Dude... I've been throwing the Ralph Thorn's large Shur Knife and the North Wind for the last year and am so stoked on the quality and design. Highly recommended.
I am one of those guys who, if I have a knife, I have to throw it... at least a few times. Yeah, I have thrown knives I shouldn't have, for sure.
Regrets? Yeah, kind of. But I have a good feel for what it's like to throw a large variety of shapes, sizes, balances, textures... That being said, I am still a beginner.
These two Flying Steel knives I have are so so good. Worth the money for sure in design and materials. You get what you pay for in this case.
They won't stay nice forever, but they'll stay nicer for longer.
First off, I have accidentally bounced them both into a concrete wall and watched them hit tip first several times :-/ The tip was rolled over a little bit, but not much AT ALL. Not close to what I was afraid to see when I picked them up. Pleasantly surprised. That's when I realized the design is not theory or a gimmick. The geometry of the facets works for sure. I spent 30 minutes re-faceting the tip on a stone. They now have a little more of an obtuse point, but that has resulted in a harder to bend tip... and probably a little more energy needed to make them stick. I haven't noticed the more energy needed though. It's so miniscule as far as a full arm throw is concerned.
They feel great and feel heavy for their size; which I really like. I handed them to a friend I was teaching, and right off the bat she said, "wow, they really feel different." I think she was just innocently keying in on the weight for size, the tone the metal makes and the balance.
They are a little hard to let go of if they get wet (throwing in the rain), but that is how any knife would feel.
Really, they are the best throwing knives I've ever let go of in the direction of a target. I'd say I have technically abused them by any knifemaker's standards, and they have put up well with it.
I have a stainless thower, and have seen chips and divots come off it. I have yet to see anything like that with the Flying Steel throwers. I did leave the North Wind on a table with some moisture on it overnight, and awoke to see some discoloration. That's what happens with higher carbon steel, of course. I put some oil on it and it looks much better, and the spot did not get bigger. It happened quicker than I thought it would... word to the wise.
I like these knives so much, seeing this thread is what prompted me to create an account here at bladeforums. My dream is to own everything they make. I am assuming their other knives are similar in quality when I say that.
As for the conical tipped options... why would you not want that design? Not rhetorical. I'm actually asking.