GK Chesterton on knives

Peakbagger46

Gold Member
Joined
Apr 20, 2017
Messages
1,754
Thought I’d share this quote from the great sacramental thinker GK Chesterton on finding a knife in his pocket. Really speaks to man’s primeval love of steel and weapons:

“The next thing that I took out was a pocket-knife. A pocket-knife, I need hardly say, would require a thick book full of moral meditations all to itself. A knife typifies one of the most primary of those practical origins upon which as upon low, thick pillows all our human civilisation reposes.

Metals, the mystery of the thing called iron and of the thing called steel, led me off half-dazed into a kind of dream. I saw into the intrails of dim, damp wood, where the first man among all the common stones found the strange stone. I saw a vague and violent battle, in which stone axes broke and stone knives were splintered against something shining and new in the hand of one desperate man. I heard all the hammers on all the anvils of the earth. I saw all the swords of Feudal and all the weals of Industrial war.

For the knife is only a short sword; and the pocket-knife is a secret sword. I opened it and looked at that brilliant and terrible tongue which we call a blade; and I thought that perhaps it was the symbol of the oldest of the needs of man.”
 
" for the knife is only a short sword " ?

He's equating a pocket knife with which is probably a small slipjoint with a sword or other weapon and that sounds odd to me.
I don't know about you guys but I do not look at this and think of swords or other weapons.


And not to nitpick at this famous philosophers words, but the knife came first which would make the sword only a long knife.

In the end though I think he is right about the primal connection between man and cutting tool.
 
" for the knife is only a short sword " ?

He's equating a pocket knife with which is probably a small slipjoint with a sword or other weapon and that sounds odd to me.
I don't know about you guys but I do not look at this and think of swords or other weapons.


And not to nitpick at this famous philosophers words, but the knife came first which would make the sword only a long knife.

In the end though I think he is right about the primal connection between man and cutting tool.
Maybe he foresaw the XL Espada ( Cold Steel's folding short sword) ! :p
 
"The next moment I knew that I was wrong; for the thing that came next out of my pocket was a box of matches. Then I saw fire, which is stronger even than steel, the old, fierce female thing, the thing we all love, but dare not touch."

P.S. Maybe my post belongs in MatchForums.
Especially going out into the cold &/or dark , I carry a fire-starter and flashlights . But it doesn't have the same obsessive drive as the knife need .
 
Back
Top