Fold Knives Locking Systems Opinions

Joined
Jun 13, 2022
Messages
21
This is just my opinion. Feel free to agree or disagree.
My opinion is based on experience and ease of use.


Axis Lock (and other sliding bar locks such as Hogue Able, SOG XR):thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup:
Liner Lock :thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup:
Frame (Intergal) Lock :thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup:
Compression Lock (Spyderco) :thumbsdown:
Button Lock :thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup:
Slip Joint (No Lock) :thumbsup:
Lock Back :thumbsup::thumbsup:
Tri-ad Lock - no exxperience
Ball Bearing Lock (Spyderco only) :thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup:
Arc Lock (SOG Only) :thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup:
Twist Lock :thumbsup:

My first decent knife was the Buck 110, in the 1970's. It was big, heavy and fit on my duty belt with accompanying sheath.
My next decent knife, in the 2000's, was the Benchmade Mini Griptilian. When I bought it I never knew knives could cost so much.😊. It was easy to figure out how to open and close.
From then on, it has been a knife here, a knife there, looking at what I liked and videos on YouTube, which I know are the author's opinion. As you know some present better than others.

Not until recently have I gotten a Spyderco. I am one of those guys who think the ParaMilitary 2 and the Para 3 are ugly, like a dead pelican. BUT, I do understand the ergonomics of those knives. I also understand Spyderco's spydie hole trademark, if that is what you can call it. What I like about Spyderco knives are the very sharp, very slicey blades.

Other than looks, I prefer knives with steel liners, for heavier use. Examples: Benchmade Presidio (I and II), Benchmade Adamas series, Benchmade Turret, Spyderco Sage series, Spyderco Manix 2, Spyderco Chaparral.

I do have Benchmade Bugouts. However, all have had their scales replaced with carbon fiber or titanium. Regarding the Benchmade Bugout, I dislike the short, weak pocket clip. I lost my first Bugout in a field. It simply slid out of my pocket, lost forever.

So there are my opinions. I know I started out with the locking systems but digressed to other things.

🤔
 
My favorite is still the compression lock. Although I don’t don’t mind backlocks. Axis locks sit weird in my hands to operate. The compression lock just takes one finger to use.
 
I work with gloves on a decent part of the year.

Shark lock is the best work knife I've found. Followed by-
Compression
Axis

My favorite non work knife is a frame lock.

Also a big fan of random locks like the one on the buck marksman. Not sure what it's called
 
Yes, the compression lock, and I feel I must add the Shark lock too for its similar operation, remain my favorite overall lock. Combination of fast opening/closing plus strength. One motion open, one motion closed. Of course, I open two handed in some company.

A ball lock is stronger than the Axis lock, but not as smooth. Axis is probably fine for EDC, but I have never owned a BM folder. Too high failure rate. Backlocks and midlocks, classic and strong, the Triad is safe and good, easily one hand opening. Just do not have any fingers in the path of the blade. Pinky and pointer firmly on the G10, and it is all good.

A liner lock, when well-made, is OK. I have many as beaters. I know I have some prejudice against framelocks after seeing someone make like 20 ZTs in a row fail. I have been enjoying the Spyderco Advocate, though, sweet action.
 
I lost interest in liner locks and frame locks after I had one un-lock on me. It was my fault, trying to "gorilla" a knife through material that it was neither sharp enough or particularly suited to cutting. I'm still a fan of lockbacks and related machinery, because I have yet to experience problems with one. Likewise, AXIS/Crossbar/similar style locks: they haven't let me down, yet.
 
Back
Top