Fixed-up old knives

Joined
Feb 20, 2019
Messages
5
My Dad used to fix-up broke old pokets knives (swap scales / blades) and trade them for stuff we needed around the house. Well, I've been dabbling in it lately and just wondered what folks thought about trades. Now, I'm just getting started, so no "production line" stuff is going on. But Its a way to keep myself out of trouble and it lets me buy a lot of knives, so I'm happy! My question would be, is there a "market" for repaired knives? I imagine I'm going to, eventually, have quite a few, so could I trade these for more broken ones? Dad usually got eggs, fresh milk, or firewood for his...but I dont imagine that wiould be the case today.

Thanks for taking the time to read this and I look forward to ya'lls thoughts and ideas!!

EDIT: 27 Feb. Thank you for all the responses! I was also wonder if it was ethical to trade/sale such knives. I totally plan on telling folks they are repaired, but it has got me wondering.
 
Last edited:
I dabble in messing around with old knives and really enjoy it. It is an awesome hobby and I get a kick out of bringing back old knives that are normally left to die.

As far as there being a market for these, I have never tried to sell or trade any. But I bet there are plenty of people out there who'd love to have a restored knife. Keep at it and have fun. :)

The knives I mess with, I just end up carrying. For me, there is a great deal of satisfaction to be had knowing I took something that someone discarded and now it's back in a pocket being used. The last knife I worked on is an old Colonial Ranger. Cheaper knife back in its day but I love it and carry it all the time.

Horsewright Horsewright , it looks like your avatar is Gus McCrae. Anyone with an avatar such as yours is ok in my book brother. 👍
 
Last edited:
I'd certainly trade eggs for knives... I trade tree work for beef and vehicle repair all the time.

I'd suppose your market would depend on what you'd be able to trade for, but hitting flea markets and whatnot with a bag of knives might pay off. Knap ins might be another good place to hit up if there's any in your area.
 
I dabble in messing around with old knives and really enjoy it. It is an awesome hobby and I get a kick out of bringing back old knives that are normally left to die.

As far as there being a market for these, I have never tried to sell or trade any. But I bet there are plenty of people out there who'd love to have a restored knife. Keep at it and have fun. :)

The knives I mess with, I just end up carrying. For me, there is a great deal of satisfaction to be had knowing I took something that someone discarded and now it's back in a pocket being used. The last knife I worked on is an old Colonial Ranger. Cheaper knife back in its day but I love it and carry it all the time.

Horsewright Horsewright , it looks like your avatar is Gus McCrae. Anyone with an avatar such as yours is ok in my book brother. 👍
Sorry nobody as famous as Ol Augustus. Just me and my old bridle horse, a big paint, Clancy The Rock, in that pic. He was called The Rock long before we ever heard it was a name for a wrestler. He lived till he was 36 which is very old for a horse. Average life span for a horse they say is bout 20. He stayed sound too, was using him on the ranch up till he was a bout 30. Then he was retired out at the ranch with some other older horses. 2,000 acres of horsey Cancun. I traded a black mare and $500 for Clancy. This was back in the early to mid 90's and wasn't making knives then so no knives involved in the trade. Let me take a minute to relate a short story to let ya know what a special horse he really was. This was after he was retired out at the ranch.

We were gathering remnants and had five I was chasing up this brush covered hillside. Brush was so bad that I couldn't see the cattle, just hear them crashing through the brush. A buddy's wife was riding with me and I realized that she was no longer with me, so I slowed down and let the cattle go, as I was more concerned for her as she was riding a horse that occasionally could be opinionated. I headed back down the way I'd come and in a few minutes hooked back up with her. Fortunately she wasn't having horse trouble she just wasn't used to going that fast through such rough country. I figured those five miscreants were long gone but we took our time climbing up that brush covered hill as I knew from the top I'd be able see a long ways and maybe spot them. Well dang if Clancy didn't have them gathered up under a lone tree on the top. He was circling them there keeping them under the tree. Now nobody is riding Clancy, he's doing this on his own! He's turned loose in this 2,000 acre pasture. When we get to the top we waited a minute to let our horses catch their breath and then we pushed the cattle down a long ridge to the water in The Bowl. I was on the left, Angie was on the right and Clancy was in the middle directly behind the cattle. He pushed them all the way to the water by himself a little over a mile. We just rode the flanks to help keep em pointed straight. We let them get a sip or two and then pushed those five problems in leather bags out of The Bowl and onto the flats and then over to the corrals and into a pen. This was a distance of over two miles. When we got to the flats and made the turn to the west to head to the corrals, Angie and Clancy switched places, it was Clancy's idea. He just trotted over to where she was and she moved over to where he'd been behind the cattle, and we pushed the cattle to the corrals. At the corrals we pushed em into a pen and closed the gate Clancy trotted off and we didn't see him again that day. You know moving cattle is an art form and he was an artist. He was never out of time or too far ahead or too far behind. He was perfect, The Rock. Why did he switch positions with Angie? Cause when I was using him a lot I would often take the right side as there were lots of steep hill sides there that the cattle could escape back up to the high country. Ya get a few head on those hillsides and it was like herding cats. So that was his spot, the place he was use to. They didn't even try, not with The Rock on duty.

Branding with The Rock

9TZNCbk.jpg
 
Last edited:
I think there is a market as long as you aren't sanding on the blades or anything to try making them look new.
For the most part many people tend to avoid knives that look like bubba ( not that you're a bubba ) took a rotary tool to it.
If you're rehabbing the knives in a smart way by leaving the age / character of a blade while just fixing what absolutely needs to be fix these could be some great looking old knives that people would love to have.
 
Sorry nobody as famous as Ol Augustus. Just me and my old bridle horse, a big paint, Clancy The Rock, in that pic. He was called The Rock long before we ever heard it was a name for a wrestler. He lived till he was 36 which is very old for a horse. Average life span for a horse they say is bout 20. He stayed sound too, was using him on the ranch up till he was a bout 30. Then he was retired out at the ranch with some other older horses. 2,000 acres of horsey Cancun. I traded a black mare and $500 for Clancy. This was back in the early to mid 90's and wasn't making knives then so no knives involved in the trade. Let me take a minute to relate a short story to let ya know what a special horse he really was. This was after he was retired out at the ranch.

We were gathering remnants and had five I was chasing up this brush covered hillside. Brush was so bad that I couldn't see the cattle, just hear them crashing through the brush. A buddy's wife was riding with me and I realized that she was no longer with me, so I slowed down and let the cattle go, as I was more concerned for her as she was riding a horse that occasionally could be opinionated. I headed back down the way I'd come and in a few minutes hooked back up with her. Fortunately she wasn't having horse trouble she just wasn't used to going that fast through such rough country. I figured those five miscreants were long gone but we took our time climbing up that brush covered hill as I knew from the top I'd be able see a long ways and maybe spot them. Well dang if Clancy didn't have them gathered up under a lone tree on the top. He was circling them there keeping them under the tree. Now nobody is riding Clancy, he's doing this on his own! He's turned loose in this 2,000 acre pasture. When we get to the top we waited a minute to let our horses catch their breath and then we pushed the cattle down a long ridge to the water in The Bowl. I was on the left, Angie was on the right and Clancy was in the middle directly behind the cattle. He pushed them all the way to the water by himself a little over a mile. We just rode the flanks to help keep em pointed straight. We let them get a sip or two and then pushed those five problems in leather bags out of The Bowl and onto the flats and then over to the corrals and into a pen. This was a distance of over two miles. When we got to the flats and made the turn to the west to head to the corrals, Angie and Clancy switched places, it was Clancy's idea. He just trotted over to where she was and she moved over to where he'd been behind the cattle, and we pushed the cattle to the corrals. At the corrals we pushed em into a pen and closed the gate Clancy trotted off and we didn't see him again that day. You know moving cattle is an art form and he was an artist. He was never out of time or too far ahead or too far behind. He was perfect, The Rock. Why did he switch positions with Angie? Cause when I was using him a lot I would often take the right side as there were lots of steep hill sides there that the cattle could escape back up to the high country. Ya get a few head on those hillsides and it was like herding cats. So that was his spot, the place he was use to. They didn't even try, not with The Rock on duty.

Branding with The Rock

9TZNCbk.jpg

Awesome story, thank you for sharing that. Horses are amazing animals he sure didn't forget what he has done many times either. The pic does look like ol Gus though and I half expected you to mention that you were being chased by some Mexican bandits. :) Thank you again for the story, that made my day. 👍
 
Sorry nobody as famous as Ol Augustus. Just me and my old bridle horse, a big paint, Clancy The Rock, in that pic. He was called The Rock long before we ever heard it was a name for a wrestler. He lived till he was 36 which is very old for a horse. Average life span for a horse they say is bout 20. He stayed sound too, was using him on the ranch up till he was a bout 30. Then he was retired out at the ranch with some other older horses. 2,000 acres of horsey Cancun. I traded a black mare and $500 for Clancy. This was back in the early to mid 90's and wasn't making knives then so no knives involved in the trade. Let me take a minute to relate a short story to let ya know what a special horse he really was. This was after he was retired out at the ranch.

We were gathering remnants and had five I was chasing up this brush covered hillside. Brush was so bad that I couldn't see the cattle, just hear them crashing through the brush. A buddy's wife was riding with me and I realized that she was no longer with me, so I slowed down and let the cattle go, as I was more concerned for her as she was riding a horse that occasionally could be opinionated. I headed back down the way I'd come and in a few minutes hooked back up with her. Fortunately she wasn't having horse trouble she just wasn't used to going that fast through such rough country. I figured those five miscreants were long gone but we took our time climbing up that brush covered hill as I knew from the top I'd be able see a long ways and maybe spot them. Well dang if Clancy didn't have them gathered up under a lone tree on the top. He was circling them there keeping them under the tree. Now nobody is riding Clancy, he's doing this on his own! He's turned loose in this 2,000 acre pasture. When we get to the top we waited a minute to let our horses catch their breath and then we pushed the cattle down a long ridge to the water in The Bowl. I was on the left, Angie was on the right and Clancy was in the middle directly behind the cattle. He pushed them all the way to the water by himself a little over a mile. We just rode the flanks to help keep em pointed straight. We let them get a sip or two and then pushed those five problems in leather bags out of The Bowl and onto the flats and then over to the corrals and into a pen. This was a distance of over two miles. When we got to the flats and made the turn to the west to head to the corrals, Angie and Clancy switched places, it was Clancy's idea. He just trotted over to where she was and she moved over to where he'd been behind the cattle, and we pushed the cattle to the corrals. At the corrals we pushed em into a pen and closed the gate Clancy trotted off and we didn't see him again that day. You know moving cattle is an art form and he was an artist. He was never out of time or too far ahead or too far behind. He was perfect, The Rock. Why did he switch positions with Angie? Cause when I was using him a lot I would often take the right side as there were lots of steep hill sides there that the cattle could escape back up to the high country. Ya get a few head on those hillsides and it was like herding cats. So that was his spot, the place he was use to. They didn't even try, not with The Rock on duty.

Branding with The Rock

9TZNCbk.jpg
Watching any animal with a job do their thing, and do it well, is a real treat.
 
Sorry nobody as famous as Ol Augustus. Just me and my old bridle horse, a big paint, Clancy The Rock, in that pic. He was called The Rock long before we ever heard it was a name for a wrestler. He lived till he was 36 which is very old for a horse. Average life span for a horse they say is bout 20. He stayed sound too, was using him on the ranch up till he was a bout 30. Then he was retired out at the ranch with some other older horses. 2,000 acres of horsey Cancun. I traded a black mare and $500 for Clancy. This was back in the early to mid 90's and wasn't making knives then so no knives involved in the trade. Let me take a minute to relate a short story to let ya know what a special horse he really was. This was after he was retired out at the ranch.

We were gathering remnants and had five I was chasing up this brush covered hillside. Brush was so bad that I couldn't see the cattle, just hear them crashing through the brush. A buddy's wife was riding with me and I realized that she was no longer with me, so I slowed down and let the cattle go, as I was more concerned for her as she was riding a horse that occasionally could be opinionated. I headed back down the way I'd come and in a few minutes hooked back up with her. Fortunately she wasn't having horse trouble she just wasn't used to going that fast through such rough country. I figured those five miscreants were long gone but we took our time climbing up that brush covered hill as I knew from the top I'd be able see a long ways and maybe spot them. Well dang if Clancy didn't have them gathered up under a lone tree on the top. He was circling them there keeping them under the tree. Now nobody is riding Clancy, he's doing this on his own! He's turned loose in this 2,000 acre pasture. When we get to the top we waited a minute to let our horses catch their breath and then we pushed the cattle down a long ridge to the water in The Bowl. I was on the left, Angie was on the right and Clancy was in the middle directly behind the cattle. He pushed them all the way to the water by himself a little over a mile. We just rode the flanks to help keep em pointed straight. We let them get a sip or two and then pushed those five problems in leather bags out of The Bowl and onto the flats and then over to the corrals and into a pen. This was a distance of over two miles. When we got to the flats and made the turn to the west to head to the corrals, Angie and Clancy switched places, it was Clancy's idea. He just trotted over to where she was and she moved over to where he'd been behind the cattle, and we pushed the cattle to the corrals. At the corrals we pushed em into a pen and closed the gate Clancy trotted off and we didn't see him again that day. You know moving cattle is an art form and he was an artist. He was never out of time or too far ahead or too far behind. He was perfect, The Rock. Why did he switch positions with Angie? Cause when I was using him a lot I would often take the right side as there were lots of steep hill sides there that the cattle could escape back up to the high country. Ya get a few head on those hillsides and it was like herding cats. So that was his spot, the place he was use to. They didn't even try, not with The Rock on duty.

Branding with The Rock

9TZNCbk.jpg

Clancy must have been quite a horse.
 
I also like Anza knives since they are made from files, sort of fits this category, maybe, using another another material for a blade, repurposing.
 
There is a market for restored knives provided they are done correctly and only taken to the point where as much of the knife as possible remains original. There is little or no market for Frankenstein blades assembled from odd parts. These usually become personal users and little more.

N2s
 
There is always a market for this type of work. Whether you're trading them, selling them as flea market knives, online, or as a service...if you are replacing covers or blades, you should do the responsible thing and mark your work in some way so that potential future owners know that the knife has been worked on. A good mechanic can do work that most people will think is factory. A great one can do work that only very experienced collectors can tell isn't original.

Marking your work will help alert buyers, and it's the honest thing to do. And please share pictures of your work, we love pictures!
 
Awesome story, thank you for sharing that. Horses are amazing animals he sure didn't forget what he has done many times either. The pic does look like ol Gus though and I half expected you to mention that you were being chased by some Mexican bandits. :) Thank you again for the story, that made my day. 👍
Ya bet!

Watching any animal with a job do their thing, and do it well, is a real treat.
Really is!

Clancy must have been quite a horse.
He really was. He’s buried over yonder here at the house. Couple big Rocks overtop of him.
 
Back
Top