First work with my BK-2

dogboye

Gold Member
Joined
Nov 23, 1999
Messages
7,150
Finally got back out into the woods to do some camping/hiking after a 5-year hiatus (to include a new daughter and waiting for her to get a little older). This past Friday, my wife, our 4 y.o. daugher, and 8 y.o. Rott headed to Crabtree Meadows in George Washington Nat'l Forest for a couple of days of car camping (backpacking in still isn't in the cards for a couple more years). The relevance here is, as alluded by the subject, I had my brand-new BK-2 with me as one of my cutters. It literally had not cut anything more than paper and arm-hair since I got it and outfitted it with K-Bar's micarta scales. BTW, it is a Gen2. I had free-handed the edge a bit on a stone and Spyderco Doublestuff, but wasn't satisfied. So I did some convexing of the primary bevel after watching a couple of virtuovoice's convexing vids. I did not want to do a full convex of the primary and secondary, though, because I watned to keep the coating. I don't especially like coated blades, but it's there for a reason, and K-Bar's isn't overly obtrusive, IMO. The convexing really brought it to life "on paper," and I'm really glad I did. I can still touch it up on stones, but it seems to cut much better. And I pretty much started beating it like a rented mule as soon as we hit the camp site. It was about 40degF, the wind was blowing HARD (IIRC, the forecast for the valley was for 20mph winds, and we were up on a ridge), and it was spitting rain. I started splitting wood with it with a baton to get into some core wood looking for some dry, and then was able to get some nice feathering of the drier "innards" of wood. I was kinda shocked at how well it whittled the shavings considering how thick a chunk o' metal it is. The wind and the rain was so bad that my butane lighter would not stay lit. I had to pull out an LMF Scout Firesteel, which came close to getting the fire started. But I ended up having to cheat and use one of the tinder-blocks from this, which worked like a charm. I didn't have the Strike Force out, and the lighter still wouldn't stay lit at all, so I ended up using the Scout to light the block, best I remember. Got a fire started, and was getting it going, but the rain kept getting more steady, and no one wanted to be out in it anyway. So we got in the vestibule of the tent and cooked our dinner on the Optimus NOVA.

The BK-2 was pretty much my constant companion... err... "Campanion"... for the two days I was there, and it worked well. I used it to chop through numerous downed tree branches, and on one old oak that had been drying in the woods long enough that all that as left was the hard core-wood. I ended up using it on that old oak for only part of the chop, though, and finished with the Gerber Back Paxe that I had, only because the Paxe's handle seemed to work better once I got to the core of the tree (busted my knuckle a couple of times on the tree with the BK-2). But while the handle set-up on the Paxe was better, the BK seemed to chop at least as good, and maybe better. Not sure why; both were sharpened to the point of shaving before we left for the trip. And as for beating, even though I KNOW it is abusive, I even hammered the spine of the BK-2 into the oak a couple of times, kinda lightly. I knew metal on metal would be bad, so I didn't do much with that. But it stood up to it marvelously.

As I mentioned, I put the micarta slabs on it. I like them. They really have a nice texture to them, and look nice on the black blade. BUT.... I'm not sure about them and chopping. I wished I had had the basic scales with me while I was there and could have tried them. The micarta scales were causing some hot spots, and I think I just barely escaped some blisters. The basic plastic scales feel like they would work better, but then I don't know how secure they would have been. I guess I would recommend anyone that gets a Becker try it without the micarta scales first, if you're going to be doing any heavy-duty work like that. I don't regret buying them at all, almost purely for the aesthetics. But thought I should mention it.

Anyway, after a couple of days of this, getting back home, the BK-2 would still scrape arm hair a little, and the coating is still in good shape. After this weekend, the BK-2 has made me a believer in thick, well-designed blades. It will definitely be on more trips with me.
 
Are the micarta scales thinner, or the same dimensions as the factory ones?
Thanks:thumbup:
I do think the smooth handles are less likely to have hotspots, and will be fine with a knife the size of the BK2. I've slung the Patrol Machete like a boomerang a few times, and several years ago wound up vandalizing the handles on it and a BK7 with a file, then sanding the edges of the grooves smooth. They look like crap, but do give better grip without creating hotspots. You could probably sand the micarta handles smoother pretty easily-just don't breathe the dust if you go to sanding on them.
 
Congrats on an awesome outing. Now you see why my BK2 is my favorite blade by far. How were you gripping the handle when you were chopping? I only ask, 'cause I slip my hand down, wrap a lanyard around, grab the "ball" on the bottom and wail away.

You didn't cheat. You started the fire, that was the intent. You needed a fire, doesn't matter if you used a road flare.

Welcome to the fold. Moose
 
The scales appear to be the same thickness. I think my BK-2 has the newer K-Bar scales, not left-over Camillus scales (the plastic ones).

I chopped exactly as you describe, Moose, as I had seen you mention in another thread. Although I didn't have a lanyard. It was plenty secure, though.

I don't think I'll modify the micarta scales. And I'll probably just leave them on, too. They worked, they're grippy, and they look good.
 
Congrats on an awesome outing. Now you see why my BK2 is my favorite blade by far. How were you gripping the handle when you were chopping? I only ask, 'cause I slip my hand down, wrap a lanyard around, grab the "ball" on the bottom and wail away.

That's the only way to chop with the BK2 or ESEE5 slipped down with a lanyard:thumbup: if not your not going to chop much:grumpy:
 
Throwing a little bit more info over on the Wilderness Survival forum. It is going to be a few observations on some other ... I dunno... skills? ... that I worked on, some lessons learned, etc. It is this thread.
 
Congrats on an awesome outing. Now you see why my BK2 is my favorite blade by far. How were you gripping the handle when you were chopping? I only ask, 'cause I slip my hand down, wrap a lanyard around, grab the "ball" on the bottom and wail away.

That's the only way to chop with the BK2 or ESEE5 slipped down with a lanyard:thumbup: if not your not going to chop much:grumpy:

No doubt about it. I been using a BK2 for about 10yrs, and those that say it can't chop, don't own one. Consider is weighs more than a BK9, that dude bites deep. Moose
 
it really does.its like a meat cleaver with a point.im gonna test that theory this hunting season butchering deer.
 
Hey Rockspyder....

Thanks for sharing your outing with us.....As far as hotspots go the smoother scales of the Grivory goes Will Fennell and Anthony Lombardo both plenty stout and plenty strong dipped a Becker with the Grivory scales in automatic transmission fluid and then bare-handed drove them into a tree trunk without a single slip....DO NOT DO THIS AT HOME....(they are both a bit crazy and were working for BJ at the time which has a tendency do induce mental illness)....I would NOT do this myself and I LOOOOVE my handles.....The Micarta is lovely stuff and is a great fashion statement and I love the feel but, If I gotta lotta work to do give me Grivoryor semi polished Micarta......

A great post....Always good to have a plan "B" and "C".....

ALL best....

ethan
 
No doubt about it. I been using a BK2 for about 10yrs, and those that say it can't chop, don't own one. Consider is weighs more than a BK9, that dude bites deep. Moose

the 2 is heavier than the 9 and it dose bite deep,I've owned a 9 for six years
and the 2 for almost two years.if I had to pick just one for chopping it would be
the 9.the BK2 is such a well rounded all around thick knife:thumbup:
 
A great post....Always good to have a plan "B" and "C".....

ALL best....

ethan

Good words to live by. I heard a quote, don't remember where now, but it went something like, "Life is all about how you handle plan B."

Thanks again.
 
I don't have a BK2 yet so my experience with one is zilch..

but I don't think weight has much to do with a knifes ability to chop, I have a lot of HI machetes, super heavy and they're lame at chopping compared to a tramotina cheapo machete to be perfectly honest.. Balance, leverage, blade geometry all tends to have a part in 'chopping' ability.. weight IMO plays a small part..

with that said, my BK7 tends to chop better when I choke down on the ball..

I too love the stock handles, I've said it before and I'll say it again, I think Becker Knives are one of, if not the best value knife for the money.. High quality.. :thumbup:
 
I think Becker Knives are one of, if not the best value knife for the money.. High quality..

I think so also. I am considering getting another BK2 for truck carry. It's definately a very versatile knife. It's one of the best knives I've ever purchased . I've also considered micarta scales , but didn't get them for fear of the exact same issue posted by the OP.( hot spots.) I'm happy with the grivory as is.
 
Deff getting a Bk2 soon. Maybe I can slip some hints to the wife. Birthday and X-mas is coming up. On second thought. I have to straight up tell her... she never gets my hints.:confused:
 
Good luck with the hint, or the tell. I do believe you will quite like the BK-2.
 
I roll a 4" section of bicycle inner tube around the grivory handle and that solves any slipping or vibration problems. I love the shape.

Also, for the edge: I way prefer convex. I'd never want to touch up with stones. I keep a soft flat nail file around as my 'stone'. It's more consistent, comes in multiple grits, and costs $0.50 to replace.

Thanks for the first-time-out story.

-Daizee
 
I roll a 4" section of bicycle inner tube around the grivory handle and that solves any slipping or vibration problems. I love the shape.

Also, for the edge: I way prefer convex. I'd never want to touch up with stones. I keep a soft flat nail file around as my 'stone'. It's more consistent, comes in multiple grits, and costs $0.50 to replace.

Thanks for the first-time-out story.

-Daizee

You're welcome.

Good call on the "nail file," if it is what I'm thinking about. Kinda had two sides, different grits, and a piece of material in the middle that makes it give a little? I have those all around, in various grits. Not so much for touch-up, but for "rough-in" and some refinement.
 
Back
Top