MCH-2 in M390, 5" BL, .157" thick. Within your budget, too.

i-7z4w5RC-X2.jpg
 
try using the advanced serch filter at knifecenter and see what pops up?
 
The other one that should be exactly in your budget, is the CPK DEK1 in AEB-L. I think there is a sale coming in a couple of days. Made exactly for what you want it, a 4.5" blade utility fighter.

Left-most:

i-ZFKNVWD-X3.jpg
 
A couple things I would suggest about the tasks real quick, I Don't use knives for digging unless its absolutely necessary! :) If I need to dig a hole I make a digging stick. Its just a stick with a sharpened end. Works as well and I am not ruining my blade. Dirt can dull knives pretty quick in my experience. Especially if you hit rocks.

Also What do you mean by removing objects? Splinters and such?

As For knives, Bark River did the Aurora and Aurora 2 in a stainless run. I think the Bushcrafter 2 is also made in S30v and Elmax. They don't have a metal guard though. The fallkniven S1 is close but slightly thicker than you want and Also no metal guard. If your stuck on that, the only one I could think of would be something from buck, or possibly one of the Helle knives. Although I cant think of any specific models. Good Luck! let us know what you choose.
I never though about doing it with a stick, it sure would be a better idea.

Yes, I do mean splinter and such although I realise I should lower the probability as I will use my multi-tool first.

I really want a guard, but I guess a "non-slipping" guard would be enough for me instead of a "stabbing" guard.

Bark river seem nice, but they are too much above my price range, as for buck and Helle they don't fit enough in my spec.

I will post my choice in the end.
 
Perhaps the Sendero Classic from White River Knives? I don't have any personal experience (one is coming in the mail, just hasn't arrived yet). It seems to fit all your criteria except thickness - 0.13". CPM S35VN steel. No lanyard hole.
 
Fallkniven F1 Pro. (Or S1 Pro with 5" blade and a buit more $)
Q42ZSj.jpg

S1 Pro
Q6LKsg.jpg
The F1 was already on my list, but I didn't like the slightly thicker than my spec and I found the guard to be too small. Then again I agree that I don't exactly need a "stabbing" guard, it's used my the military and the Kraton handle has its reputation too.
 
The other one that should be exactly in your budget, is the CPK DEK1 in AEB-L. I think there is a sale coming in a couple of days. Made exactly for what you want it, a 4.5" blade utility fighter.

Left-most:

i-ZFKNVWD-X3.jpg
Holy hell, I didn't expect Carother to make sub 300$ stainless knife, that's on top of my list now. I really need something spot-on to buy something else
 
Perhaps the Sendero Classic from White River Knives? I don't have any personal experience (one is coming in the mail, just hasn't arrived yet). It seems to fit all your criteria except thickness - 0.13". CPM S35VN steel. No lanyard hole.
Look nice, would it be a bit thicker I would not be affraid, but I also find it thin at the tip. I'm not sure I would baton with it
 
Picked up a CPM DEK1 in D3V a few months ago and it has become one of my favorite blades in that size. Excellent suggestion on that one above.

Just last week I received a TFK (Tanev Family Knives) 17.5s in N690 (Bolher VG10ish Stainless.) The maker is in Bulgaria and an user on BFC. Beautiful execution and a great stainless knife. I’m looking forward to some real world use. You might want to check one out.
The linked one is D2 but you get the idea: T17.5s
 
Last edited:
Great, but do you know somebody in Canada? I only know David Mary.

Graeson Fehr
Fehrforgeworks on etsy or fehr_forgeworks on IG
I forget where he is, I wanna say Manitoba.
THis is one of his stock patterns the Praetorian:

DSC_3776.jpg

I don't remember the steel, but carbon because of the hamon, approx. 12" with a sharpened clip. I don't really like recurves, but I bought this anyway!
With sheath was right around $300
This was a custom in 1095:

DSC_3774.jpg

Less than $200. I wanna say it was $150 or so, approx. 10".
He did the small and large maple pair in my avatar.
The smaller was done in W2.
I'm sure he'll do what ever you want.
Fit and finish is not perfect (I'd call it 9.5/10), he just started and is a young dude, but he seems to know his stuff.
Price was very reasonable for me because of the exchange rate.
YMMV
 
Back
Top