Gerber knives

Joined
Mar 22, 2006
Messages
5,944
WHile remaining popular on the commercial market, I haven't seen anyone speak of gerber on the forums Was wondering what the opinions of The fixed drop-point freeman hunter I saw it on line, looks nice but can't find anything on blade thickness..Thanks
 
I have owned a few gerbers, good enough blades but I always found them hard to sharpen. I had a gerber multi tool that worked well for me for several years, carried it everywhere, then one of the locks and the slider for the pliers broke within a week of each other. Leatherman has a much better multi tool, but I really liked flicking out the pliers like it was a switchblade.
Sorry, don't know anything about the freeman hunter.


Just did a search in the knife reviews forum. Good place to look. Anyway, Fonly should be able to answer your questions.

http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=434337&highlight=gerber+freeman+hunter
 
I also love my gerber pliers, as well as their axe and hatchet as well. Never tried the knife you're talking about.
 
If the description is correct it shows it being 440A Stainless Steel.

You may want to check on the quality and attributes of that steel to see if it is what you think you need.
 
My opinion is that Gerber used to by synonymous with quality. But I think that has changed. Although I'm sure they still make some quality products, they've also diluted their product lines with some pretty shoddy materials. For example, the freeman hunter you're interested in - 440A is pretty low quality knife steel. Not the worst, but not what I'd want to carry.
 
the listing I saw for the freeman hunter lists it as aus 8 which I believe is similar to 440 b not the best steel but not bad for a stainless either
 
I have several older Gerbers, a couple of Mark IIs, a Folding Sportsman II drop point in stag, an early bolt action, a stag sheath knife I can't remember the name of and an 8" BMF in a 9" sheath I bought froma buddy of mine. They all seem to be good quality esp the FS IID and the sheath knife. The current generation sure doesn't have the reputation the older stuff did. Maybe someone can join in with a report of a current model.
 
I looked at one, Wal-Mart is clearing them out at $23.00. It doesn't look too bad, but I decided against it.
 
I've never been impressed with Gerber. At least not until I started learning about the older stuff out there. The older stuff is outstanding. Great steels, design, and craftsmanship. I'm collecting a few of them now.

I wonder when they started such a downhill slide?:(
 
Gerbers suck IMHO they used to be really good once apon a time. Now most of them are overglorified chinese crap.
 
i decided to venture into the gerber world and bought a multi-tool from the gerber line called the suspension.

i think its appropriatly called suspension because it will SUSPEND what ever activity you are trying to accomplish. darn thing needs TWO hands to open ANYTHING on it. my leatherman pulse is a MUCH better product.

think i'll either end up selling it, or trading it to someone who will be able to mod the damn thing to work well.

or just leave it where it is now, at the bottom of my glove box WAITING for someday when i'll need a decent/crappy multitool in which im in no rush to use. maybe crack open a few beers with them.

conclusion? i think i'll stick with other brands and stay away from gerber. particularly try to go with american or japanese made products.

anyways rant over.

cheers ^^

edit: i think its just those specific pliers i purchased were crappy because i've been told by my friend that gerber multi-tools are actually quite good.. just that the one i bought was a piece of shit.

so i take back my gerber sucks comment. just that the gerber SUSPENSION sucks :P
 
my gerber pilers are decent, not as heavy duty as some other ones, but I choose gerber mainly for the flip open design for removing hooks while fishing. If I use it for really heavy stuff, I would get a proper pair of pliers.
 
i have never been a fan of gerber they may be an okay knife but they just felt cheap in my hand but thats just my .02
 
hey guys, yeah just got in.

The freeman hunter is not bad, but like I said, the gut hook that comes on them are horrible. The main blade comes very sharp, as in shaving. There a very sturdy knife, but GET THE DROP POINT, cant say it enough. For a small dedicated hunter, it would make a nice knife. And it is made from 440A.
 
Some of us remember the old Gerber. That made knives.

I agree with Liam--the old Gerbers were a pain to sharpen and required a lot of it. Fortunately, they came razor-sharp out of the box.

Remember that the new Gerber is a subsidiary of Fiskars, the scissor people. If you're looking for where the downturn started, it started right there.

Although, I have heard nothing but good to great things about their axe (which isn't by default a Gerber product, but another product sold under the Gerber name courtesy Fiskars).
 
I've had three Gerber products; one of their old double edged boot knives, with a convex edge; a larger double-edged Faiborn-Sykes type commando knife that had a wasp waist with serrations, and a Fiskars made camp axe.

The boot knife I still have, and as stated, it is hard to sharpen, but once sharp it stays that way. The commando knife went missing years ago, I suspect a certain roommate but can't prove anything. It seemed well made and strong. I later had a client who killed his wife's lover with one just like it. He was able to cleanly cut the guy's head off with it, so I guess it was good for something.

The Gerber/Fiskar axe is very good and a standard part of my camping gear.

Andy
 
Gerber/Fiskars buisness practices may leave a bit to be desired, and they do purloin knife deigns. But, think about something. Fiskars sissors and knives are very good. Fiskars has been in buisness in Finland since the 1600's making fishing knives, puuko's and sissors. The Finns are'nt idiots who don't know what a good knife is.

Years ago, somebody gave me a Gerber LST. I used it as a carry knife at work in the machine shop where conditions were abusive to good knives and I did not want to tear up one of my good traditional pocket knives. The little LST proved to be a good tough knife that held up well. The steel was 440A, the same steel that Kershaw used at the time, and was accepted by the Kershaw crowd as good. I find it funny that if 440A was used on Kershaws it was okay, but if Gerber used it then it was junk.

The bad rep that Gerber gets is over the made in china or taiwan junk. The knives made in Portland like the LST, the Gator series, are good knives. They will hold a decent edge, are easy to sharpen, and if it walks off, its easy to replace. I know alot of people who are not knife nuts that get very good service from the Gerber LST's, Gators, multipliers, and ax's.

Alot of anti gerber stuff comes from knife snobs.

Another thing to think about for all the "I remember when Gerber made great knives like the FS-1" bunch. Al Mar and Pete Kershaw both quit Gerber because Pete Gerber was a stick in the mud and would not even think of bringing out any new designs, and would not modernize. Pete Gerber ran the company into the ground of financial unstability that made it possable for Fiskars to come over here and buy them out.

As for Fiskars being a bad knife company, you don't have a 400 year reputation all over Europe by making junk. And ask any woman who sews about thier Fiskars sissors.
 
I agree that gerber does make some good using knives,I really like the lst.Really most of the us made are ok,taiwan usable, but I wouldn't waste my money on the chinease.

And you can't beat fiskars scissors!
 
Back
Top