Gatco or Lansky?

[jonnyt16]

I will be purchasing either the Gatco Edgemate or the Lansky sharpening system and was wondering which one you guys would recommend. I know most of you love the Spyderco Sharpmaker and I have tried that one and liked it but could never seem to get a razor sharp edge. Please refrain from offering me tips on technique with that as I have already decided to go with a Lansky or Gatco.

That being said, I know the Gatco and Lansky systems are almost identical (both use a clamp and guide rods) except that Lansky uses diamond hones? Anyway, wanted to see what you guys think and your experience with either one. Price isn't really a concern (as long as its under $90) Thanks!

 

[vmlew]

About the same. Gatco stones are wider. The thinner lansky negotiates curves better but the stones clog faster since you need more strokes for the same area. The rods on the Gatco pull out to extend and the Lansky's have to be screwed in which is one more thing to do. Which ever you decide on, be sure to get the optional stand as it helps a lot. The Gatco is more sturdy. Also, Lansky makes standard kits without the more expensive diamond hones.

Another good sharpener I like is the KME :
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zZQWhTGkb5c

and edge pro which I still suck at (so I don't use much).

The Spyderco sharpmaker is still great for minor touch ups.

 

[Sep]

Neither. I'd pick DMT Aligner.