g10 vs. canvas micarta opinions?

Josh Muller

Josh Muller

Joined
Jun 22, 2003
Messages
3,049
okay... so the nuclear fallout handles may be off the road for what normal handles look like - BUT, being a fan of glow in the dark fan, i think that i wouldnt mind (and would probably like) them in a glow in the dark on black finish.

but i would only do it if i felt that g10 was the better choice - so, what are your guys's thoughts?


specifically, im interested in the wear patterns of g10, wether it will chip, compact down, or just abraze off the impact point when it hits hard objects, and wether it can take a low grit finish.

also does it soak in moisture like canvas micarta? (doesnt efect the micarta - but it does take on moisture).

one more question, at a 200 grit finish, where does it lie in the micarta pattern? - paper micarta at 200 isn't very grippy, where as linen is moreso, and canvas has an inate rough finish that is gripy at almost any grit (as long as its textured (diamond pattern, rope pattern, whatever)
 
I think I can only answer one of your questions and that is no... :D

All G-10 I have dealt with will not retain/absorb moisture.
 
G-10/FR-4 Epoxy

G-10/FR-4 is a thermosetting industrial laminate consisting of a continuous filament glass cloth material with an epoxy resin binder. This product, first introduced in the 1950's, has characteristics of high strength, excellent electrical properties and chemical resistance. These properties are maintained not only at room temperature but also under humid or moist conditions.

Today what is called G-10 is actually FR-4, the flame retardant version of G-10. The material FR-4 can usually be used where G-10 is specified, however G-10 should not be used where FR-4 is specified.

Both G-10 and FR-4 are rated at 285 degree F continuous operating temperature. Because they are thermosets, no melting will occur with these grades, however charring will be observed after extended periods above the temperature rating. FR-4 has a flammability rating of 94 V-0.

With these outstanding characteristics, it is easy to understand why G-10/FR-4 is such a versatile material and is used in a wide variety of applications.
Properties

High dielectric strength

Radiation resistant

High tensile strength

Low cold flow or creep

Chemically resistant

High flexural strength

Dimensional stability

Low moisture absorption

Low dissipation factor

High impact strength

Cryogenic serviceability
Applications

Electrical equipment Solder Frames
Aerospace conditions Test fixtures
Rocket cases Medical diagnostic
Antenna insulators Circuit board holders
Test boards Terminal boards
End plates Underwater conditions
Cryogenic insulation

The above found here....

Benchmade says:
G10- An extremely durable makeup of layers of fiberglass soaked in resin, then highly compressed and baked. Impervious to moisture or liquid and physically stable under climate change. Most commonly black, but is available in various colors, too. Benchmade was the first knife manufacturer to use G10.



These people say...
G-10 CR & G-11 CR
Cryogenic Glass Epoxy Lamitex® material maintains its electrical insulation properties and superior strength at temperatures as low as 4°F. It additionally meets MIL-I-247682 Type GEE/CR. Application acceptance has been established in super conductor power coils, high energy accelerators, superconducting generators and magnetic levitation for high speed rail transportation.
 
One other thing... Personally, I'm choosing the micarta for strength over the G-10. I've taken a hammer to micarta it won't bust. I've had G-10 handled folders (Granted the stock was thinner than said beaten micarta) that dropped and had small pieces come off and dents.

Others may have different experiences too... :confused:
 
interesting... i think that i will be going with micarta then...

if there is even the remotest possibility of chipping from rock damage, then id rather go with a sure thing...
 
Okay.. Just did a test that may mean something or nothing lol... Got a piece of G-10 1/16" thick and whacked it head on with a hammer. Didn't shatter. But I didn't try to power house it either. Unscientific, but my new opinion is that it would hold up and may be in the same field as micarta. I didn't consider the fact that the G-10 on my rat trap is thin, where as the handles on the AK would be contoured, yet thick.

Hopefully someone can give further insight. My opinion now stands that G-10 may be nearly as good as micarta if the G-10 is thick enough.

Sorry to be wishy-washy, but didn't want to give the wrong info. Anyone else have experience with G-10? :confused:
 
note: the bussecompanystore.com has bought all the green $hit and has shipped it to another planet in a galaxy far far away :thumbup: :thumbup:

micarta rules :cool:
 
The only advantage I see with G-10 is that it won't absorb water or moisture. Micarta handles with little moisture or palm sweat will get darker really quick. Because of this, micarta will offer a more sticky grip which is a good thing. Still, I wouldn't mind seeing Busses offered with optional g-10 scales.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top