first time KA-BAR buyer, MK1 or MK2?

Joined
Jul 13, 2015
Messages
47
i love a sturdy solid feeling knife, i don't mind regularly sharpening it ( i find it relaxing) but DO value an extremely keen edge, i've loved the look of both models for a while, slightly preffering the aesthetic of the MK2 but preffering the reviews on the MK1 so here's what i need to know, what specific steel is used, how durable is the whole thing, how easy to sharpen and anything else that springs to mind. help a brother out here.
 
Hey mate. Whilst I'm no authority on Kabar knives, I do love them. So I'd like to help a brother out.

Both the MK1s and MK2s are made from 1095 cro-van steel. Kabar steel is generally heat treated to about 58rc. Holds a great edge whilst being quite easy to sharpen.

These particular shapes of knives have been used for decades and decades in numerous wars and other facets of life by millions of people. Ergo, they are a great design. Typically though they're not the first blade that people usually suggest to use as a bush craft type knife however IMO I believe they would make a fantastic bush knife.

They have a full tang construction, the tang however being hidden inside the handle. Don't be misled by the concept that they are a stick tang however. The tang is certainly not stick thin but they are not a exposed full tang like you find on the Becker range. There are pictures available of a sectioned blue print that gives you an indication of how wide the tang is. Whilst the original design had stress risers where the tang meets the handle I believe the next generation of F/Us have been modified with radiused inner corners (someone correct me if I'm wrong here).

I have a D2 Extreme F/U that has the same shape as the MK2 and am looking at getting myself one of the 1317s Dog Head F/Us. They look super cool. If you wanna see this knife in use as a bush knife check out Lost Vikings thread. Brilliantly written with some great pics of it in action. Anyway, hope that helped Nathan..

http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php/1300572-Dog-s-Head-Utility-The-First-Thirty-Days
 
Honestly?

I carry a modified 1250 Short KA-BAR the most when out in the field, and have a modified KA-BAR Mk I Navy in the pack and in camp.

Really useful knives...




GR
 
  • Like
Reactions: vab
Hey mate. Whilst I'm no authority on Kabar knives, I do love them. So I'd like to help a brother out.

Both the MK1s and MK2s are made from 1095 cro-van steel. Kabar steel is generally heat treated to about 58rc. Holds a great edge whilst being quite easy to sharpen.

These particular shapes of knives have been used for decades and decades in numerous wars and other facets of life by millions of people. Ergo, they are a great design. Typically though they're not the first blade that people usually suggest to use as a bush craft type knife however IMO I believe they would make a fantastic bush knife.

They have a full tang construction, the tang however being hidden inside the handle. Don't be misled by the concept that they are a stick tang however. The tang is certainly not stick thin but they are not a exposed full tang like you find on the Becker range. There are pictures available of a sectioned blue print that gives you an indication of how wide the tang is. Whilst the original design had stress risers where the tang meets the handle I believe the next generation of F/Us have been modified with radiused inner corners (someone correct me if I'm wrong here).

I have a D2 Extreme F/U that has the same shape as the MK2 and am looking at getting myself one of the 1317s Dog Head F/Us. They look super cool. If you wanna see this knife in use as a bush knife check out Lost Vikings thread. Brilliantly written with some great pics of it in action. Anyway, hope that helped Nathan..

http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php/1300572-Dog-s-Head-Utility-The-First-Thirty-Days
thank you kindly.
 
I'd begin with a Mk1. Basic configuration "bushcraft" hunting knife. It is a "no frills" approach. (This particular hunting/general purpose pattern has been In use for about 85 years). Unless your heart is set on a "combat-type" blade, the Mk1 should serve you well.

It works for me.
 
The Mk1 is a nice little blade, but you might feel like you need a little more knife. I'd say get yourself a Mk2 and you won't regret it. Just make sure you SnoSeal the handle and sheath!
 
so not feeling a lot of love for thE MK2?

I have all three... Great knives all.

picture0101024.jpg


...but more than not the 1217 (Mk2) stays home. It's just a really big knife for most jobs.

The 1250 (short KABAR) is a beast that just needs a good belt grinding to thin the blade up a little bit, for finer work.

The Mk1 is just a little thin for the heavy work, but excels at both the fine and general duties.


I would even venture to say that if you wanted just One(1.0) knife?

...then that would be a pricy 5" Fallkniven S1:

S1_4abca7622fc3f.jpg



...or an economical 5" Ontario 499 Pilot Survival Knife:

499-air-force-knife-6150.jpg





GR
 
Back
Top