Freehand stones or new knife...

Joined
Sep 17, 2011
Messages
35
Im currently stuck between getting a few dmt dia-sharp plates and a spyderco 306uf stone and learning how to freehand or getting a new knife (chaparral, stretch, or manix 2). I cant afford to do both right now but I have wanted to learn to freehand for a while and after spending hours looking through the forums and watching youtube I think im ready to take the plunge. Problem is, I also want to get a new knife haha. What do you all think. New knife or some stones?
 
A good set of stones and learn on the knives you have now.
You can pick up another knife later.
A good sharpening system is always a good thing to have.
 
Stones. If you're like me, you'll always want a new knife. That's nothing new. Get the stones.
 
I will have to side with everyone else.
You buy a good set of stones, you shouldn't want another.
A knife on the other hand, you're always going to want more. Buy the stones now and learn sooner rather than later.
I really should take my own advice. Get a good stone or two for touchups and sharpening. Or atleast more sandpaper and a spare mousepad lol. I have a lansky but I still like the sandpaper mousepad thing more. I only use the guided system if I'm reprofiling or removing large chips/nick/dings.
 
I think you should get the knife... who needs them to be sharp :cool:
 
I sharpen freehand and have decided to get some Diamond stones when I get the extra cash.
My current stones are great but I want some Diamond stones. I'll have to hold off from buying a knife with that money.
I will likely see a knife I like, but keeping the knives I love extremely sharp is an important thing for me. =]
Knives are great and getting new ones is fun. But it's better to get a nice set up and learn.
You'll always want another knife or find one you must have. The sharpening set up will help you take care of present and future knives.
You'll have tons of nice knives throughout your time enjoying them.
You'll likely only go through a few sharpening systems if more than one. Better to have a nice set up you can depend on for a long time and that you'll like. =]
 
Definitely stones if you're interested in learning to sharpen. You'll have more use of the stones compared to "yet another" knife.
 
For sure the stones man. I love sharpening free hand there is kind of a relaxing quality too it for me. Also when I first started collecting I had no idea so many people had issues sharpening free hand because I had been taught from such a young age. It truly is a unique skill to be very good at. Almost like an art.
 
Def the stones.

I've been practicing free hand for a little while now.

And while I'm pretty good, I'm no where near great at it(YET).

But day to day there are ALWAYS more knives I want.

Getting some good stones and learning to use them is a great art to know.
 
The stones are a great investment. I'm sort of a novice freehander myself and have a patchwork setup of stones, but they are very satisfying. I found the old schrade super sharp bowie that my folks gave me years ago when I was really young the other day. It was so dull it was ripping cardboard when I started, and buy the end it was sharp enough to shave with (though not as sharp as my folders that I've spent more time with). I'm sure we've watched many of the same freehand videos on youtube, but if you haven't seen them jdavis882 has tons of great ones that should help sell you on it.

You can also sort of piece together a set bit by bit like I've done for moderate results without breaking the bank so to speak. I actually use the stones from a lansky guided system freehand (usually in a vise or similar setup for stability since they are small) for the rougher grits at the moment (about $30), a spyderco double stuff that never leaves my pocket (~$25), and a homemade strop I built ($5 for scrap leather from a local saddle maker, a paint stirrer, rubber cement, and however much a little green compound costs). Its far from ideal, but it can definitely help you get a feel for it and learn or at least it helped me. I would definitely recommend bigger or more secure stones as you can afford it though, sharpening tougher steels on small difficult to secure stones can definitely be taxing on the stabilizer muscles in your wrists.
 
Back
Top